Reply to Some Questions of Quotients when ultrafilters divide ultrafilters
Manoranjan Singha, Rohan Pradhan · 2026
Read Reply to Some Questions of Quotients when ultrafilters divide ultrafilters by Manoranjan Singha, Rohan Pradhan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-09010.txt.
Introduction
Manoranjan Singha and Rohan Pradhan write on ultrafilters, a tool in set theory used to judge which sets count as large. They define a quotient-like operation between two ultrafilters and study what happens when one ultrafilter divides another in a strong sense.
Much of the work centers on ultrafilters that divide themselves, and on how that property links to the quotient construction. The authors also present results on the stability of special ultrafilters tied to multiplication, and they connect the theory to sets in combinatorics called multiplicative delta sets. Readers get a focused piece of pure mathematics that ties several strands of ultrafilter research together.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Manoranjan Singha, Rohan Pradhan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.09010
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reply to Some Questions of Quotients when ultrafilters divide ultrafilters Manoranjan Singha, Rohan Pradhan Abstract For ultrafilters u , v ∈ β ℕ u,v\in\beta\mathbb{N} , the operation u v \frac{u}{v} is introduced and formalised which acts as ’quotient-like structure’ when v v strongly divides u u .Central to our study is the characterization of self-divisible ultrafilters in connection with the divisibility of u u by u v \frac{u}{v} .Some results on the the algebraic stability of multiplicative idempotents are presented . By assuming that u u is self-divisible and a multiplicative idempotent, it is established that the property of self-divisibility is inherited by the quotient u u \frac{u}{u} .The paper also connects combinatorial notions such as multiplicative Δ \Delta - sets and Δ ∗ \Delta^{*} - sets, providing characterizations via self-divisible ultrafilters. Also the continuous extensions of functions f : ℕ → ℕ f:\mathbb{N}\rightarrow\mathbb{N} are examined and it is shown that the identity f ~ ( u v ) = f ~ ( u ) f ~ ( v ) \widetilde{f}(\frac{u}{v})=\frac{\widetilde{f}(u)}{\widetilde{f}(v)} holds iff f f is multiplicative homomorphism, provided that v | u v\mid u . 1 Introduction The Stone-Čech Compactification of the discrete space \mathbb{N} denoted by \beta\mathbb{N} is the space of all the ultrafilters on \mathbb{N} . Collection of the sets of the form \widehat{A}=\{u\in\beta\mathbb{N}:A\in u\} forms a basis for a topology on \beta\mathbb{N} . Each n\in\mathbb{N} is identified with the ultrafilter u_{n}=\{A\subset\mathbb{N}:x\in A\} . The usual addition and multiplication on \mathbb{N} can be extended to \beta\mathbb{N} ; with these operations, \beta\mathbb{N} forms a compact Hausdorff right topological semigroup and the study of \beta\mathbb{N} as a compact Hausdorff right topological semigroup has proven to be a fertile ground for translating classical problems of elementary number theory in the realm of topological algebra. Central to this program is the extension of standard arithmetic relations - such as divisibility and congruences to the space of ultrafilters. Fact 1 . [ 3 ] Every