Governing AI-Assisted Security Operations: A Design Science Framework for Operational Decision Support
Elyson A. De La Cruz, Rishikesh Sahay, Md Rasel Al Mamun · 2026
Read Governing AI-Assisted Security Operations: A Design Science Framework for Operational Decision Support by Elyson A. De La Cruz, Rishikesh Sahay, Md Rasel Al Mamun (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-09534.txt.
Introduction
De La Cruz and two colleagues offer a management frame for bringing generative AI into security work without losing control. Security teams blend private data feeds, expert judgment, code stores, cloud tools, and choices where evidence matters. Leaders must decide how to add language models, retrieval, and coding agents to such high risk work. The paper argues AI aided choice support should first be run as a governed skill, not scaled as raw automation.
Using Kusto Query Language on Azure as a bounded test case, the authors show read only queries still carry risk. Wide scans, private field leaks, cost blowouts, stale tips, and false readings can all harm choices. Their governed query broker splits AI planning from action. It uses grounded retrieval, set templates, policy checks, read only links, and clear audit trails, with review board gates before scale up.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Elyson A. De La Cruz, Rishikesh Sahay, Md Rasel Al Mamun |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 78 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.09534
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Governing AI-Assisted Security Operations: A Design Science Framework for Operational Decision Support Elyson A. De La Cruz, Rishikesh Sahay, Md Rasel Al Mamun Abstract Engineering managers increasingly must decide how to introduce generative artificial intelligence (AI), retrieval-augmented generation, and coding agents into high-risk operational functions without weakening accountability, privacy, cost discipline, or auditability. The central message of this study is that AI-assisted operational decision support should be managed as a governed engineering capability before it is scaled as automation. Security operations centers (SOCs) provide a suitable setting because they combine privileged telemetry, specialist expertise, software repositories, cloud services, and evidence-sensitive decisions. This study uses Kusto Query Language (KQL) and Microsoft Azure security capabilities as a bounded technical instantiation of that broader engineering management problem. KQL is read-only in ordinary query use, but read-only does not mean risk-free: AI-assisted queries can still create privacy, cost, performance, schema-validity, and decision-quality risks through broad scans, sensitive-field exposure, stale intelligence, and misleading interpretations. Using design science research, the study develops a governed AI query-broker artifact that separates AI planning from operational execution through schema-grounded retrieval, approved templates, policy validation, read-only adapters, normalized outputs, auditable agent traces, and engineering review board gates. The contribution is not a new KQL technique, security product, or detection algorithm. Rather, the study contributes a management framework for governing AI-assisted operational decision support in high-risk digital infrastructure by specifying design propositions, role accountability, maturity stages, quality gates, evaluation criteria, and evidence boundaries. Keywords: AI governance, cybersecurity management, design science research, engineering management, operational decision support, security operations center, technology adoption. Managerial Relevance Statement Security executives and engineering managers face a practical dilemma: AI can accelerate operational analysis and detection engineering, but ungoverned AI use can create unacceptable risk in privileged telemetry environments. The managerial value of this study is a decision framework for moving AI assistance from informal experimentation to governed operational capability. KQL is used only as the illustrative technical setting: it is read-only in ordinary query use, but broad scans, sensitive-field exposure, cost overruns, invalid schemas, and misleading interpretations can still harm operations and decision quality. The proposed broker converts AI assistance into a governed capability by requiring schema grounding, approved templates, read-only execution, time and row limits, human approval for sensitive hunts, auditable traces, and engineering review board gates. Managers can use the framework to assign operating roles, define maturity stages, establish CI/CD quality gates, monitor cost and reliability, and decide when a proof of concept is ready for shadow-mode or production use. Its intended impact is safer, more auditable, and more scalable AI adoption in high-risk engineering work. 1 Introduction Engineering managers increasingly face a new adoption problem: generative artificial intelligence (AI), retrieval-augmented generation, and coding agents can accelerate technical work, but they also blur accountability when they propose actions, generate code-like artifacts, summarize evidence, or invoke tools inside high-risk operating environments. Security operations centers (SOCs) are a particularly useful setting for this problem because they combine cloud platforms, software