Change My View? The Dynamics of Persuasion and Polarization in Online Discourse

David Freeborn, Malihe Alikani, Anthony Sicilia · 2026

Read Change My View? The Dynamics of Persuasion and Polarization in Online Discourse by David Freeborn, Malihe Alikani, Anthony Sicilia (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-08383.txt.

Introduction

David Freeborn, Malihe Alikani, and Anthony Sicilia study which moves change minds online. Philosophy often expects shared evidence to pull peers toward agreement. Ordinary debate suggests otherwise. The authors turn to Reddit's ChangeMyView forum. Users there publicly flag when a comment shifted their view.

Language models forecast from the midpoint of each thread. They estimate whether a change would be acknowledged. Those estimates serve as a conversational baseline. Human-machine coding then tagged each reply for ten rhetorical strategies. The strategies range from concession and empathy to logical challenge and credibility appeals. Adding those features improved prediction sharply. Concession and empathetic alignment raised the odds of belief change. Frontal attacks lowered them.

Catalog record

CREATORDavid Freeborn, Malihe Alikani, Anthony Sicilia
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.08383

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Change My View? The Dynamics of Persuasion and Polarization in Online Discourse David Freeborn, Malihe Alikani, Anthony Sicilia Abstract Philosophical accounts of persuasion often assume that shared evidence and rational argumentation should lead to a convergence of views between peers, yet everyday discourse often suggests otherwise. In this study, we use large language models to analyze a corpus of debates on Reddit’s r/ChangeMyView, where belief revision is publicly signaled. Large language models were asked, halfway through each discussion, to forecast whether such an acknowledgement would arise; their probabilistic estimates serve as a conversational baseline. Each reply was then coded, through a hybrid machine-assisted procedure, for ten familiar rhetorical strategies—concession, empathy, logical challenge, credibility appeals, and so forth. Adding these strategic features markedly improves predictive power and yields a consistent pattern: moves that express concession or empathetic alignment substantially increase the prospect of belief change, whereas frontal refutation, credibility attacks, and topic deflection diminish it. The findings indicate that effective public reasoning depends as much on relational framing as on evidential content, and they invite a refinement of normative accounts of rational dialogue. 1 Introduction: The Puzzle of Persuasion and Polarization On 27 September 2018 the United States paused to watch Christine Blasey Ford and Brett Kavanaugh testify before the Senate Judiciary Committee. Before the hearing an NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll ( 10 ) found the public largely undecided: 42% were unsure whom to believe, while belief in Ford (32%) and in Kavanaugh (26%) was roughly balanced. However, just days later after watching the same testimony, the undecided share had collapsed to 22% and opinions had pulled apart: belief in Ford jumped to 45%, belief in Kavanaugh nudged up to 33%. Further polling suggested only 5% of respondents now judged both witnesses credible; instead, 73% of Democrats believed Ford while 74% of Republicans believed Kavanaugh 9 . Thus the very moment designed to elicit a shared judgment instead pushed the poles of opinion further apart. The Kavanaugh case exemplifies a puzzle for philosophers. The same body of evidence—two sworn testimonies, a single televised exchange—generated sharply divergent posterior beliefs, challenging the expectation that rational agents exposed to common data should converge. The episode illustrates the double-edged nature of public reasoning: whereas deliberation is often lauded as a pathway to collective truth, here it seemed to entrench factional narratives, suggesting that sincere, information-rich discourse can rationally widen disagreement when background credences are entangled. Philosophers often expect rational inquiry to be truth-conducive, yet in cases like the Kavanaugh testimonials, it sometimes only exacerbates disagreement. This raises what we shall call the “puzzle of persuasion”: why does rational persuasion sometimes succeed whilst at other times it can fail so spectacularly? Classical Bayesian epistemology appears to promise an answer: agents with absolutely continuous priors who update on the same data must eventually merge their opinions ( 2 ) . Yet the Ford–Kavanaugh case, and countless smaller exchanges, belie that promise. Indeed, recent formal work ( 6 ; 7 ) proves the fragility of merger: when agents hold multiple, probabilistically entangled beliefs, Bayesian updating can rationally generate persistent polarisation and even