f:\mathbb{N}\rightarrow\mathbb{N} extends uniquely to continous \widetilde{f}:\beta\mathbb{N}\rightarrow\beta\mathbb{N} and for every u\in\beta\mathbb{N},\widetilde{f}(u)=\{A\subset\mathbb{N}:f^{-1}(A)\in u\} . Motivated by Fact 1, B Šobot introduced the relation \widetilde{\mid} as an extension of standard divisibility on \mathbb{N} to \beta\mathbb{N} in [ 6 ] . More about this relation \widetilde{\mid} has been studied in [ 6 ] , [ 7 ] , [ 8 ] , [ 9 ] , [ 10 ] and [ 11 ] . In [ 9 ] , B Šobot introducted a new type of divisibility relation as a strengthening of \widetilde{\mid} namely stronger divisibility and showed that this divisibility relation is compatible with the congruence relation. Definition 1 . For u\in\beta\mathbb{N},D(u) is defined as D(u)=\{x\in\mathbb{N}:x\mathbb{N}\in u\} . Definition 2 . Given u,v\in\beta\mathbb{N},u is strongly divisible by v whenever D(u)\in v . In terms of quotient \frac{u}{v},u is said to be strongly divisible by v iff \frac{u}{v}\in\beta\mathbb{N} iff \frac{u}{v} is non-empty . Definition 3 . An element u\in\beta\mathbb{N} is said to be self-divisible if u\mid u , that is , if D(u)\in u . Definition 4 . Let u\in\beta\mathbb{N} . Then u is called a prime ultrafilter if P\in u where P=\{x\in\mathbb{N}:x\text{ is prime}\}. Definition 5 . The class of ultrafilters divisible by all the members of \beta\mathbb{N} is denoted MAX and is defined as MAX=\bigcap_{n\in\mathbb{N}}\widehat{n\mathbb{N}} . Throughout the paper : (i) P is the set of prime numbers. (ii) The terms ‘divisible’ and ‘divisibility’ refer to ‘strongly divisible’ and ‘strong divisibility’, respectively. 2 Some results and theorems Fact 2 . For any u,v\in\beta\mathbb{N} with v\mid u , D(v)\subset D(u) and D(\frac{u}{v})\subset D(u) . Proposition 1 . Let u\in\beta\mathbb{N} . Then for any v\in\beta\mathbb{N} with v\mid u , u\in MAX\iff\frac{u}{v}\in MAX . Proof: Let us assume that u\in MAX . Take any v\in\beta\mathbb{N} . Suppose \frac{u}{v}\notin MAX . Then there exists k\in\mathbb{N} such that k\mathbb{N}\notin\frac{u}{v} . k\mathbb{N}\notin\frac{u}{v}\implies\mathbb{N}\setminus k\mathbb{N}\in\frac{u}{v}\implies\{x\in\mathbb{N}:x(\mathbb{N}\setminus k\mathbb{N})\in u\}\in v . Pick x such that x(\mathbb{N}\setminus k\mathbb{N})\in u . Now x(\mathbb{N}\setminus k\mathbb{N})\subset\mathbb{N}\setminus xk\mathbb{N}\implies\mathbb{N}\setminus xk\mathbb{N}\in u . But since u\in MAX,xk\mathbb{N}\in u and this leads to contradiction. Hence \frac{u}{v}\in MAX . Conversely let v\in\beta\mathbb{N} such that v\mid u and \frac{u}{v}\in MAX . \frac{u}{v}\in MAX\implies D(\frac{u}{v})=\mathbb{N} . Now D(\frac{u}{v})\subset D(u)\implies D(u)=\mathbb{N} , which means u\in MAX . Fact 3 . [ 2 ] For any u\in\beta\mathbb{N} , the set of divisors of u in \beta\mathbb{N} is denoted by D and D = \widehat{D(u)} . Before proceeding further let us recall the definitions of left divisibility and right divisibility. For u,v\in\beta\mathbb{N} , u is said to be left divisible by v , denoted by v\mid_{L}u if there exists w\in\beta\mathbb{N} such that u=wv .Similarly , u is said to be right divisible by v , denoted by v\mid_{R}u if there exists w\in\beta\mathbb{N} such that u=vw . Lemma 1 . Let u,v,w\in\beta\mathbb{N} .Then (i) v\mid u and u\mid_{R}w\implies v\mid w . (ii) v\mid u and u\mid_{L}w\implies v\mid w . Proof : (i) v\mid