repositories, telemetry pipelines, identity systems, threat-intelligence feeds, and human judgment in evidence-sensitive workflows. Incident-response guidance emphasizes preparation, detection, analysis, communication, recovery, and continuous improvement rather than detection tooling alone [ 39 ] . The resulting challenge is not simply whether an AI system can generate a useful technical artifact. It is whether an organization can govern how that artifact is proposed, validated, approved, executed, audited, and improved. This study uses Kusto Query Language (KQL) and Microsoft Azure security capabilities as the empirical and technical instantiation because they make the governance problem observable in a real enterprise-scale environment. Microsoft describes Kusto queries as read-only requests that process data and return results, while distinguishing them from management commands [ 2 ] . Microsoft Graph provides the security/runHuntingQuery method for advanced hunting in Microsoft Defender XDR and identifies ThreatHunting.Read.All as the relevant permission for the Graph advanced-hunting API [ 1 ] . Defender XDR advanced hunting and Microsoft Sentinel support cross-source investigation across endpoint, identity, email, cloud, and SIEM data sources [ 3 ] . Microsoft Sentinel analytics, Sentinel data lake, and Azure Data Explorer add additional query, retention, and analytics contexts [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . These characteristics make the setting suitable for engineering management research because it exposes real choices about permissions, schemas, cloud cost, retention, auditability, role assignment, and evidence quality. KQL’s read-only nature is important but insufficient as a governance argument. It lowers the blast radius compared with response automation that isolates devices, disables accounts, deletes messages, or changes cloud configurations. It does not eliminate operational risk. AI-generated read-only queries can still reference unavailable tables, omit required time filters, perform excessive scans, expose sensitive fields, increase cloud or query cost, misuse weak threat intelligence, or produce misleading interpretations. Telemetry fields such as command lines, URLs, filenames, and email subjects may also contain attacker-controlled text that should be treated as evidence rather than instructions. The study therefore uses KQL as a bounded technical instantiation of a broader management problem: governing AI-assisted operational decision support in high-risk digital infrastructure. The study addresses the following research question: How can engineering managers govern AI-assisted operational decision support in security operations while preserving technical validity, auditability, analyst accountability, privacy, cost discipline, and operational control? This question aligns with IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management because it concerns technology adoption, engineering governance, organizational readiness, and risk-controlled implementation of an emerging capability. The study does not position KQL syntax, a detection rule, or a Microsoft-specific product alternative as the primary contribution. Instead, it studies the management architecture required to convert AI assistance from informal experimentation into an accountable socio-technical capability. Design science research (DSR) provides the methodological foundation because the study creates and evaluates an artifact intended to improve an organizational capability [ 7 , 8 ] . The artifact is a governed AI query broker instantiated in KQL-based threat hunting. It allows AI systems to plan, explain, and propose operational analyses, but it requires executable queries and coding-agent changes to pass through schema grounding, template constraints, policy validation, source-specific adapters, CI/CD gates, human approval where needed, and audit logging. The article makes four contributions. First, it reframes AI-assisted security operations as an engineering management problem involving governance, risk, cost, accountability, adoption readiness, and evidence maturity. Second, it contributes a DSR artifact that integrates schema-grounded AI planning, brokered read-only execution, agentic tool boundaries, and engineering review board (ERB) promotion gates. Third, it provides design propositions, requirements traceability, operating roles, maturity stages, and quality gates that extend the body of knowledge on governed AI adoption in technical functions. Fourth, it proposes an evaluation protocol that separates package-level engineering validation from stronger claims requiring historical replay, purple-team exercises, shadow-mode SOC use, and limited production deployment. The message for the IEEE TEM community is direct: the value and impact of AI in high-risk engineering work depend less on model fluency than on accountable operating models, evidence gates, and managerial control. 2 Study Positioning and Research Objectives The study is positioned as an engineering management contribution rather than as a purely technical cybersecurity implementation. The empirical context is Microsoft-oriented threat hunting, but the management problem is broader: organizations increasingly adopt AI tools inside technical functions that already depend on privileged access, specialist expertise, software