predictable factionalisation. This paper tackles the puzzle of persuasion with an empirical lens, using a novel philosophical methodology. We analyse more than 3,000 discussions from Reddit’s Change My View forum, where original posters publicly signal persuasion by awarding a delta badge. Building on methods developed by 12 , who show that pre-trained language models can forecast conversational outcomes and, when calibrated for uncertainty, markedly reduce bias in prediction. As such we set out to answer three related questions. First, can large language models help us to forecast persuasion? We prompt Llama-3 variants to assign probabilities that an unfinished Change My View thread will end in a badge. Second, which argumentative strategies actually work? We use two complementary taxonomies, one distilled from the social-influence literature, the other induced by chain-of-thought prompting: we label every reply for strategic content (concession, logical appeal, shared-identity cues, pathos, and so forth) and regress badge outcomes on these labels. Third, what do these patterns teach us about persuasion? By linking calibrated forecasts to strategy coefficients we gain a micro-level view of when evidence overcomes, or fails to overcome, prior commitments. These questions sit at the intersection of formal epistemology, the philosophy of language, and social epistemology. Methodologically we pair large-scale computational tools with conceptual analysis: the language model functions both as an instrument for tracing statistical regularities in natural argument and as an object whose own predictive commitments invite philosophical scrutiny. The paper proceeds as follows. Section 2 surveys philosophical accounts of persuasion and the formal limits of Bayesian convergence. Section 3 introduces the Change My View corpus, the forecasting architecture, and our dual strategy-coding pipeline. Section 4 reports empirical findings: baseline model calibration, the added value of strategy features, and illustrative cases. Section 5 interprets those findings, arguing that successful persuasion realises a form of strategically bounded rationality that integrates evidential coherence with credibility cues and minimal empathy. Section 6 concludes. 2 Theoretical Framework Philosophers and theorists have long distinguished between dialectical and rhetorical approaches to persuasion. The dialectical tradition views persuasion as a truth-oriented dialogue: ideally, through reasoned argument and shared evidence, interlocutors should converge on the truth. This perspective has one clear expression in Bayesian frameworks, where belief change is governed by the internal coherence of credences and their updating via Bayesian conditioning. In contrast, the rhetorical tradition emphasizes the art of influence, i.e. how speakers actually persuade audiences, which may involve appeals to emotion, credibility, or style as much as logical argument. These two traditions sometimes diverge: what ought to persuade a fully rational agent need not always work in practice. Contemporary research has sought to reconcile these traditions. 11 , in their influential “argumentative theory of reasoning,” argue that reasoning evolved not to deliver truth per se, but to persuade others and defend one’s views in social contexts. In support of this view, 13 introduce the concept of epistemic vigilance: a suite of mechanisms evolved to assess the reliability of communicated information and the credibility of speakers. Yet a tension remains between normative and descriptive accounts of persuasion. Normative theories identify what should rationally persuade: valid arguments, well-supported evidence, and logical coherence. Descriptive theories document what in fact persuades: emotional narratives, credibility displays, and appeals to social identity. 2.1 Rationality, Agreement and Consensus A natural philosophical intuition is that dialogue should lead to common evidence, which in turn should lead to agreement. This expectation is encapsulated in what nielsen2021 call the optimistic thesis about learning: that rational agents who acquire the same evidence will resolve their disagreements. This expectation is formalized in theorems like that of 2 , which demonstrates that if two Bayesian agents possess non-dogmatic prior beliefs and observe the same complete and infinite sequence of evidence, their posterior beliefs regarding future events will inevitably converge. Meanwhile, 1 ’s agreement theorem establishes that if two rational agents begin with common prior beliefs, and their respective posterior probabilities for a specific event become common knowledge between them, then these posterior probabilities must necessarily be identical. Thus, under sufficiently stringent assumptions, these theorems provide the foundation for a Bayesian account of rational agreement. 2.2 Higher Order Evidence and

Read the complete text