u\implies D(u)\in v and u\mid_{R}w\implies w=ut for some t\in\beta\mathbb{N} . Take any x\in D(u) . Then we have x\mathbb{N}\in u . Let y\in x\mathbb{N} . x\mathbb{N}/y=\{k\in\mathbb{N}:ky\in x\mathbb{N}\}=\{k\in\mathbb{N}:x\mid ky\}=\mathbb{N} (since x\mid y ). Thus it follows that x\mathbb{N}\subset\{k\in\mathbb{N}:x\mathbb{N}/k\in t\} . So we have \{k\in\mathbb{N}:x\mathbb{N}/k\in t\}\in u which implies x\mathbb{N}\in ut . That is, x\in D(ut) . Now, D(u)\in v and D(u)\subset D(ut)\implies D(ut)\in v\implies v\mid ut i.e, v\mid w . (ii) v\mid u\implies D(u)\in v and u\mid_{L}w\implies w=tu for some t\in\beta\mathbb{N} . Take any x\in\mathbb{N} . Then we have x\mathbb{N}\in u .For any k\in\mathbb{N} , we have x\mathbb{N}\subset x\mathbb{N}/k . So it follows that x\mathbb{N}/k\in u and \{k\in\mathbb{N}:x\mathbb{N}/k\in t\}=\mathbb{N}\in t which implies that x\in D(tu) . Now, D(u)\in v and D(u)\subset D(tu)\implies D(tu)\in v\implies v\mid tu i.e, v\mid w . Theorem 2 . Let u\in\beta\mathbb{N} such that u is self divisible. Then (i) D(u.\frac{u}{u})\subset D(u.u) . (ii) D(\frac{u}{u}.u)\subset D(u.u) . (iii) In addition if u is multiplicative idempotent then D(u)=D(\frac{u}{u}.u)=D(u.\frac{u}{u}) . Proof :(i) Let x\in D(u.\frac{u}{u}) . x\in D(u.\frac{u}{u})\implies x\mathbb{N}\in u.\frac{u}{u} . x\mathbb{N}\in u.\frac{u}{u}\implies\{k\in\mathbb{N}:x\mathbb{N}/k\in\frac{u}{u}\}\in u (2.1). From Fact 1 it follows that D(\frac{u}{u})\subset D(u) which implies that \{k\in\mathbb{N}:x\mathbb{N}/k\in\frac{u}{u}\}\subset\{k\in\mathbb{N}:x\mathbb{N}/k\in u\} . And from (2.1) we have \{k\in\mathbb{N}:x\mathbb{N}/k\in u\}\in u\implies x\mathbb{N}\in u.u\implies x\in D(u.u) . Hence D(u.\frac{u}{u})\subset D(u.u) . (2.2) (ii) Let x\in D(\frac{u}{u}.u) . x\in D(\frac{u}{u}.u)\implies x\mathbb{N}\in\frac{u}{u}.u . x\mathbb{N}\in\frac{u}{u}.u\implies\{k\in\mathbb{N}:x\mathbb{N}/k\in u\}\in\frac{u}{u} . x\mathbb{N}\in\frac{u}{u}.u\implies\{k\in\mathbb{N}:x\mathbb{N}/k\in u\}=B(say)\in\frac{u}{u} . Now B\in\frac{u}{u}\implies\{n\in\mathbb{N}:nB\in u\}\in u . Pick n such that nB\in u . Now, y\in nB\implies y=nb for some b\in B . So y=nb such that x\mathbb{N}/b\in u . x\mathbb{N}/b\subset x\mathbb{N}/y\implies x\mathbb{N}/y\in u\implies y\in B and therefore nB\subset B\implies B\in u . Now, B\in u\implies x\mathbb{N}\in u.u\implies x\in D(u.u) . Hence D(\frac{u}{u}.u)\subset D(u.u) . (2.3) (iii) From lemma 1 , it follows that D(u)\subset D(\frac{u}{u}.u) and D(u)\subset D(u.\frac{u}{u}) . (2.4) If u is multiplicative idempotent then using (2.2) and (2.3) we have D(u.\frac{u}{u})\subset D(u) and D(\frac{u}{u}.u)\subset D(u) . (2.5) Using (2.4) and (2.5) we get D(u)=D(\frac{u}{u}.u)=D(u.\frac{u}{u}) . Corollary 3 . Let u\in\beta\mathbb{N} such that u is self divisible as well as multiplicative idempotent. Then for any v\in\beta\mathbb{N},v\mid u\iff v\mid\frac{u}{u}.u\iff v\mid u.\frac{u}{u} . Proof : From theorem 2 (iii), we obtain D(u)=D(\frac{u}{u}.u)=D(u.\frac{u}{u}) which further implies that \widehat{D(u)}=\widehat{D(\frac{u}{u}.u)}=\widehat{D(u.\frac{u}{u})} and hence the result follows. Example 1 . Here we present the example of an ultrafilter which is multiplicative idempotent as well as self divisible but not a member of MAX . Consider the set M=\{2^{n}:n\in\mathbb{N}\} .By Zorn’s Lemma ,