Accelerated and data-efficient flow prediction in stirred tanks via physics-informed learning

Mahdi Naderibeni, Liang Wu, David M.J. Tax · 2026

Read Accelerated and data-efficient flow prediction in stirred tanks via physics-informed learning by Mahdi Naderibeni, Liang Wu, David M.J. Tax (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-07444.txt.

Introduction

Mahdi Naderibeni, Liang Wu, and David M. J. Tax study how much training data physics-guided flow predictors really need inside factory stirred tanks. Running flow models is costly, so learned stand-ins promise far faster field forecasts. The team made steady flows across impeller speeds and liquid heights with standard turbulence runs, then trained neural field models.

Error fell as data grew, but with clear fading returns past mid-size datasets. Physics-based constraints helped most when data were scarce, lifting scores and steadier tracer transport. Reasonable interpolation across speeds and heights was possible, though constraint benefits faded as datasets grew large.

Catalog record

CREATORMahdi Naderibeni, Liang Wu, David M.J. Tax
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.07444

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Accelerated and data-efficient flow prediction in stirred tanks via physics-informed learning Mahdi Naderibeni, Liang Wu, David M.J. Tax Abstract The simulation of fluid flows is computationally expensive due to the complexity of its governing partial differential equations. Machine learning models offer a potential surrogate, enabling learning from simulations and significantly faster predictions of flow fields. However, these models require large training datasets, which introduces a trade-off between dataset generation cost and predictive accuracy. In this work, we investigate the relationship between the size of the training-set and accuracy of the prediction when learning steady flow fields in an industrial-scale stirred vessel. A data set of steady flows is generated using Reynolds Averaged Navier Stokes (RANS) simulations in a range of realistic operating conditions, including impeller speeds and liquid heights. We train implicit neural representations of flow fields and compare purely data-driven and constrained variants. Model performance is evaluated using global mean squared error (MSE), qualitative spatial comparisons of predicted and reference flow fields, and tracer transport simulations. We find that the prediction error decreases monotonically with increasing training data, but also that it exhibits clear diminishing returns beyond moderate dataset sizes. Physics-based constraints significantly improve accuracy and reduce variability across training runs in low-data regimes, and they lead to more stable tracer-transport behavior. Furthermore, reasonable interpolation can be achieved over different impeller speeds and liquid heights. However, these benefits come with an increase in the complexity of training, and their relative advantage diminishes as the training set grows. 1 Introduction Stirred vessels have widespread applications in chemical and biochemical processes as a result of their favorable performance in mixing and heat transfer 12 . An essential step in modeling such processes is to simulate the fluid flow by solving the Navier-Stokes equations. Given the tolerable assumptions and accessible compute resources, such simulations are performed at different scales of fidelity. From low-fidelity methods such as Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) simulations to more computationally intensive approaches such as Large Eddy Simulation (LES) and Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) 17 . In numerous applications, such as fermentation and crystallization, even the routinely used coarse-grained RANS simulations are computationally prohibitive, requiring researchers and industry practitioners to resort to even lower-fidelity modeling approaches, such as compartment models, despite their inherent limitations 6 . In addition, since these simulations involve solving partial differential equations (derived from the conservation laws of mass and momentum, along with transport equations for species and energy), even minor modifications to initial or boundary conditions, such as variations in fluid properties, stirring rate, liquid height, or inlet and outlet flow rates, can significantly alter the solution, necessitating new simulations. Given these limitations and considering that CFD simulations are inherently data-rich, generating extensive spatiotemporal datasets, present a compelling opportunity to leverage data-driven approaches to extract insights and enable predictive modeling 3 . Recent advances in machine learning have produced a spectrum of approaches to enhance or accelerate CFD simulations. At one end, hybrid methods embed learned components