Revival of the Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly

Carlo Giunti, Yu-Feng Li, Rong-ping Zhang · 2026

Read Revival of the Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly by Carlo Giunti, Yu-Feng Li, Rong-ping Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10353.txt.

Introduction

Carlo Giunti, Yu-Feng Li, and Rong-ping Zhang revisit a long-running neutrino puzzle. The Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly is a deficit between measured reactor antineutrino event rates and theoretical predictions. First spotted in 2011 at 2.5 sigma, it seemed resolved by 2021, falling to about 1 sigma under newer flux calculations. Their 2026 paper applies a flux model never before used for the anomaly.

That model, a 2023 French summation calculation, is the first to include a comprehensive uncertainty budget. With it, the anomaly revives to 2.2 sigma. The authors also test the standard explanation, oscillations into a light sterile neutrino, and find tension of 3.8 sigma with gallium source experiments once solar, KATRIN, reactor spectral-ratio, and Daya Bay bounds are included. Enlarging gallium uncertainties in a global analysis cuts that tension to 1.3 sigma, suggesting underestimated systematics may explain the clash.

Catalog record

CREATORCarlo Giunti, Yu-Feng Li, Rong-ping Zhang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10353

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Revival of the Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly Carlo Giunti, Yu-Feng Li, Rong-ping Zhang Abstract The Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly (RAA) refers to the deficit observed between the average event rate measured in reactor antineutrino experiments with respect to the theoretical prediction. This anomaly was first identified in 2011 ( 2.5 ​ σ 2.5\sigma ) as a consequence of the Huber-Muller reactor antineutrino flux calculation. It was thought to be resolved in 2021 as a result of previous reactor antineutrino flux calculations, with a reduction to about 1 ​ σ 1\sigma . In this work, we present the RAA obtained with the latest reactor antineutrino flux calculation published in 2023 by a French research group, which was never used before for the calculation of the RAA. It is the first summation flux model which includes a comprehensive uncertainty budget. The result indicates a revival of the RAA at the level of 2.2 ​ σ 2.2\sigma . We also consider the usual simplest explanation of the RAA by active-sterile neutrino oscillations. We present the constraints on the oscillation parameters and we derive a tension of 3.8 ​ σ 3.8\sigma with the results of gallium source experiments (Gallium Anomaly) taking into account also the solar neutrino and KATRIN bounds, that of the combined short-baseline reactor spectral ratio measurements, and that of the Daya Bay search for a sub-eV sterile neutrino. Since the tension may be due to underestimated systematic uncertainties and the main tension is between the gallium data and the other data, we finally present the results of a global analysis with enlarged gallium uncertainties, which reduce the global tension to 1.3 ​ σ 1.3\sigma . I Introduction In this paper we present an updated analysis of the status of the short baseline Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly (RAA). We also consider the usual simplest explanation of the RAA by oscillations due to 3+1 mixing of the electron neutrino \nu_{e} with a light sterile neutrino \nu_{s} (see the reviews in Refs. Gariazzo et al. 2016 ; Giunti and Lasserre 2019 ; Boser et al. 2020 ; Diaz et al. 2020 ; Dasgupta and Kopp 2021 ). We discuss the compatibility of the RAA with the Gallium Anomaly (GA) Cadeddu et al. 2026 , the solar bound (SOL) Gonzalez-Garcia et al. 2025 , the KATRIN bound Acharya et al. 2025 , the combined bound of the DANSS Danilov 2022 , NEOS+RENO Atif et al. 2022 , PROSPECT Andriamirado et al. 2025 , STEREO Almazan et al. 2023 reactor spectral ratio measurements (SPE) and that of the Daya Bay search for a sub-eV sterile neutrino An et al. 2024 (DB). For recent reviews of the RAA and GA see Refs. Zhang et al. 2024 ; Elliott et al. 2024 . We do not consider the other short baseline neutrino anomalies which involve the muon neutrino: the LSND anomaly and the MiniBooNE anomaly (see the reviews in