How to augment cosmic shear measurements with radio polarimetry of galaxies?
and Simone Ferraro · 2026
Read How to augment cosmic shear measurements with radio polarimetry of galaxies? by and Simone Ferraro (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-08465.txt.
Introduction
Liang Dai, Junwu Huang, Weichen Winston Yin, Rui Zhou, and coauthors add radio polarization to the measurement of cosmic shear. Cosmic shear is the tiny distortion of galaxy shapes by gravity. The total polarization of a spiral galaxy traces its true orientation. It can expose the intrinsic shape that lensing measurements must subtract.
The authors build a statistical model of shape and polarization. They are joint Gaussian variables. Their covariance measures alignment quality. Maximizing the likelihood gives estimators that recover three things at once. They recover shear, intrinsic alignment, and line-of-sight polarization rotation. The estimators are unbiased with minimal variance to first order. They stay reliable with few galaxies or weak alignment.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | and Simone Ferraro |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.08465
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
How to augment cosmic shear measurements with radio polarimetry of galaxies? and Simone Ferraro Abstract The integral polarization of spiral galaxies in the radio band has been proposed as a new tracer of the intrinsic galaxy shape that augments lensing shear measurements. We revisit the method of shear estimation in this context. We introduce a new statistical model in which galaxy shape and polarization are Gaussian random variables with their covariance characterizing the quality of polarization-shape alignment. Applying the principle of likelihood maximization, we then analytically derive unbiased, minimal-variance estimators, which allow to simultaneously estimate gravitational shear, intrinsic shape alignment and line-of-sight polarization rotation, all at once and accurate to first order in these three effects. New to the literature, our estimators have the merits of being free of biases, robust in situations of few galaxies or poor polarization-shape alignment, allowing analytic reconstruction noise covariance, and minimizing uncertainties in power spectrum estimation, thus resolving conceptual issues of the existing estimation methods. This new analytic framework is generally applicable to future research that exploits the polarization-shape alignment effect of galaxies. 1 Introduction In star-forming galaxies, the integral ISM continuum emission in the radio band ( \nu\sim 1 – 10\, GHz; often dominated by synchrotron emission except toward high frequencies) has a polarization direction that strongly correlates with the apparent minor axis of the galaxy in optical images. Stil et al first empirically discovered this correlation at 4.8\, GHz in small samples of nearby galaxies [ 1 ] . This correlation arises because the interstellar magnetic field that locally sets the polarization direction of the diffuse synchrotron emission has an ordered global component tracing the geometry of the gas disk [ 1 , 2 ] . Therefore, this effect should be prevalent in distant galaxies. Indeed, Zhou et al confirmed and quantified this effect for simulated galaxies in the IllustrisTNG50 project over a range of redshifts ( z=0 – 2 ) and for a range of observed radio frequencies ( \nu=1 – 8\, GHz) [ 3 ] . Despite several public datasets from radio continuum surveys with polarimetry [ 4 , 5 ] , sufficiently deep radio data for a cosmologically significant sample of galaxies are still lacking, which would be needed for accurately modeling the statistics of polarization-shape (mis)alignment. Recently, there has been renewed community attention to cosmology and fundamental physics applications that exploit polarization-shape alignment in galaxies, with the prospect of large datasets to be delivered by upcoming radio-band galaxy surveys such as those from the Square Kilometre Array (SKA) project [ 6 ] . When leveraging radio continuum imaging of distant galaxies, the integral polarization is measurable without the need to spatially resolve individual galaxies. At the same time, galaxy shape measurements are readily available from current and upcoming optical imaging surveys since shapes are standard inputs to weak lensing analyses. Polarization-shape alignment for general extragalactic sources has been found useful in the search of cosmic birefringence. Here, the observed source shape is used as a tracer of the intrinsic polarization direction [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] . A synergy of polarimetric radio surveys and optical shape surveys will enable us to detect or constrain polarization rotation along the line of sight induced by ultralight axion fields in the Universe [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] , at sensitivities that rival Stage-IV CMB experiments [ 9 ] and enabling redshift tomography [ 16 ] . For another application, it has been recognized that a novel method to measure weak gravitational lensing of background galaxies can be developed based on polarization-shape alignment [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] . Compared to measuring lensing shear simply from the average observed galaxy shape, polarization supplements information on the intrinsic galaxy shape, which not only reduces the shape noise but also tells apart gravitational shear and intrinsic shape alignment [ 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 ] . This conceptually parallels other promising ideas on augmenting shear measurements using additional galaxy observables, such as the method of kinematic weak lensing [ 27 , 28 , 29 ] . More than a cosmological nuisance, intrinsic alignment may carry unique information about galaxy formation [ 30 ] , primordial non-Gaussianity [ 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 ] , or primordial tensor modes [ 36 , 37 , 38 , 39 ] , so a new independent capability to measure it will be valuable. In the pioneer work of Ref. [ 17 ] , Brown & Battye (BB11) developed new shear estimators that leverage radio polarization information. In constructing these estimators, the authors use the integral polarization direction as an indicator of the intrinsic galaxy minor axis. Aiming to remove degeneracy between lensing shear and intrinsic alignment, they choose to project out the ellipticity component aligned with that direction. This reduces the shape noise, yet causes intrinsic alignment to contaminate shear estimation by a small amount that precisely vanishes only in the limit of perfect polarization-shape alignment (i.e. when the polarization-shape misalignment angle, defined in Eq. ( 2.3 ), has zero standard deviation). While this bias may appear numerically insignificant when intrinsic alignment is weak for the relevant galaxy sample, it poses a conceptual problem, which can become important with large statistics from future galaxy data. Later in Ref. [ 40 ] , Whittaker, Brown & Battye (WBB15) identified the root of this bias to be imperfect knowledge of the intrinsic shape due to randomness in the polarization direction, and derived an analytic approximation for the bias. This then enabled the authors to modify the original BB11 estimators in [ 17 ] so that shear bias is removed at the level of combining measurements done for many independent galaxies. Ref. [ 18 ] demonstrated that the spatially varying weak lensing convergence can be correctly mapped out using these estimators. Ref. [ 8 ] further generalized the method to estimating an additional polarization rotation effect along the line of sight, but focused on applying the estimators to resolved AGN radio lobes. However, corrections are implemented in the WBB15 estimators at the cost of inflated reconstruction noise compared to the BB11 method, due to estimation outliers that result from inverting (near-)singular matrices. This occurs when the number of usable galaxies in each pixel of map-making is small [ 40 ] , an issue absent in the original BB11 estimators. This in principle poses a limitation for reconstructing shear modes on very small angular scales or in shallow radio continuum surveys [ 40 ] . Following an independent logic, we revisit the problem of separating shear and intrinsic alignment with polarization information and that of simultaneously estimating extrinsic polarization rotation. Building upon but significantly revising the mathematical framework introduced in Ref. [ 9 ] , we first present an analytic model describing galaxy ellipticity and integral polarization as Gaussian random variables. Crucially, polarization-shape alignment is captured by a covariance between ellipticity and polarization. For simplicity, we will not further model the strong dependence of polarization-shape alignment on galaxy inclination [ 1 ] , only to note that this dependence is theoretically expected [ 1 ] and confirmed for