Disentangling coherent structures and the origin of swirl-switching

Eman Bagheri \aff 1, Riccardo Casali \aff 1, Stefan Becker \aff 1, Philipp Schlatter \aff 1 · 2026

Read Disentangling coherent structures and the origin of swirl-switching by Eman Bagheri \aff 1, Riccardo Casali \aff 1, Stefan Becker \aff 1, Philipp Schlatter \aff 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-08849.txt.

Introduction

Eman Bagheri, Riccardo Casali, Stefan Becker, and Philipp Schlatter hunt the origin of swirl switching, a puzzling flip in the swirling flow inside bent pipes. Three direct numerical simulations cover a half circle bend at two speeds and two curvatures. Standard modal decompositions blur distinct instabilities together, so the team introduces a filtered Hilbert decomposition that separates them into clean modes.

Seven modes in four families emerge, with the switching and breathing modes living in the curved section as the wavy and pulsing instabilities of the bend's twin vortices. Local stability analysis of the mean flow independently finds the same modes, with switching the most unstable. The agreement supports swirl switching as an intrinsic instability of the bent pipe flow itself.

Catalog record

CREATOREman Bagheri \aff 1, Riccardo Casali \aff 1, Stefan Becker \aff 1, Philipp Schlatter \aff 1
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.08849

