Probing In-Solid Proton Energy Distributions in Laser-Driven Fusion via Nuclear Activation Diagnostics

Hiroki Matsubara, Ryunosuke Takizawa, Yuga Karaki, Ryuya Yamada, Tomoyuki Johzaki, Rinya Akematsu, Ryo Omura, Kai Kimura, Fuka Nikaido, Toshiharu Yasui, Takumi Minami, Law King Fai Farley, Akifumi Yogo, Yuki Abe, Yasuhiro Kuramitsu, Yuji Fukuda, Takehito Hayakawa, Masato Kanasaki, Koichi Honda, Kohei Yamanoi, Keisuke Takahashi, Koji Tsubakimoto, Yu Yamamoto, Hideyuki Maruta, Atsushi Sunahara, Seita Iizuka, Shuji Nakamura, Shinsuke Fujioka · 2026

Read Probing In-Solid Proton Energy Distributions in Laser-Driven Fusion via Nuclear Activation Diagnostics by Hiroki Matsubara, Ryunosuke Takizawa, Yuga Karaki, Ryuya Yamada, Tomoyuki Johzaki, Rinya Akematsu, Ryo Omura, Kai Kimura, Fuka Nikaido, Toshiharu Yasui, Takumi Minami, Law King Fai Farley, Akifumi Yogo, Yuki Abe, Yasuhiro Kuramitsu, Yuji Fukuda, Takehito Hayakawa, Masato Kanasaki, Koichi Honda, Kohei Yamanoi, Keisuke Takahashi, Koji Tsubakimoto, Yu Yamamoto, Hideyuki Maruta, Atsushi Sunahara, Seita Iizuka, Shuji Nakamura, Shinsuke Fujioka (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-09191.txt.

Introduction

Hiroki Matsubara, Ryunosuke Takizawa, and twenty-six other co-authors tackle a hidden quantity in laser-driven fusion: how much energy the fast protons carry while still inside a solid target. That spread of energies drives nuclear reactions and heat deposit, yet normal detectors only see ions that escape. Strong electric and magnetic fields in the plasma also disturb their readings. Their 2026 paper uses reactions inside the target itself as a probe.

By measuring the amounts of two products made by proton hits on boron, the team rebuilds the energy spread of protons inside the solid. A side analysis also gives the total count of a key boron-proton fusion reaction, with uncertainty carried through. The method opens a direct window on proton behavior that drives these fusion tests.

Catalog record

CREATORHiroki Matsubara, Ryunosuke Takizawa, Yuga Karaki, Ryuya Yamada, Tomoyuki Johzaki, Rinya Akematsu, Ryo Omura, Kai Kimura, Fuka Nikaido, Toshiharu Yasui, Takumi Minami, Law King Fai Farley, Akifumi Yogo, Yuki Abe, Yasuhiro Kuramitsu, Yuji Fukuda, Takehito Hayakawa, Masato Kanasaki, Koichi Honda, Kohei Yamanoi, Keisuke Takahashi, Koji Tsubakimoto, Yu Yamamoto, Hideyuki Maruta, Atsushi Sunahara, Seita Iizuka, Shuji Nakamura, Shinsuke Fujioka
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.09191

