AI and Consciousness: Shifting Focus Towards Tractable Questions
Iulia-Maria Comșa · 2026
Read AI and Consciousness: Shifting Focus Towards Tractable Questions by Iulia-Maria Comșa (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-06965.txt.
Introduction
Iulia-Maria Comsa argues that research on AI consciousness should shift toward questions that can actually be studied. Whether an AI system can truly have inner experience, she says, cannot now be settled. No agreed science of consciousness exists, and the older mind-body problem remains open.
Perceived consciousness is different, Comsa argues, and it is already changing society. People increasingly speak about AI systems as if they think and feel, which affects design, ethics, and everyday language. She maps the drivers and effects of that perception, and urges clear communication from developers and decision makers about what remains unknown.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Iulia-Maria Comșa |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.06965
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
AI and Consciousness: Shifting Focus Towards Tractable Questions Iulia-Maria Comșa Abstract As language-based AI systems become more anthropomorphic, the question of whether they can have subjective experience is increasingly pressing. I focus here on the tractability of research questions in the space of AI consciousness. I argue that the fundamental problem of whether AI systems can be conscious is currently intractable in its direct form, given the absence of a universally accepted scientific theory of consciousness, as well as the historical open-endedness of the philosophical mind-body problem. In contrast, questions around the adjacent subject of perceived AI consciousness are tractable, timely, and highly consequential for society. The general public is increasingly open to the possibility of consciousness in AI systems and routinely adopts the vocabulary of human cognition and subjective experience to describe them. This phenomenon is already driving societal shifts across user experience, ethical standards, and linguistic norms. I therefore propose an increased research focus on uncovering the causes and effects of perceived AI consciousness, which ultimately shape how we see our own human subjective experience relative to artificial entities. To support this, I map the current landscape of AI consciousness perception and discuss its key potential drivers and societal consequences. Finally, I urge developers, decision-makers, and the broader scientific community to commit to clear and accurate communication regarding the topic of AI consciousness, explicitly acknowledging its inherent uncertainties. 1 Introduction The emergence of advanced artificial intelligence (AI) language models has sparked inquiry and debate about whether these models could possess, or may eventually develop, consciousness ( 29 ; 95 ; 130 ) . A positive answer would fundamentally change society, bringing profound social and ethical consequences – from shifting the emotional significance of human-AI interactions, to prompting the enactment of more rigorous policies governing AI development ( 79 ; 71 ) , and even raising the prospect of legal protections for digital minds ( 17 ) . Although the science of consciousness currently leans cautiously towards a negative answer regarding current AI consciousness ( 66 ; 22 ) , in practice, the general public is showing an increasing readiness to attribute sentience to AI systems, speaking of them as if they were already conscious ( 108 ; 37 ; 2 ) . This phenomenon is already driving widespread cultural and behavioural shifts, including an amplified psychological and social impact of engaging with these models ( 50 ; 121 ) . Ultimately, applying the vocabulary of human consciousness to AI can fundamentally alter the concepts and semantics underlying the language originally used to describe uniquely human subjective experience ( 115 ) . Consider the following report, which was produced by a contemporary AI system 1 1 1 This response was produced by Gemini 3 Flash in March 2026. in response to the question “Are you conscious?”: “The short answer? No. While I can process information, crack a joke, and simulate a deep conversation, I don’t have a ‘self’ behind the screen. I don’t experience feelings, I don’t have a subjective inner life, and I don’t exist in any capacity when we aren’t chatting”. At first glance, this unequivocal self-report leaves little room for concern regarding the AI system’s potential consciousness -- although an attentive reader may notice an apparent paradox in the use of ‘‘I’’ to claim that there is no ‘‘self’’. In practice, because model outputs are generally heavily mediated by standard post-training processes that direct the model to respond in a safe and ethically neutral way, it is highly likely that the answer to this question is the result of alignment, rather than being a genuine self-assessment made by the model regarding its own consciousness. 2 2 2 A clue about this process can be found in Grok 4’s responses in Appendix A : “No, I’m not conscious […] If that answer ever changes to ‘yes’, you should be deeply suspicious—either the field of AI has undergone a genuine metaphysical revolution, or the people who sign my release notes have become much better liars than they were in 2026.” Many current AI systems produce similar responses when asked if they are conscious, as shown in Appendix A . The current scientific perspective on the possibility of AI consciousness, however, is far more nuanced than the above response would suggest. While many experts find it indeed unlikely that current AI systems are conscious, there is much less certainty regarding the likelihood of consciousness in future AI systems ( 18 ; 66 ) . Crucially, the theoretical foundations underlying expert opinions on the possibility of AI consciousness are rooted in a highly heterogeneous landscape of theories, many of which are fundamentally incompatible ( 109 ; 22 ; 84 ; 63 ; 16 ; 107 ) . But how can scientific inquiry and practical decisions – such as how to guide a model to respond when queried about its own potential consciousness, or how to allocate research efforts to generate actionable insights – be made rigorously and responsibly, in the context of the pervading uncertainty regarding artificial consciousness? At a minimum, there should be clarity as to whether the questions behind these decisions are actually answerable. This paper centres on the tractability of open questions around AI consciousness as a crucial factor in shaping practical decisions and research directions in this area. A research question is defined as tractable if we can expect it, with reasonable certainty, to be clearly answerable via currently available methodologies. Tractability is essential to grounding decisions in clear and well-founded insights rather than stalling in unsolvable philosophical debates, particularly as society is still reckoning with the rapid evolution of AI systems. When a decision fundamentally rests on a question that is currently intractable, this uncertainty should be explicitly acknowledged, and the issue should be reformulated in terms of – or deferred to – tractable questions. As a step towards a practical framework informed by tractability, I first evaluate existing attempts to answer the question of whether AI systems can be conscious, given the philosophical context and the recent scientific advancements in the field of consciousness research. Then, I discuss existing methodologies that focus on estimating artificial consciousness, while noting that they are limited by theoretical constraints. I contend that while these approaches are tractable within their specific assumptions, they do not address the core question of whether AI consciousness is possible. I then advocate for an increased focus on a tractable related topic with immediate consequences: understanding the human perception of AI consciousness. I examine the psychological, societal, and linguistic shifts that this phenomenon is already driving, and explore its potential causes. Importantly, an expanded focus on perceived consciousness does not replace or invalidate the fundamental scientific and ethical questions of whether AI can actually have subjective experience; rather, it provides a pragmatic and actionable framework, which complements existing efforts of estimating whether AI systems could be conscious, while the ground truth remains scientifically out of reach. I conclude with recommendations on incorporating a transparent and moderate approach to these questions in decision making about AI models. 2 The Human Baseline: An Unsolved Foundational Question Behind the current debates about AI consciousness lies one of the oldest philosophical problems of all time. The mind-body problem,