Numerical estimation of the capture ability of Neptunian mean motion resonances
Hailiang Li, Li-Yong Zhou ,, Xiaoping Zhang · 2026
Read Numerical estimation of the capture ability of Neptunian mean motion resonances by Hailiang Li, Li-Yong Zhou ,, Xiaoping Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-09876.txt.
Introduction
Li and two colleagues ran numerical simulations to gauge how well Neptunian mean motion resonances trap small bodies while Neptune moves outward. Resonant trans-Neptunian groups preserve clues to the early migratory past of the Solar System, so trap rates help pin down migration settings and the first planetesimal disk. The study used a flat model of outer resonances.
For a set p:q resonance, capture needs eccentricity past a cutoff e_min. That cutoff rises with faster migration, greater orbit distance, and higher order. The 1:q cases show a notably higher e_min from their own dynamics. Once eccentricity suffices, trap rates barely hinge on migration rate. They hinge mainly on p and heliocentric distance, falling exponentially as either grows. Trap counts from 1:2 out to about 1:4 track what is seen, but far regions fall short, hinting other causes like resonant sticking matter there.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hailiang Li, Li-Yong Zhou ,, Xiaoping Zhang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.09876
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Numerical estimation of the capture ability of Neptunian mean motion resonances Hailiang Li, Li-Yong Zhou ,, Xiaoping Zhang Abstract Resonant populations of trans-Neptunian objects serve as crucial dynamical archives for unraveling the early migratory history of the Solar System. A quantitative assessment of the capture efficiency into various mean motion resonances (MMRs) during migration is essential for understanding the origins of these populations, constraining migration parameters, and reconstructing of the primordial planetesimal disk. Using numerical simulations, this study systematically investigates the capture capability of exterior MMRs during Neptune’s outward migration in a planar model. For a specific p p : q q MMR, the small bodies can be captured only when their eccentricities surpass a certain threshold, e m i n e_{min} , which increases with faster migration rates, greater distances of MMRs, and higher resonance orders. We also find that 1: q q -type MMRs exhibit notably higher e m i n e_{min} due to their unique dynamical structure. On the other hand, as long as a particle’s eccentricity is suitable, its capture efficiency shows little dependence on the migration rate; instead, it mainly depends on the p p value and heliocentric distance, decaying exponentially as either parameter increases. Based on our simulation results, we derive for the first time a simple empirical expression to calculate e m i n e_{min} and the capture efficiency. From beyond the 1:2 MMR out to approximately the 1:4 MMR, the theoretically predicted capture numbers follow a trend that resembles what is seen in observations, suggesting that migration capture could be the primary source of resonant populations in these regions. However, in more distant regions, the theoretical predictions fall significantly short of observational estimates, implying that other mechanisms (e.g., resonant sticking) might be necessary. This research provides a systematic quantitative framework for understanding capture into Neptunian MMRs during migration. Future integrations of more comprehensive observational data will facilitate a more precise reconstruction of the Solar System’s early dynamical evolution. 1 Introduction Within the context of planetary migration, the distribution patterns of the vast majority of trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs) can now be explained ( 19 ; 31 , e.g.,) . Among these, Neptune’s mean motion resonances (MMRs) contain significant information about the early Solar System. As more TNOs are discovered, the insights embedded within Neptune’s MMRs, particularly those related to planetary migration, can be further elucidated. Many mechanisms can influence both the number and distribution of small bodies within resonance belts. For instance, numerous studies have compared the stability of different MMRs ( 30 ; 28 ; 49 ; 48 ; 21 , e.g.,) . This stability reflects the likelihood of objects escaping from MMRs after being captured. Other fundamental factors include the capture ability and capture locations of MMRs, which result in the distinct population sizes retained by different MMRs since the early Solar System. A substantial number of prior studies have investigated the physical process of resonant capture. Early work often treated it as an adiabatic process, which required migration to be sufficiently slow, with a timescale that is significantly longer than the libration period of the resonant angle. Analytical methods have derived capture probabilities under idealized models ( 42 ; 56 ; 13 ; 5 ; 33 , e.g.,) . A key conclusion of adiabatic capture theory is that when migration is sufficiently slow and the particle’s eccentricity is below a certain threshold, capture is inevitable. Conversely, if the particle’s eccentricity exceeds this threshold, the capture probability decreases progressively ( 5 ) . 55 further extended the study to higher migration rates, focusing on several specific MMRs and assuming a dynamically cold planetesimal disk. This work demonstrated that the capture probability increases with planetary mass and decreases with migration rates. Building on this, subsequent work employed Hamiltonian models to conduct a detailed exploration of first- and second-order MMRs, further investigating how different initial eccentricities of small bodies affect capture efficiency ( 45 ; 35 ) . These studies also systematically examined issues such as the interference of nearby resonant terms, the shifting of resonant centers during migration, the changes in eccentricity of particles upon failed capture, and the amplitude distribution of captured particles. With advancements in technology and observations, resonant TNOs have been discovered in dozens of Neptunian MMRs, extending out to hundreds of astronomical units. Several studies have provided estimates of the number of objects within these resonant belts ( 11 ; 52 ; 8 , e.g.,) . Through direct numerical simulations within a planar model, we aim to test the ability of different Neptunian MMRs to capture bodies, quantify key parameters (e.g., the eccentricity threshold and probability for capture), and extend this analysis to higher order MMRs. Furthermore, we compare the predicted number of captured bodies in each MMR from our model with observational resonant populations, aiming to constrain the early dynamical evolution of the Solar System. The remaining sections of this paper are organized as follows. In Section 2, we describe the numerical methods, the initial conditions, and the approach used to identify resonant objects. In Section 3, we analyze the simulation results, evaluate the capture capabilities of MMRs between 30 au to 80 au, carry out a detailed individual analysis of 1: q MMRs, and provide a comparison with observational estimates. Finally, we conclude with a summary and discussion. 2 Methods 2.1 Initial conditions In this study, we employed a planar restricted three-body model consisting of the Sun, Neptune, and massless small bodies. Although other giant planets may significantly alter Neptune’s migration ( 50 ; 38 , e.g.,) and continue to affect the stability of MMRs after migration ends ( 21 ; 12 , e.g.,) , this paper focuses solely on the physical process of capturing small bodies, which is predominantly governed by Neptune itself. For a given p : q MMR (where p ¡ q ), its strength primarily depends on the resonance order k=q-p , with lower order MMRs generally exhibiting a greater strength. The nominal location of the MMR is given by a_{N}\times(\frac{q}{p})^{2/3} , where a_{N} denotes Neptune’s semimajor axis. Under the simplified model considered in this paper, the resonant angle for an MMR can be expressed as \phi=q\lambda-p\lambda_{N}-(q-p)\varpi , where \lambda and \lambda_{N} , respectively, represent the mean longitude of the small body and Neptune, while \varpi represents the longitude of perihelion of the small body. In each simulation, we applied an additional force in the direction of Neptune’s velocity, making Neptune migrate at a constant rate of \dot{a}_{N} . During this process, its eccentricity remains small and it can be considered on a circular orbit. Numerous previous studies have examined the influence of Neptune’s migration on resonance capture ( 7 ; 22 ; 14 ; 20 , e.g.,) . While there is no consensus yet on the precise details of Neptune’s migration, it is generally believed that during the early Solar System, a phase known as the giant planet instability occurred, during which the giant planets underwent dramatic orbital changes (see 41 , for a review) . Therefore, we explored a wide range of \dot{a}_{N} values (from 0.01 au/Myr to 10 au/Myr), allowing each set of simulations to analogously represent MMR capture scenarios at different migration