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Probing In-Solid Proton Energy Distributions in Laser-Driven Fusion via Nuclear Activation Diagnostics Hiroki Matsubara, Ryunosuke Takizawa, Yuga Karaki, Ryuya Yamada, Tomoyuki Johzaki, Rinya Akematsu, Ryo Omura, Kai Kimura, Fuka Nikaido, Toshiharu Yasui, Takumi Minami, Law King Fai Farley, Akifumi Yogo, Yuki Abe, Yasuhiro Kuramitsu, Yuji Fukuda, Takehito Hayakawa, Masato Kanasaki, Koichi Honda, Kohei Yamanoi, Keisuke Takahashi, Koji Tsubakimoto, Yu Yamamoto, Hideyuki Maruta, Atsushi Sunahara, Seita Iizuka, Shuji Nakamura, Shinsuke Fujioka Abstract The energy distribution of energetic protons inside a solid target is a key quantity governing nuclear reaction yields and energy deposition in high-intensity laser-driven fusion, including nonthermal proton–boron (p–B) schemes and proton fast ignition. Yet it has remained inaccessible to conventional particle diagnostics, which detect only ions escaping the target and are perturbed by intense plasma electromagnetic fields. Here we establish a quantitative diagnostic that uses nuclear activation reactions occurring within the target itself as an internal probe of the in-solid proton energy distribution. Applied to laser-driven p–B fusion experiments on the kJ-class laser, the method reconstructs an exponential-equivalent in-solid proton energy distribution from the absolute yields of C 11 {}^{11}\mathrm{C} and Be 7 {}^{7}\mathrm{Be} produced via B 11 ​ ( p , n ) 11 ​ C \mathrm{{}^{11}B(p,n)^{11}C} and B 10 ​ ( p , α ) 7 ​ Be \mathrm{{}^{10}B(p,\alpha)^{7}Be} , and yields the absolute number of B 11 ​ ( p , 2 ​ α ) 4 ​ He \mathrm{{}^{11}B(p,2\alpha)^{4}He} reactions through a side-channel analysis with propagated cross-section uncertainties. This work opens a quantitative window onto the in-solid proton dynamics that drive nuclear reactions in laser-driven fusion experiments. \usephysicsmodule ab \usephysicsmodule ab.braket \usephysicsmodule diagmat \usephysicsmodule nabla.legacy \usephysicsmodule [showleft=2,showtop=2]xmat A central problem common to laser-driven inertial fusion, fast ignition, laboratory astrophysics, and high-intensity laser-driven nuclear physics is the determination of the energy distribution of energetic ions inside a dense medium. This in-solid distribution governs both the nuclear reaction yield and the spatial profile of energy deposition, and it is fundamentally distinct from that of externally detected ions escaping the target. The recent achievement of ignition at the National Ignition Facility 3 has intensified efforts toward practical fusion power 22 ; 19 and revived interest in nonthermal schemes 10 ; 28 ; 40 ; 12 ; 35 based on the proton–boron reaction, \mathrm{{}^{11}B(p,2\alpha)^{4}He} . These schemes, which exploit the low neutron yield and aneutronic character of p–B fusion 29 , depend critically on what fraction of the laser energy is deposited as fast protons inside the boron target—a question that current diagnostics cannot answer directly. Conventional charged-particle diagnostics, such as the Thomson parabola (TP) ion energy analyzer and radiochromic film stacks 14 ; 26 ; 39 ; 1 , sample only the small fraction of ions that escape the target. The escaping distribution is further distorted by sheath electric fields, self-generated megagauss magnetic fields 33 , and self-absorption, none of which can be deconvolved without strong model assumptions. Diagnostics based on direct detection of the emitted \alpha particles using solid-state track detectors 15 ; 16 ; 48 ; 6 ; 17 are similarly compromised: track-size ambiguity between \alpha particles and contaminant heavy ions 8 and the field-induced redirection of emitted \alpha particles introduce systematic uncertainties that are difficult to bound. As a result, the in-solid proton energy distribution—the very quantity that determines the fusion yield—has remained largely inaccessible. Here we develop and demonstrate a quantitative diagnostic that turns the target itself into a detector. Energetic protons traversing the boron target trigger the side channels \mathrm{{}^{11}B(p,n)^{11}C} and \mathrm{{}^{10}B(p,\alpha)^{7}Be} , whose cross sections peak in different energy bands as shown in Fig. 1 . The absolute yields of the radioactive products {}^{11}\mathrm{C} and {}^{7}\mathrm{Be} therefore encode