Coordination Mechanisms with Partially Specified Probabilities
Francesco Giordanolabel=e1][email protected] · 2026
Read Coordination Mechanisms with Partially Specified Probabilities by Francesco Giordanolabel=e1][email protected] (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-07469.txt.
Introduction
Francesco Giordano studies which game outcomes can be achieved when players see only coarse stats of an unsure process, not its full shape. Players know the means of a few random values and fill in beliefs by maximum entropy. He asks what a designer can achieve by sharing such partial information.
With open message spaces, workable outcomes coincide exactly with a class he calls jointly coherent ones, widening the usual linked balance points. For standard schemes, the test reduces to one cross-entropy check involving a linked balance point through the target. Cases across several game classes show how far it reaches.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Francesco Giordanolabel=e1][email protected] |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.07469
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Coordination Mechanisms with Partially Specified Probabilities Francesco Giordanolabel=e1][email protected] Abstract We study which outcomes are implementable by disclosing coarse statistics of a data-generating process rather than its full distribution. Players observe data whose joint distribution is only partially known: they know the expectations of finitely many random variables and form beliefs by maximum-entropy inference. We obtain two characterizations. When message spaces are unrestricted, implementable outcomes coincide with jointly coherent outcomes, expanding the set of correlated equilibria. With canonical mechanisms, implementability reduces to a single cross-entropy condition: the target outcome must lie on the cross-entropy level set of some correlated equilibrium that passes through that equilibrium itself. Examples and several classes of games illustrate the reach of the framework. keywords keywords [class=JEL] \startlocaldefs \endlocaldefs {funding} I am grateful to Frederic Koessler, Tristan Tomala, Marie Laclau, Nicolas Vieille, Itzhak Gilboa, Françoise Forges, Marco Scarsini, Julian Chitiva, and Francesco Conti for helpful discussions and comments. This work was significantly improved through discussions with Rossella Argenzano, Mariagiovanna Baccara, Pierpaolo Battigalli, Olivier Compte, Michael Greinecker, Philip Jehiel, Elliot Lipnowski, Alessandro Lizzeri, Jérôme Renault, Ludovic Renou, Karl Schlag, Vasiliki Skreta, Ran Spiegler, and Guillaume Vigeral. I thank participants of the (Junior) Game Theory Seminar at the Institut Henri Poincaré, the HEC PhD brownbag, the 7th World Congress of the Game Theory Society (Beijing), the Première rencontre nationale du RT Optimisation (Lyon), and the 2025 European Winter Meeting of the Econometric Society (Nicosia) for their comments. All errors are my own. This work benefited from a State grant managed by the Agence Nationale de la Recherche under the Investissements d’Avenir programme, reference ANR-18-EURE-0005 / EUR DATA EFM. 1 Introduction Often, decision makers act based on observed data, while they only have partial knowledge of how these data are produced: this paper investigates some implications of coarse information in games. In many strategic situations, players have a good understanding of the payoff structure of the game, but face uncertainty about how correlated their information is. For instance, in financial markets, traders observe analyst forecasts that are partly based on shared data sources. Each trader knows that others receive similar recommendations, but not how strongly these are correlated. Under correlation neglect, they might implicitly act as if others’ signals are “as independent as possible” given what they know — a maximum-entropy belief. A similar logic applies in social media coordination: users decide whether to join a protest or adopt a behaviour after seeing messages or posts generated by an opaque algorithmic feed. Although everyone knows the incentives to coordinate, each person only has coarse knowledge of what others have seen and therefore adopts some heuristic to deal with the unknown correlation. Finally, in corporate committees, members often rely on reports from analysts who use overlapping data. Each member of the committee knows their colleagues’ advice comes from correlated sources but not how much overlap exists, leading them to treat others’ signals as roughly independent. In all these settings, the game is common knowledge, but the structure of the correlation device linking players’ private signals is uncertain, making entropy-based beliefs a natural behavioral foundation. These examples emphasize some broad implications of partial information disclosure and raise the central question of this paper: what economic outcomes can arise when data is available, but disclosure rules limit the extent to which the data-generating process is revealed? This paper models an idealized environment that captures the information misspecification as a design problem, where a hypothetical information provider generates data according to a true data-generating process (constituted by a set of messages and a probability distribution over them) and a feedback structure: a set of functions whose expectation is known according to the data-generating process, that represents the partial information players have about how data is produced. Before taking any action, each player receives some data, which may be correlated with the data received by other players. However, the joint distribution of such data is only partially revealed by the feedback structure, leaving ambiguity about the true underlying process. Messages are not payoff-relevant per se and, faced with a set of plausible data-generating processes consistent with the moment conditions, players use a heuristic maximum-entropy criterion to identify a belief that aligns with their limited knowledge of the true process. The interaction between the available data and the induced beliefs gives rise to endogenous patterns of correlated behavior. The main body of the paper develops a formal framework for analyzing such partially specified data-generating processes and characterizes the set of outcomes implementable under both canonical and arbitrary partially specified data-generating processes. In both cases, the notion of implementation allows for more than correlated equilibria. If the message set is arbitrary, the set of outcomes that can be implemented coincides with the set of outcomes that are jointly coherent, namely randomizations over jointly coherent strategy profiles, i.e., profiles that lie in the support of some correlated equilibria, as introduced by Nau and McCardle 1990 . Once we restrict attention to the case of canonical implementation—namely, the message set coincides with action recommendations and players’ strategies are obedient—the set of implementable outcomes depends on a condition relating the cross-entropy of the outcome to the set of correlated equilibria, capturing the extent to which the data-generating process can be distorted into a belief consistent with a correlated equilibrium. When agents complete partially specified information using Shannon entropy, the induced beliefs generate systematic correlation across actions, so that coarse information disclosure itself acts as a coordination device. Importantly, the set of outcomes implementable through such disclosure strictly expands the set of correlated equilibrium outcomes. 1.1 Literature Correlated behavior in games has been introduced and studied since the seminal papers of Aumann 1974 and Aumann 1987 , with a recent comprehensive review provided by Forges and Ray 2024 . In particular, a mechanism design perspective is introduced in the foundational work of Myerson 1982 , who develops a generalized principal-agent model in which a principal can coordinate players’ actions through coordination devices; when players have a single type, the principal’s decision problem reduces to choosing a correlated equilibrium. The current paper integrates the classical framework with more recent advances concerning partial specification of underlying data-generating processes, by allowing for partially specified probabilities, incomplete data access, and model misspecification. Lehrer 2012 proposes a theory of decision making under partially specified probabilities and introduces an equilibrium concept in which players best respond to the worst-case strategies consistent with a partially specified distribution over others’ actions. In that model, the mixed strategies of other players are only partially specified, and players evaluate their actions reflecting ambiguity aversion. In contrast, our model considers a similar framework of partially specified information but assumes a heuristic belief-formation process that fills in the missing information. Players then respond optimally by maximizing their expected utility based on this partial information. This distinction is motivated by the fact that, in our setup, messages are not inherently payoff-relevant; rather, an equilibrium condition is defined given a belief over these messages. Our notion of implementation is also connected to prominent solution concepts in which players’ actions align with what they know, while relying on subjective beliefs or adversarial attitudes whenever available data do not support a particular belief. An example is the