Changing the Game: Status-Quo Inertia, Institutional Design, and Equilibrium Transition

Madjid Eshaghi Gordji, Esmaiel Abounoori, Mohamadali Berahman · 2026

Read Changing the Game: Status-Quo Inertia, Institutional Design, and Equilibrium Transition by Madjid Eshaghi Gordji, Esmaiel Abounoori, Mohamadali Berahman (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-09083.txt.

Introduction

Madjid Eshaghi Gordji, Esmaiel Abounoori, and Mohamadali Berahman study why small policy nudges so often fail to change behavior. In settings shaped by coordination and habit, people stick with the old way of doing things as long as it remains a stable outcome, a force they call status-quo inertia.

Within their framework, price-based tools and simply adding new options can fail even when they look better on paper. Interventions that remove or replace the old actions work far better, because they take away the ground the old outcome stands on. The authors prove general results and draw examples from climate policy, platform rules, financial reform, and industry. Their lesson: sometimes the game itself must change.

Catalog record

CREATORMadjid Eshaghi Gordji, Esmaiel Abounoori, Mohamadali Berahman
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.09083

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Changing the Game: Status-Quo Inertia, Institutional Design, and Equilibrium Transition Madjid Eshaghi Gordji, Esmaiel Abounoori, Mohamadali Berahman Abstract Many economic interventions are designed as marginal changes in incentives. Yet in environments shaped by coordination, institutional persistence, and path dependence, such reforms often leave behavior largely unchanged. This paper studies interventions in games when equilibrium selection displays status-quo inertia: if the pre-intervention equilibrium remains a Nash equilibrium after policy, it continues to be selected. In that environment, price-based interventions and simple option expansion may fail even when they improve welfare in a partial-equilibrium sense. By contrast, interventions that modify the feasible action space—especially deletion and replacement interventions—can be substantially more effective because they remove the strategic basis for persistence. We develop a simple framework, derive general results, provide complete proofs, and illustrate the economics with examples from climate transition, platform regulation, financial reform, and industrial modernization. The analysis highlights a basic policy lesson: when inefficient equilibria are institutionally entrenched, the central problem is often not how to price the existing game more finely, but how to change the game itself. JEL Codes: C72, D02, D62, L51, Q58 Keywords: equilibrium selection, status-quo inertia, institutional design, mechanism design, coordination failure, regulation, path dependence 1 Introduction Since the foundational work of 5 , 6 , game theory has provided economists with a language for understanding strategic interdependence. But from the beginning, one difficulty was apparent: equilibrium existence does not by itself identify the outcome an economy will reach. This concern led to a vast literature on equilibrium selection, focal points, and strategic refinement, from 8 to 1 . In parallel, mechanism design and implementation theory—shaped by the work of 2 , 4 , and 3 —showed that outcomes depend not only on incentives, but also on the institutional structure of interaction. This paper builds on those traditions while focusing on a practical issue that is central in modern policy environments: economies rarely choose among equilibria from a blank slate. They inherit an existing equilibrium. In many settings, that inherited outcome is supported by routines, legal continuity, sunk investments, complementary infrastructures, network effects, and shared expectations. As a consequence, even when a policy creates a better equilibrium, the economy may remain where it is. We study interventions in games under status-quo inertia . The idea is simple. If the pre-intervention equilibrium remains a Nash equilibrium after policy, it continues to be selected. This assumption is intentionally reduced-form, but it captures a broad class of phenomena that economists routinely observe: institutional stickiness, path dependence, lock-in, and equilibrium persistence. The distinction matters because many standard interventions are designed as local changes in payoffs. Taxes, subsidies, fines, bonuses, and relative-price corrections all aim to improve incentives while leaving the set of feasible actions intact. In environments without serious coordination frictions, that may be enough. But when agents must move together, price corrections can be too weak to dislodge a prevailing equilibrium. A superior alternative may exist and still remain unrealized. The paper’s main claim is that in such environments, the decisive question is often not whether policy improves incentives, but whether policy changes