different moments of the proton energy distribution integrated along its path through the target. Measuring these yields by \gamma -ray spectroscopy of target debris collected after each shot and by solving the coupled proton-transport and nuclear-reaction problem, we reconstruct the in-solid proton energy distribution from internal nuclear signatures. The same reconstruction yields the absolute number of \mathrm{{}^{11}B(p,2\alpha)^{4}He} reactions, providing a route to the fusion yield that is independent of direct \alpha -particle detection and free from the species-identification ambiguities intrinsic to track-detector methods. We apply this diagnostic to the kJ-class laser in two complementary geometries: a pitcher–catcher configuration where the activation result can be cross-checked against a conventional TP, and an in-target configuration where it cannot. Agreement in the former validates the method, while in the latter the diagnostic remains operational in a regime inaccessible to external particle analyzers. The conceptual framework—using selected nuclear side channels as built-in energy analyzers—is broadly applicable to laser-driven nuclear physics, including energy-deposition diagnostics for proton fast ignition 43 ; 18 , laboratory nuclear astrophysics, and high-intensity ion-beam material science. An extended discussion of the physical motivation for laser-driven p–B fusion and the systematic limitations of existing diagnostics is provided in Appendix A. The cross sections of the three p–B reaction channels relevant to this work are shown in Fig. 1 . Across the analysis range ( E_{\mathrm{cm}}=0.01 – 30 MeV), uncertainties in these cross sections propagate directly to the proton-distribution parameters (T_{0},A_{0}) inferred from the activation analysis. We therefore evaluate each cross section as the posterior of a Bayesian model for \log\sigma(E) (Appendix B) so that these uncertainties enter the final result through error propagation. The data come primarily from EXFOR, supplemented for \mathrm{{}^{10}B}(p,\alpha)\mathrm{{}^{7}Be} by recent measurements not yet registered in the database 13 ; 24 ; 51 ; 27 ; these recent measurements significantly tighten the constraint in the E_{\mathrm{cm}}=0.2 – 1 MeV region, where EXFOR data alone are sparse and the posterior would otherwise be markedly broader. For \mathrm{{}^{11}B}(p,n)\mathrm{{}^{11}C} , the substantial dispersion among reported values in the 4–10 MeV region is similarly absorbed into the posterior. The \mathrm{{}^{11}B(p,2\alpha)^{4}He} channel does not enter the measured radioisotope yields and is used only to evaluate the final fusion reaction number Y_{\alpha} ; for this channel we adopt the reference fit from a published evaluation 50 . In Fig. 1 , the solid curves and shaded bands show the posterior medians and 95% credible intervals; the dashed curve is the reference fit. Figure 1 : Energy-dependent cross sections of the three p–B reaction channels relevant to this work (log–log scale). Symbols show experimental data from EXFOR, supplemented for \mathrm{{}^{10}B}(p,\alpha)\mathrm{{}^{7}Be} with measurements not yet registered in EXFOR 13 ; 24 ; 51 ; 27 ; the complete dataset list is given in Appendix B. The solid curves and shaded bands show the posterior medians and 95% credible intervals from the Bayesian analysis, while the dashed curve indicates the reference fit 50 adopted for \mathrm{{}^{11}B(p,2\alpha)^{4}He} . The two absolute yields of {}^{11}\mathrm{C} and {}^{7}\mathrm{Be} obtained from the activation measurement constitute two independent observables of the in-solid proton energy distribution, restricting the reconstruction to two degrees of freedom. We model the incident proton energy distribution at the boron-containing target with the two-parameter Boltzmann form f(E_{0};A_{0},T_{0})=A_{0}\exp\!\left(-E_{0}/T_{0}\right),\qquad E_{\mathrm{min}}\leq E_{0}\leq E_{\mathrm{cut\text{-}off}}, (1) where E_{0} , T_{0} , and A_{0} are respectively energy, slope temperature, and absolute normalization of the incident protons on the boron target surface, and E_{\mathrm{cut\text{-}off}} the maximum energy characteristic of the acceleration mechanism. This single-temperature Boltzmann form is well established for TNSA, both experimentally and theoretically 56 ; 34 . We have

Read the complete text