Refs. Gariazzo et al. 2016 ; Giunti and Lasserre 2019 ; Boser et al. 2020 ; Diaz et al. 2020 ; Dasgupta and Kopp 2021 ). In experiments with commercial reactors the \bar{\nu}_{e} flux is produced by the \beta decays of the fission products of {}^{235}\text{U} , {}^{238}\text{U} , {}^{239}\text{Pu} , and {}^{241}\text{Pu} with the respective typical fractions of about 0.55, 0.09, 0.30, and 0.06. In experiments with research reactors the \bar{\nu}_{e} flux is produced only by the \beta decays of the fission products of {}^{235}\text{U} . Since the RAA is a deficit of the number of measured \bar{\nu}_{e} events with respect to the calculated number, the RAA depends mainly on the calculated {}^{235}\text{U} \bar{\nu}_{e} flux. Figure 1: Graphical representation of the theoretical IBD yields in Tab. 3 in Appendix A.1 . The reactor antineutrino fluxes have been calculated with two methods (see the reviews in Refs. Huber 2016 ; Hayes and Vogel 2016 ; Zhang et al. 2024 ): the summation method which uses the nuclear databases, and the conversion method in which the neutrino spectra are derived from the measured electron spectra of the same fission nucleus. The RAA ( 2.5\sigma anomaly) was discovered in 2011 Mention et al. 2011 as a consequence of the calculations of the reactor antineutrino fluxes in the Huber-Muller (HM) model Mueller et al. 2011 ; Huber 2011 . In the HM model the {}^{235}\text{U} , {}^{239}\text{Pu} , and {}^{241}\text{Pu} fluxes are those calculated by Huber Huber 2011 with the conversion method, using the experimental cumulative \beta spectra measured at ILL Feilitzsch et al. 1982 ; Schreckenbach et al. 1985 . The {}^{238}\text{U} flux is that calculated by Mueller et al. Mueller et al. 2011 with the summation method. It has been confirmed with the conversion method using the first and only measurement of the \beta spectrum of {}^{238}\text{U} Haag et al. 2014 . In 2019 Estienne, Fallot et al (EF) Estienne et al. 2019 presented a new summation method calculation of the reactor antineutrino fluxes which gave a smaller value for the main {}^{235}\text{U} flux, thus relieving the RAA. In 2021, Kopeikin, Skorokhvatov, and Titov of the Kurchatov Institute (KI) Kopeikin et al. 2021 measured the cumulative \beta spectra of {}^{235}\text{U} and {}^{239}\text{Pu} and found that the ratio of the two fluxes is 1.054\pm 0.002 smaller than that of the ILL Feilitzsch et al. 1982 ; Schreckenbach et al. 1985 measurement on which the HM is based. Assuming that the HM {}^{239}\text{Pu} antineutrino flux is correct, the KI group revised the Huber Huber 2011 conversion calculation and obtained a smaller {}^{235}\text{U} flux, thus relieving the RAA. A subsequent analysis Giunti et al. 2022a of the experimental reactor antineutrino data found that the RAA is dramatically reduced assuming the EF or KI fluxes: 1.2\sigma for EF and 1.1\sigma for KI. This suggested a potential resolution of the RAA. In this article we consider the accurate calculation of the reactor antineutrino fluxes with the summation method published in 2023 Perisse et al. 2023 , which was never used before for the calculation of the RAA. We label this calculation as CEA, from the affiliations of the authors. In Section II , we discuss the effects of the CEA fluxes on the RAA. In Section III we consider the explanation of the CEA-RAA in terms of 3+1 \nu_{e} - \nu_{s} oscillations, where \nu_{s} is a light sterile neutrino (see the reviews in Refs. Gariazzo et al. 2016 ; Giunti and Lasserre 2019 ; Boser et al. 2020 ; Diaz et al. 2020 ; Dasgupta and Kopp 2021 ). We emphasize that active-sterile neutrino oscillations is the only known explanation of the short baseline anomalies which is not ad-hoc. It is a general possibility which can be tested in many experiments and was not invented for a specific anomaly. The existence of sterile neutrinos was proposed many years ago (see the review in Ref. Bilenky and Petcov 1987 ), independently of any anomaly. Hence it is worth to insist on the active-sterile neutrino oscillation explanation of the short-baseline neutrino data in spite of the tensions between the existing data in this scenario Coloma et al. 2021 ; Giunti et al. 2022a ; Berryman et al. 2022 ; Giunti et al. 2022b ; Brdar et al. 2023 ; Giunti and Ternes 2024 ; Gonzalez-Garcia et al. 2025 ; Rodrigues

Read the complete text