the game deeply enough to eliminate the inherited equilibrium. This shifts attention from marginal payoff manipulation to institutional redesign. We compare four classes of interventions: price-only interventions, addition interventions, deletion interventions, and replacement interventions. The core results are direct. If the old equilibrium survives, it persists. This immediately limits the power of many taxes and subsidies. It also limits the effectiveness of reforms that merely add new options while leaving incumbent ones in place. By contrast, deletion and replacement interventions can induce transition because they undermine the strategic foundations of the old equilibrium. Replacement is often especially effective because it combines disruption with direction: it not only removes the old option but also helps coordinate behavior around a new one. The economics is broad. In climate transition, carbon pricing may be desirable and still insufficient when incumbent technologies are embedded in complementary production systems. In digital markets, conduct remedies may leave platform architecture unchanged and therefore fail to alter the equilibrium. In financial reform, charging more for risk may be less effective than removing specific instruments or replacing them with safer contractual forms. In industrial modernization, subsidizing innovation may not move production networks if firms, suppliers, and workers remain coordinated on old standards. Our contribution is threefold. First, we offer a compact framework that merges equilibrium selection with institutional persistence. Second, we provide a clear theoretical distinction between interventions that alter payoffs and interventions that alter feasible action spaces. Third, we use that distinction to clarify a practical policy lesson: under inertia, structurally targeted reforms may dominate softer incentive-based approaches. The paper is also related to classic themes in institutional economics. 7 emphasized that institutions persist because they stabilize expectations and organize repeated interaction. Our model translates that intuition into a strategic-form environment with equilibrium selection. More generally, the paper contributes to a growing recognition that many policy problems are transition problems. The relevant issue is not simply whether a better equilibrium exists, but how a society can move to it. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the framework. Section 3 defines the intervention classes. Section 4 states the main theoretical results. Section 5 provides a simple coordination example. Section 6 discusses broader policy implications and the relation to the literature. Section 7 concludes. Complete proofs are collected in the Appendix. 2 Framework Definition 1 (Replacement intervention) . A replacement intervention removes an old action and simultaneously introduces a new one. If a\in A_{k} is replaced by a^{\prime}\notin A_{k} , then A_{k}^{R}=(A_{k}\setminus\{a\})\cup\{a^{\prime}\},\qquad A_{i}^{R}=A_{i}\text{ for }i\neq k. Economic example. Replacing a dirty production standard with a clean mandatory standard, substituting an opaque auction rule with a transparent one, or replacing a harmful financial contract with a regulated alternative are replacement interventions. 3 Main Results We begin with the general persistence result. Proposition 1 (Persistence under status-quo inertia) . Let I be any intervention, and let G_{I} be the intervened game. If q^{-}\in NE(G_{I}), then \sigma(G_{I};q^{-})=q^{-}. Economic example. Suppose a regulator imposes modest compliance penalties on a dominant digital platform, but the existing architecture still makes the old conduct pattern mutually optimal for users, advertisers, and the platform itself. Then the platform ecosystem may remain at the same equilibrium. The intervention affects incentives but not enough to dislodge the inherited strategic arrangement. Proposition 1 has an immediate implication for standard price-based reform. Proposition 2 (The limit of price-only intervention) . Suppose a price-only intervention produces a game G^{P} such that q^{-}\in NE(G^{P}). Then \sigma(G^{P};q^{-})=q^{-}. Economic example. A carbon tax may improve welfare comparisons across technologies, but if the incumbent fossil-based production system remains self-enforcing because suppliers, maintenance firms, infrastructure providers, and customers are all coordinated around it, then the economy may stay at the old equilibrium. Addition interventions face the same basic limitation. Proposition 3 (Addition may leave the old equilibrium intact) . Suppose an addition intervention produces a game G^{A} such that q^{-}\in NE(G^{A}). Then \sigma(G^{A};q^{-})=q^{-}. Economic example. A government may subsidize the introduction of a superior technology, but if incumbent firms expect their suppliers and customers to continue using the old system, adoption may remain limited. A better option

Read the complete text