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Disentangling coherent structures and the origin of swirl-switching Eman Bagheri \aff 1, Riccardo Casali \aff 1, Stefan Becker \aff 1, Philipp Schlatter \aff 1 Abstract Modal decomposition of turbulent flows using classical proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) often suffers from mode mixing, in which a distinct coherent structure may be distributed over several POD modes. We propose a decomposition method based on the Hilbert transform and band-pass filtering to address this issue (filtered Hilbert POD – FHPOD). We apply this approach to the turbulent flow through a 180 bent pipe at R ​ e D = 10,000 Re_{D}=10,000 (based on bulk velocity ( U b U_{b} ) and pipe diameter ( D D )) and curvature γ = 0.2 \gamma=0.2 , simulated using direct numerical simulation. The FHPOD results in four distinct mode families, including a swirl-switching mode at Strouhal number of 0.13 localised in the curved section. Our novel modal decomposition shows that the modes observed in the bend and downstream correspond to distinct physical mechanisms rather than to a single universal swirl-switching instability throughout the pipe, as previous work implied. To further examine the origin of the swirl-switching mode, we perform a local stability analysis of the cross-sectional mean flow along the bend. We find unstable eigenmodes at the same streamwise wavenumber and within the same range of Strouhal numbers as the swirl-switching mode found in the modal decomposition. The result supports the interpretation that the swirl-switching phenomenon is an intrinsic instability of the curved-pipe flow that can be excited and potentially enhanced by incoming turbulent structures, but is ultimately not caused by them. Finally, we also establish a link of the downstream modes to the local shear layers of the modified base flow, highlighting the different nature of these modes. \lefttitle Bagheri, Casali, Becker & Schlatter \righttitle Disentangling coherent structures and the origin of swirl-switching \corresau Eman Bagheri, keywords low-dimensional models, shear-layer instability, pipe flow 1 Introduction Flows in curved pipes are found in a wide range of industrial and physiological systems and have been the subject of research for more than a century ( 3 ; 52 ; 25 ) . The dynamics of the flow and turbulence in curved pipes are fundamentally different from those in straight pipes ( 32 ) . Curved pipe flows are characterised by two non-dimensional numbers, namely the Reynolds number, Re_{D}=\frac{U_{b}D}{\nu} (1) and the non-dimensional curvature parameter, \gamma=\frac{D}{2R_{c}}\ . (2) Here, D denotes the pipe diameter, U_{b} the bulk velocity, \nu the kinematic viscosity, and R_{c} the radius of curvature of the bend. As a result of the curvature and the centrifugal force, a Prandtl’s secondary flow of the first type forms inside the curved pipe. This cross-stream secondary motion is termed Dean vortices in recognition of the contributions of 8 ; 9 , who derived the governing asymptotic solution for weak curvatures. At sufficiently high Reynolds numbers, the Dean vortices become unstable and significantly affect the turbulent flow ( 1 ) . A key feature of the unstable Dean vortices is the so-called swirl-switching phenomenon. 51 were the first to report a low-frequency modulation of the Dean vortices. They studied turbulent flows in mitred 90^{\circ} bends and noticed that the Dean pair was replaced by a single vortex that intermittently flipped its axis of rotation. They reported a very low switching frequency, which is commonly expressed in later reviews with the Strouhal number. St=\frac{fD}{U_{b}},\qquad 2\times 10^{-4}\lesssim St\lesssim 4.5\times 10^{-3}, (3) where f is the characteristic modulation frequency. 4 utilised time-resolved digital particle image velocimetry (DPIV) in water at Re_{D}=2000 and 5000 to visualise quasi-periodic oscillations of the secondary flow in a spatially developing 90^{\circ} bend with \gamma=0.5 . From the tangential-velocity signal measured at 1.5D downstream of the bend close to the inner wall and in the geometrical plane of symmetry, he found two dominant frequencies at St\approx 0.03 and St\approx 0.12 , associated with alternate switching of the tangential flow. The corresponding streamwise-vorticity visualisations showed an alternating left and right switching of the vortex pair, which he referred to as “swirl-switching” (see the reprinted figure 1 ). A source of confusion, however, emerged in later studies, where the term “swirl-switching” was loosely used to refer to similar yet distinct coherent structures with different Strouhal numbers and spatial support from those originally described by 4 . Figure 1: Coherent structures identified by 4 as the manifestation of the swirl-switching phenomenon, shown using the spatio-temporal reconstruction of streamwise vorticity isosurfaces at 1.5\,D downstream of a 90^{\circ} bend measured over 50 seconds. Adapted from figure 2(b) of 4 , with permission from Christoph Brücker. Subsequent work by 48 ; 49 characterised the streamwise development of the mean flow in 90^{\circ} and 180^{\circ} bends. 48 showed that, in the 90^{\circ} bend, the secondary flow weakens downstream, while the influence of the bend remains even at 10D downstream of the bend. 49 found that, in the 180^{\circ} bend, an additional pair of vortices appears just downstream of the bend exit, and that recovery to a straight pipe flow requires a longer downstream distance compared with the 90^{\circ} bend. Understanding swirl-switching is important both from a flow-physics perspective and from an engineering point of view. The modulation of wall pressure and wall shear stress caused by swirl-switching has practical implications for structural fatigue, flow-induced vibrations and potential resonance in curved-pipe systems ( 18 ; 16 ; 55 ; 28 ) . This practical relevance has helped drive extensive experimental and numerical work in subsequent years. 41 ; 42 performed the first large-eddy simulations (LES) to confirm the existence of this phenomenon. In 90^{\circ} bends at Re_{D}\approx 2.7\times 10^{4} , they observed low–frequency oscillations of the Dean-vortex stagnation point and wall forces, with peaks at St\approx 0.0055 and 0.014 ( 41 ) , and later around St\approx 0.01 ( 42 ) . They associated the high-frequency oscillations at St\approx 0.2 – 0.3 with shear–layer instabilities. They also noted that the low–frequency oscillation can persist even when the curvature is too small to produce a strong separation region. 44 applied stereo-PIV and proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) in a 90^{\circ} bend at high Reynolds number. They identified antisymmetric modes with time-coefficient spectra exhibiting peaks in the range St\approx 0.02 – 0.07 , depending on the downstream position. In a later study, 43 performed simultaneous upstream and downstream PIV measurements and found upstream streaks correlated with the downstream displacement of the inner-side stagnation point. They noted that the connection between these streaks and very-large-scale motions (VLSMs) was unclear. In 2013, several PIV/POD studies focused on the swirl-switching phenomenon in 90^{\circ} bends. 24 used time-resolved stereoscopic PIV (2D3C) at the exit of a 90^{\circ} bend ( \gamma\approx 0.31 , Re_{D}\approx 3.4\times 10^{4} ). Using snapshot POD of the 2D3C velocity fields, they reconstructed the flow using the first six POD modes and analysed PSDs of the tangential velocity. They found a dominant peak at St\approx 0.12 , with additional peaks at St\approx 0.04 and St\approx 0.18 and the lower-frequency peak St\approx 0.04 was associated with swirl-switching. 17 measured the velocity further downstream of a 90^{\circ} bend with \gamma=0.5 at Re_{D}\approx 2.5\times 10^{4} . They stated that the mode at St\approx 0.16 is due to the oscillation of the Dean motion,

Read the complete text