Stellar Age Compression Reshapes Interpretations of the Milky Way Thick-Disk Formation History
Zhipeng Zhang · 2026
Read Stellar Age Compression Reshapes Interpretations of the Milky Way Thick-Disk Formation History by Zhipeng Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10220.txt.
Introduction
Zhang, writing alone, argues stellar age compression reshapes the thick-disk story. The thick disk's formation timescale is debated in Galactic study. The age-metallicity relation, formation timescale and gradients read as rapid bursty formation. But stellar ages are never seen, so inferred ages may carry compression.
Using the same sample and matching with two age scales, spectroscopic astroNN and asteroseismic APOKASC-3 ages, the paper checks marks. Under seismic anchoring, rapid-formation signals weaken. The age-metallicity slope flattens from about minus three to minus two per dex. Formation timescale widens from about three to about three and a half gigayears, and formation age shifts from about nine to six. Reverse tests show added noise only broadens ages and cannot match it. A squeezing map with lambda below one matches a narrower spread, a steeper link and rapid-formation-like marks.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhipeng Zhang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10220
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Stellar Age Compression Reshapes Interpretations of the Milky Way Thick-Disk Formation History Zhipeng Zhang Abstract The formation timescale of the Milky Way thick disk is one of the central debates in Galactic archaeology. The age–metallicity relation (AMR), formation timescale, and chemical evolution gradients are frequently used to infer a rapid assembly, short-timescale enrichment, and bursty formation history of the thick disk. However, stellar ages are not directly observable, introducing the potential risk that inferred ages may harbor a systematic compression tied to observational quality. In this paper, we use the same stellar sample and identical physical covariate matching conditions, but two independent age scales—spectroscopic inferred ages (astroNN) and asteroseismic ages (APOKASC-3)—to compare the observable signatures of the thick-disk formation history. We find that several key observables previously supporting a rapid thick-disk formation are systematically weakened under seismic anchoring: the AMR slope flattens from − 3.29 -3.29 to − 1.86 Gyr dex − 1 -1.86\,\mathrm{Gyr\,dex^{-1}} ( Δ a = + 1.43 \Delta a=+1.43 ), the formation timescale widens from 3.04 3.04 to 3.55 Gyr 3.55\,\mathrm{Gyr} , and the peak formation age shifts from 9.1 9.1 to 6.0 Gyr 6.0\,\mathrm{Gyr} . Through transport inversion experiments, we further show that additive noise can only broaden the age distribution and cannot reproduce the above pattern, whereas a compressive transport map ( λ < 1 \lambda<1 ) simultaneously reproduces a narrower age distribution, a steeper AMR, and rapid-formation-like observables. This result indicates that the compression transformation itself is sufficient to generate rapid-formation-friendly observables without requiring an intrinsically bursty formation history. Our findings reveal that statistical interpretations of the Milky Way formation history may depend sensitively on the stellar age definition itself. Corresponding author: Zhipeng Zhang ( [email protected] ) 1 Introduction The formation timescale of the Milky Way thick disk is a key problem for distinguishing different disk evolution scenarios. The age–metallicity relation (AMR) is widely used to infer the chemical enrichment rate, early enrichment history, and inside-out growth mode of the disk [ 1 ] . Some studies, based on spectroscopically inferred ages, propose that the thick disk formed rapidly within \sim 1\,\mathrm{Gyr} , exhibiting a bursty assembly mode supporting short-timescale chemical enrichment [ 2 , 3 ] , while others argue for a more extended assembly [ 4 ] . This dispute directly relates to our fundamental understanding of the early evolutionary history of the Milky Way. Stellar ages are not directly observable [ 5 ] . Current methods estimate ages indirectly through spectroscopy, photometry, parallaxes, and data-driven pipelines (e.g., astroNN; [ 6 ] ); therefore, observational conditions (signal-to-noise ratio, parallax precision) may influence the final results through the inference process. To obtain an independent benchmark, we introduce APOKASC-3 asteroseismic ages [ 7 ] , whose systematic errors arise from stellar oscillation frequencies and are thus distinct from those of spectroscopic inference, serving as a relatively independent external anchoring scale. Recent studies indicate that spectroscopically inferred ages may exhibit a systematic compression dependent on observational quality: stars with lower signal-to-noise ratios or poorer parallax precision tend to have inferred ages that shrink toward the sample mean. If such a compression