DREAMS: Modelling Support for Research into Engineering and Artistic Design

Apala Chakrabarti · 2026

Read DREAMS: Modelling Support for Research into Engineering and Artistic Design by Apala Chakrabarti (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10382.txt.

Introduction

Apala Chakrabarti offers practical help for design researchers drowning in diagrams. Design Research Methodology backs systematic design research through Reference Models and Impact Models. Yet building and keeping those models by hand means repeated redrawing, layout fixes, and scattered handling of assumptions, sources, and evidence. Her 2026 paper presents DREAMS, an early-stage prototype tool for those models.

Users build typed causal models with relevant elements, define signed causal links, and attach assumptions, inputs from experience, and sources straight to those links. Layout aid and search improve readability, revisability, and recall of supporting facts. A first test with four design-research users against manual practice showed cuts in creation time, revision time, repositioning effort, edge crossings, and evidence recall time. The authors read these as early evidence of potential, not full validation.

Catalog record

CREATORApala Chakrabarti
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10382

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

DREAMS: Modelling Support for Research into Engineering and Artistic Design Apala Chakrabarti Abstract Design Research Methodology (DRM) supports systematic design research through representations such as Reference Models and Impact Models. However, the practical construction and maintenance of these models often remains manual, requiring repeated redrawing, layout adjustment, and separate handling of assumptions, references, and supporting evidence. This can make DRM modelling time-consuming, visually cluttered, and difficult to revise as models increase in complexity. This paper presents DREAMS, an early-stage prototype modelling environment developed to support the creation and maintenance of DRM Reference Models and Impact Models. The tool enables users to construct typed causal models using DRM-relevant elements, define signed causal relationships, and attach assumptions, experiential inputs, and references directly to causal links. It also provides layout support and search functions to improve readability, modifiability, and retrieval of supporting information. A preliminary comparative evaluation with four DRM users was conducted against manual modelling practice. The results indicate reductions in model creation time, revision time, repositioning effort, edge crossings, and evidence retrieval time when using DREAMS. These findings are interpreted as early evidence of practical potential rather than full validation. The contribution of the paper lies in identifying requirements for DRM-aligned modelling support, presenting the design and implementation of DREAMS, and demonstrating its potential to reduce modelling effort and improve traceability in DRM-based research. † † institute: Centre of Excellence in Design, Department of Design and Manufacturing, Indian Institute of Science, Bengaluru, India, 1 Introduction Contemporary design research increasingly addresses problems shaped by interacting technical, human, organisational, and contextual factors. Such situations involve interdependencies, feedback effects, and evolving problem framings, making structured externalisation important for analysis, communication, and decision support 1 ; 2 . This is consistent with earlier accounts of design exploration as a co-evolutionary process, where problem understanding and solution development evolve together rather than proceeding in a fixed linear sequence 8 . Within design research, Design Research Methodology (DRM) provides a systematic basis for studying and representing such situations, including through Reference Models (RM) and Impact Models (IM) 1 . RM and IM support explicit representation of influential factors, causal relationships, assumptions, and outcomes 1 . However, despite their methodological value, their construction remains only weakly supported in practice. Researchers often rely on general-purpose drawing tools or manually arranged diagrams that offer flexibility, but limited support for the semantic requirements of DRM-based modelling. As models grow in size and are revised iteratively, these workflows become increasingly difficult to maintain and reorganise 2 . The limitation is not simply one of drawing capability. Existing graph visualisation and diagramming tools are primarily intended to organise and display relational structures rather than support DRM-specific modelling semantics 4 ; 5 ; 6 ; 7 . DRM-based models require support for typed elements, signed causal relations, and traceable links between relationships and their supporting assumptions, references, or observations. In most general-purpose tools, such information is difficult to embed directly within the model and is often maintained separately from the graph itself. This results in fragmented workflows and reduces the interpretability and maintainability of the model as it develops. In response, this paper presents DREAMS, an early-stage prototype modelling environment for the creation and maintenance of DRM Reference Models and Impact Models. The paper makes three contributions. First, it identifies functional requirements for a DRM-aligned modelling environment. Second, it presents the design rationale and prototype realisation of DREAMS. Third, it reports a preliminary comparative evaluation against manual modelling practice. The contribution should therefore be understood as an initial step towards dedicated support for DRM-based modelling, with early evidence of practical potential rather than full validation. 2 Background 2.1 Requirements of DRM-Based Modelling DRM provides a structured basis for representing influencing conditions, design activities, and outcomes in a systematic way 1 . In the case of Reference Models and Impact Models, modelling involves more than graphical depiction alone. The representation must capture directed causal relations, distinguish between different categories of model elements, and retain the assumptions, references, or observations that support those relations. More broadly, systematic design approaches emphasise the need to make design information, dependencies, and rationale explicit so that they can be examined, communicated, and revised during the design process 10 . Such models are also developed iteratively. As understanding of the problem and its influencing structure evolves, RM and IM representations often need to be extended, revised, and reorganised 2 . Modelling support must therefore address not only initial construction, but also continued modification and maintenance. 2.2 Graph Visualisation and Readability Graph visualisation research has established several layout strategies for improving the readability of node-link representations, including hierarchical, layered, and force-directed approaches 3 ; 4 . Tools such as Graphviz, yEd, and Gephi demonstrate the practical value of automated support for graph arrangement, including spacing, alignment, and crossing reduction in complex structures 5 ; 6 ; 7 . For causal modelling, layout readability is especially important because interpretation depends on clear tracing of directional relationships. Poorly organised visual representations can also increase cognitive effort, particularly when users must simultaneously interpret model structure, causal direction, and supporting information 9 . Prior work shows that edge crossings and poor structural organisation can significantly hinder graph comprehension 3 . Readable layout is therefore a necessary requirement for tools intended to support RM and IM construction. 2.3 Limitations of Existing Tool Support Despite these strengths, existing graph visualisation tools remain primarily general-purpose systems. They support graph construction and layout, but offer limited support for the domain-specific semantics required in DRM-based modelling. In particular, they do not adequately integrate typed factors, signed causal links, and relationship-level traceability to assumptions, references, or observations within a single modelling environment. In practice, this leads to fragmented workflows in which the graphical model is maintained separately from the supporting rationale and evidence associated with it. As models increase in scale and complexity, this separation makes them harder to interpret, revise, and retrieve information from. The central gap, therefore, is not the absence of graph drawing capability, but the lack of an integrated modelling environment aligned with the semantic and operational requirements of DRM. 3 Methodology 3.1 Requirements Derivation Functional requirements were derived from three sources: the limitations identified in the preceding literature review, the representational demands of DRM-based modelling reported in the literature, and a short survey involving 16 researchers who were using DRM in their own research. The survey was intended to examine the adequacy of current modelling practices and to identify the main practical difficulties encountered during RM and IM construction. Respondents were asked about the time typically spent creating DRM-based models, whether these models were produced by hand or using software tools, the approximate size of the models they worked with, and the main challenges encountered during model creation, revision, and maintenance. Additional questions addressed how supporting assumptions, references, and other evidential information were recorded and revisited during the modelling process. The survey was therefore used both to identify recurring difficulties and to assess the practical need for more integrated tool support. Table 1 : Summary of recurring issues reported in the DRM user survey ( n=16 ) Reported issue Respondents reporting issue Repeated manual restructuring during model revision 100% Difficulty maintaining layout readability as models grew 68.75%

Read the complete text