into conventional solvers (e.g. data-driven turbulence closures, surrogate sub-steps, or coarse-to-fine correction operators) to accelerate or improve iterative CFD while retaining the solver’s numerical backbone. At the other end, Physics Informed Neural Networks (PINNs) impose the governing PDEs directly on the neural network model training loss and solve for solution maps from coordinates to fields; even though they still face optimization, scalability, and robustness challenges for large, high Reynolds flows 13 . Neural operator methods (DeepONet 8 , Fourier Neural Operator 7 , etc.) aim to learn mappings between function spaces and provide fast inference for parametric PDE families, though they are typically data-hungry and sensitive to the training distribution. Complementary directions include generative models (conditional GANs, VAEs, diffusion models) that synthesize plausible flow fields conditioned on geometry or boundary/operating parameters 14 . Each class of methods trades off data requirements, physical fidelity, inference cost, and ease of coupling with existing CFD workflows. In this work, we focus on accelerating the prediction of fluid flow fields for stirred vessels, investigating prediction accuracy as a function of training-data size. We use a CFD solver to generate steady single-phase RANS simulations ( k\textendash\omega turbulence model) of an industrial-scale stirred tank across operating conditions parameterized by mixer speed and liquid height, and we train implicit neural surrogates to predict velocity, pressure, turbulent kinetic energy k and specific dissipation rate \omega fields. Our contributions are as follows: - We generate and publish a controlled dataset of steady flow fields in an industrial stirred vessel using RANS ( k\textendash\omega ) simulations across a sweep of stirring rates and liquid heights. - We present a systematic empirical study of the data–accuracy trade-off: evaluating global MSE, local spatial error statistics, and passive-tracer simulations; we show clear diminishing returns in accuracy beyond moderate dataset sizes. - We quantify the benefit of physics constraints: demonstrating that PDE-constrained models substantially improve accuracy, reduce run-to-run variability, and yield more reliable mixing simulations in low-data regimes, while also documenting increased training complexity and the practical challenges of coupling learned fields back into conventional CFD solvers. 2 Data 2.1 Case study The study considers a 22\,\text{m}^{3} multi-impeller Rushton turbine tank. The vessel has a total height of 8.12\,\text{m} and a diameter T=2.09\,\text{m} , and contains four baffles and four Rushton impellers with a diameter of D=T/3 . To explore the design space, two operational parameters are varied: the liquid height, sampled uniformly between 1.5 and 6.5\,\text{m} , and the stirring rate , sampled between 50 and 150\,\text{rpm} . A visualization of the vessel geometry together with stacked velocity magnitude profiles from the resulting dataset is shown in Fig. 1 . Additional technical specifications of the case study can be found in 18 ; 5 . Figure 1 : Tank geometry and four representative velocity magnitude profiles from the dataset, showcasing various liquid heights and stirring rates. 2.2 Simulation Setup Given that the vessel is partially filled, to simulate the two-phase flow in the vessel, we employ the Eulerian multiphase framework coupled with the Shear Stress Transport (SST) k\textendash\omega turbulence model coupled with a mixture turbulence formulation. A production limiter is applied to the turbulence equations to prevent excessive generation of turbulent kinetic energy in stagnation regions. The rotation of the mixer is captured using the Multiple Reference Frame (MRF) approach. Computational resources were provided by the Delft High Performance Computing Center (DHPC) 1 , utilizing Ansys Fluent 2024R1 on Intel® Xeon® Gold 6248R processors. Details of the computational mesh and the simulation strategy are provided in A . 2.3 Data Pipeline The simulation results are converted into compact MATLAB (.mat) files for machine learning integration. Each operating condition is represented by 100,000 points sampled uniformly by mesh index, thereby maintaining the non-uniform physical distribution of the original grid (i.e., higher density near the impeller and walls). The data set includes spatial coordinates, velocity, pressure, phase volume fractions, and turbulence closure parameters. 2.4 Tracer dispersion computations To further evaluate the predicted flow fields, we simulated the dispersion of a passive tracer. The tracer was introduced as a patch 0.5 m below the static liquid surface at a radial position of r=0.7 m. A numerical probe was positioned at the bottom of the tank ( H=0.5 m, r=0.7 m) to monitor the concentration

Read the complete text