effect exists, it will directly affect population statistics such as the width of the age distribution, the location of the peak, and the AMR slope, thereby potentially altering the physical interpretation of the thick-disk formation history. The core question of this paper is not “whether a bias exists,” but rather: Do the key observables of the Milky Way formation history themselves depend on the age definition? Using an identical stellar sample and the same physical covariate matching, we change only the age scale (inferred vs. seismic) and systematically compare diagnostic quantities including the AMR slope, formation timescale, peak formation age, and old-star fraction. Through transport inversion experiments, we distinguish the compression effect from additive noise, thus revealing how an observationally driven compression reshapes the interpretation of the Milky Way formation history. 2 Data and Methods 2.1 Data and Independent Age Scales The analysis sample is drawn from APOGEE spectroscopic survey data combined with Gaia parallaxes, together with astroNN inferred ages [ 6 , 8 ] and APOKASC-3 asteroseismic ages [ 7 ] . The two age scales have different systematic error origins: • Inferred ages (astroNN) : based on spectroscopy, photometry, and parallaxes, obtained through neural-network training [ 6 ] , and sensitive to observational quality; • Seismic ages (APOKASC-3) : based on stellar oscillation frequencies [ 7 , 9 ] , with a different systematic error budget, serving as an external anchoring scale rather than absolute truth. We apply basic quality cuts: signal-to-noise ratio \mathrm{SNR}>50 , effective temperature 4000<T_{\mathrm{eff}}<5500\,\mathrm{K} , surface gravity 2.0<\log g<3.5 , and parallax precision \varpi/\sigma_{\varpi}>5 . 2.2 Coarsened Exact Matching: Ensuring Same-Sample Comparisons To exclude the influence of sample composition differences, we employ coarsened exact matching (CEM; [ 10 ] ) to construct control samples in a five-dimensional physical covariate space: T_{\mathrm{eff}} , \log g , [\mathrm{Fe/H}] , [\alpha/\mathrm{Fe}] , distance, and Galactic coordinates (R,Z) . During the matching process, age information is excluded by construction , ensuring that we compare the behavior of the same stars under different age definitions, rather than differences between distinct samples. 2.3 Definition of the Compressive Transformation We introduce a linear transport/compression operator to describe the systematic relationship between inferred and seismic ages: a_{\text{infer}}=\alpha+\lambda\cdot a_{\text{seismo}}+\epsilon, (1) where \lambda is the compression coefficient. When \lambda=1 , the two age scales differ only by an additive offset; when \lambda<1 , the inferred ages systematically compress the age span—old stars are estimated younger, and young stars older—directly reducing the overall variance of the age distribution. By contrast, an additive noise model a_{\text{noisy}}=a_{\text{truth}}+\eta satisfies \mathrm{Var}(X+\eta)\geq\mathrm{Var}(X) , and can only broaden the distribution, not compress it. This property provides the theoretical closure for the subsequent transport inversion experiments. The key insight is: only the compressive transformation can simultaneously narrow the age distribution and steepen the AMR . 2.4 Formation-History Diagnostics To quantify the impact on the interpretation of the Milky Way formation history, we define the following diagnostics and their astrophysical interpretations: Table 1 : Formation-history diagnostics and their astrophysical interpretations. Diagnostic Astrophysical interpretation Narrow age distribution (small \Delta t ) Rapid assembly Old-dominated peak age Early-dominated buildup Steep negative AMR slope Rapid enrichment Early cumulative formation fraction (CFF) Bursty formation history 2.5 Significance Estimation The statistical significance of all differences is estimated via bootstrap resampling ( N=10^{4} ), with the significance metric defined as z=\Delta/\sigma_{\Delta} . 3 Results 3.1 Observationally Dependent Compression: Evidence for Compression We first examine the distribution of the age difference between inferred and seismic ages in the observational parameter space. Figure 1 shows that in the two-dimensional bins of \mathrm{SNR} and \varpi/\sigma_{\varpi} , the inferred bias \Delta=a_{\text{infer}}-a_{\text{seismo}} exhibits a pronounced structured pattern: in low-observational-quality regimes, the bias amplitude reaches \sim 0.5 – 1\,\mathrm{Gyr} . Figure 2 further decomposes this significance, showing that high- S_{\text{truth}} regions are primarily driven by systematic bias rather than by statistical uncertainty or small sample size artifacts. These observations demonstrate that the inferred bias is not random noise but a structured function of the observing conditions—indicating that compression indeed exists. We next test whether such compression can alter the observed features of the Milky