The Grounding Gap: How LLMs Anchor the Meaning of Abstract Concepts Differently from Humans
Odysseas S. Chlapanis, Orfeas Menis Mastromichalakis, Christos H. Papadimitriou · 2026
Read The Grounding Gap: How LLMs Anchor the Meaning of Abstract Concepts Differently from Humans by Odysseas S. Chlapanis, Orfeas Menis Mastromichalakis, Christos H. Papadimitriou (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-08837.txt.
Introduction
Odysseas Chlapanis and two coauthors ask how models ground vague words like justice or theory. For folks, such sense grows from lived acts, felt states, and shared life. No one thing can be pointed at. The team reruns famed trait list tests from mind science. They run them on twenty one top and open models. Models lean too hard on word links. They list too few traits tied to felt or inner states.
No model comes near the pact rate folks reach with each other. In a split task, models rate ground types well when asked in a straight way. That skill grows with size. Probes find inner marks for sense and social ground. The gap is in use, not in what is known.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Odysseas S. Chlapanis, Orfeas Menis Mastromichalakis, Christos H. Papadimitriou |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.08837
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Grounding Gap: How LLMs Anchor the Meaning of Abstract Concepts Differently from Humans Odysseas S. Chlapanis, Orfeas Menis Mastromichalakis, Christos H. Papadimitriou Abstract Abstract concepts — justice, theory, availability — have no single perceivable referent; in the human brain, their meaning emerges from a web of experiences, affect, and social context. Do large language models (LLMs) ground abstract concepts in a similar way? We study this by replicating property-generation experiments from cognitive science on 21 frontier and open-weight LLMs. Across models and experiments, we find a consistent pattern: when compared to humans, models rely too heavily on word associations, and underproduce properties tied to emotion and internal states. This yields a large and consistent grounding gap: no model exceeds a Pearson correlation r = 0.37 r=0.37 with human responses, compared to a human-to-human ceiling above r = 0.9 r=0.9 . To better interpret this gap, we also replicate a rating experiment on grounding categories and find that here LLMs align more closely with human judgment, and alignment improves as models get larger. We then use sparse autoencoders (SAEs) to inspect whether this information is also reflected in the models’ internal features, and we do identify features connected to grounding dimensions such as ‘‘sensorimotor’’ and ‘‘social’’. These findings suggest that current LLMs can recover grounding dimensions when explicitly queried, but do not recruit them in a human-like way when words are generated freely. 1 1 1 All data and code are publicly available at https://github.com/odychlapanis/grounding-gap/. 1 Introduction Concrete concepts such as cat and table are anchored in shared experience through identifiable referents that can be perceived through the senses ( 7 ) . In contrast, abstract concepts such as art , adventure , or justice , lack such referents. When humans process abstract words, they reconstruct their meaning from grounded experiences. Consider how a person makes sense of art : a colorful painting , a feeling of awe , a favorite concert , as well as more abstract ideas such as creativity . Grounded-cognition theories argue that such sensorimotor, emotional, and social anchors are not incidental but constitutive of meaning ( 21 ; 3 ; 4 ) . Whether LLMs represent abstract concepts in a similarly grounded way, or rely primarily on patterns of linguistic association ( 6 ; 5 ) , remains an open question. To measure how closely LLMs align with humans in the grounding of abstract concepts, we replicate on LLMs two property-generation experiments from cognitive science ( 16 ; 20 ) . In these experiments, participants — in these references humans, in this paper models — are given a concept and asked to list the properties, situations, or associations that come to mind. Although individual responses vary, the coded distributions across human participants are highly consistent: people anchor abstract concepts along grounding dimensions such as sensorimotor experience, emotion, and social context in a similar and consistent way. We then compare the distributions produced by models with those produced by humans. Across 21 frontier and open models, we find a large and consistent grounding gap. In both experiments, no model reaches a human–model correlation above r=0.37 , while the human–human ceilings exceed r=0.9 . Models are also much closer to one another than to humans: model–model correlations are systematically higher than model–human correlations. Taken together, these results show that current LLMs exhibit a shared mode of grounding abstract concepts that is systematically different from the human one. But does the gap arise because models lack an understanding of the categories that structure human grounding, or because this understanding is not recruited in a human-like way when concepts are generated freely? To answer, we turn to a rating experiment from cognitive science, in which words are evaluated directly along grounding-related dimensions ( 38 ) . There, recent LLMs align much more closely with human judgments, and this alignment improves with model scale, leaving a gap of only about .1 in Pearson correlation with humans. This contrast suggests that the relevant dimensions are at least partly available to the models when they are explicitly queried, but they are not spontaneously recruited in a human-like way during property generation. This raises a mechanistic question: Can we find in LLMs internal representations that align with these grounding-related dimensions? To investigate this, we analyze models with sparse autoencoders (SAEs), a technique that helps identify interpretable internal features ( 8 ; 19 ; 36 ) . We search for features whose activations track grounding-related dimensions, and we do find evidence of such structure: some internal features correlate with human grounding dimensions or sub-dimensions. We then validate these features by showing that steering the model along them increases generation of properties from the corresponding target categories. Taken together, our findings suggest that current LLMs understand the basic grounding categories nearly–but not quite–as well as humans do, and yet they do not recruit them in a human-like way when generating freely. Contributions. • We replicate two property-generation experiments from cognitive science on 21 frontier and open LLMs, and show a large and consistent gap between humans and models in the grounding of abstract concepts. • We replicate a rating experiment on grounding-related dimensions and show that LLMs align much more closely – but not fully – with human judgments there, indicating that the gap is not simply due to failure to recognize the relevant dimensions. • We use sparse autoencoders to probe Gemma models for internal features related to grounding dimensions, and we do find evidence of such structure. 2 Related work Grounded cognition and grounding norms. Traditional theories of grounded cognition in language posit that abstract categories are not represented as arbitrary symbols but are grounded in sensorimotor and affective experience ( 3 ; 2 ) . Neurocognitive evidence supports that action words engage motor and premotor cortex ( 17 ; 32 ) , and emotional and social dimensions of abstract concepts have been linked to interoceptive processing ( 11 ; 26 ) . Behavioral norms operationalize these dimensions at scale: datasets in which human participants rate words on Likert scales for dimensions such as sensorimotor strength, arousal, valence, and socialness. 25 provide modality-specific strength ratings for 40,000 English words, while 33 and 12 cover arousal, valence, and socialness dimensions. These corpora enable grounding research to move beyond binary concrete/abstract distinctions ( 10 ) . The property-listing paradigm ( 28 ; 2 ) provides a richer signal: rather than scalar ratings, participants freely generate properties of concepts, yielding a distributional profile over experiential dimensions. 16 applied this paradigm specifically to abstract nouns, showing that they elicit rich sensorimotor, social, and affective features. 20 extended the paradigm to test whether emotion concepts form a distinct subcategory, finding that they rely more strongly on interoceptive features than other abstract concepts. These two studies form the empirical basis of our behavioral experiments. LLM cognitive experiments. Early work showed that language models often fail psycholinguistic diagnostics and do not reliably ground semantic properties ( 13 ) . 31 compared pre-trained transformer representations against human concept norms and found that visual co-training improves alignment for concrete word pairs, but offers little benefit for abstract ones. Recent work extends this question to frontier and open LLMs by prompting them for