Exploring TRAPPIST-1 Climate States with an Energy Balance Model
Jacob Haqq-Misra · 2026
Read Exploring TRAPPIST-1 Climate States with an Energy Balance Model by Jacob Haqq-Misra (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-06964.txt.
Introduction
Jacob Haqq-Misra studies possible climates on TRAPPIST-1 e and f, two rocky planets around a small, cool star. He uses a simplified energy balance model, first checked on Earth-like planets, then adapted for worlds locked with one side facing their star. The model is tuned against results from larger climate simulations.
Running the model across different starlight levels and carbon dioxide amounts points to partial ice cover on TRAPPIST-1 e. The second planet stays fully ice covered unless carbon dioxide rises much higher. Haqq-Misra presents the simple model as a guide for costlier simulations and for choosing promising targets to observe.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jacob Haqq-Misra |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.06964
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Exploring TRAPPIST-1 Climate States with an Energy Balance Model Jacob Haqq-Misra Abstract This paper presents a version of the HEXTOR energy balance model that has been configured for the study of habitable terrestrial planets orbiting low-mass stars. The model is validated for rapidly-rotating Earth-like planets using latitudinal coordinates, which shows expected patterns of bistability. A tidally-locked coordinate transformation is then applied to the model, which is calibrated to match mean values of the minimum, average, and maximum surface temperatures from a general circulation model ensemble of TRAPPIST-1 e. This calibrated energy balance model is used to characterize the possible climate states of such a synchronously rotating planet across a parameter space of instellation and carbon dioxide partial pressure. These calculations suggest a state of partial ice cover for TRAPPIST-1 e and complete ice cover for TRAPPIST-1 f, unless carbon dioxide partial pressure is ∼ \sim 1 bar or greater. This approach demonstrates the capability of a simplified one-dimensional model to study the climates of terrestrial planets in synchronous rotation, which can help guide more complex models and observations toward the most promising targets of interest. keywords astrobiology – exoplanet atmospheres – M dwarf stars – habitable planets 1 Introduction Terrestrial planets orbiting low-mass stars remain optimal candidates for discovery and characterization through transit observations (see, e.g., [ 33 ] for a review). M-dwarf stars comprise about three-fourths of the total stellar population of the galaxy, and estimates based on Kepler data suggest that at least half of such systems should contain terrestrial planets within the liquid water habitable zone ( 24 , e.g.,) . Observations with JWST have enabled atmospheric characterization of such systems for the first time, primarily focused on the TRAPPIST-1 planets ( 27 ; 10 , e.g.,) , and continued transit observations will enable more precise constraints on the presence and composition of any atmospheres ( 7 ) . Planning and interpreting observations includes the use of computational climate models, which provide constraints on physically plausible atmospheric configurations and the observational strategies required to characterize them ( 28 , e.g.,) . M-dwarf planets within the liquid water habitable zone may fall into synchronous rotation with their host star, which leads to an atmospheric configuration with one side in perpetual daylight (the dayside or sub-stellar hemisphere) and the other side in perpetual night (the nightside or anti-stellar hemisphere), divided by the terminator in perpetual twilight. Three-dimensional general circulation climate models have shown that a wide variety of such atmospheres are stable, avoiding collapse from the atmosphere freezing out on the night side due to sufficient energy transport by atmospheric dynamics ( 20 ; 19 ; 30 ; 11 ; 4 ; 25 ; 35 ; 9 ; 26 , e.g.,) . Other recent studies have used general circulation models to explore variations in atmospheric properties and construct simulated observed spectra that can provide a basis for interpreting transit observations ( 21 ; 29 ; 1 ; 38 , e.g.,) . General circulation models are complex and computationally expensive, which include explicit calculation of radiative transfer, atmospheric dynamics, and other physical processes. Such models can be useful for studying important problems for Earth and other planets, but the ability to explore large parameter spaces with general circulation models remains computationally challenging. Some studies have performed sparse sampling experiments that attempt to maximize the amount of information gained from a multi-dimensional parameter space while minimizing the number of simulations ( 21 ; 1 ; 38 ) . Another complementary approach is to leverage simpler and more computationally efficient models to explore large parameter spaces; such results can be instructive by themselves and can also provide guidance for the regions of parameter space to study in detail with more complex models. This study presents an updated version of HEXTOR (Habitable Energy balance model for eXoplaneT ObseRvations) for simulating climate states of a TRAPPIST-1 planet in synchronous rotation. Energy balance models (EBMs) are one-dimensional latitudinal models that have traditionally been applied to study climate bistability on Earth ( 31 , e.g.,) , and various EBMs have also been used to study rapidly-rotating (i.e., Earth-like) climates with application to exoplanets ( 8 ; 3 , e.g.,) . The previous version of HEXTOR ( 15 ) implemented a tidally locked coordinate system, which was able to demonstrate a qualitative application of using an EBM to study M-dwarf planetary atmospheres. The version of HEXTOR in this study has been calibrated against results from a general circulation model ensemble of TRAPPIST-1 e ( 32 ) , which represents a first demonstration of the capability of a one-dimensional model to provide quantitative insight on M-dwarf climates. The paper begins by tuning the updated model to pre-industrial Earth conditions, exploring sensitivity to obliquity, and showing the resulting bistable climates for Earth-like planets. The following section utilizes a tidally-locked coordinate transformation to simulate a reference TRAPPIST-1 e case with 1 bar N 2 and 400 ppm CO 2 , calibrated to the results of a general circulation model ensemble. This calibrated model is then used to explore a parameter space spanning instellation and CO 2 partial pressure, which can provide constraints that apply to the characterization of TRAPPIST-1 e and f. 2 Earth Tuning The updated version of HEXTOR presented here uses the same one-dimensional energy balance equation as other Budyko-Sellers-type models ( 31 , e.g.,) : C\frac{\partial T}{\partial t}=S\left(1-\alpha\right)-F+\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\left[D\left(1-x^{2}\right)\frac{\partial T}{\partial t}\right]. (1) This equation calculates the change in surface temperature ( T ) with time ( t ) at each latitudinal band ( x , defined as the sine of latitude). The first term on the right-hand side of Eq. ( 1 ) represents incoming stellar energy, with S as the total instellation and \alpha as the planetary albedo. The term F represents outgoing infrared radiation. The last term in Eq. ( 1 ) is a diffusive latitudinal energy transport, with D representing thermal conductivity. The value of heat capacity ( C ) can vary with land fraction and ice coverage. The core model construction and parameters are unchanged from the previous version of HEXTOR ( 15 ) , which are briefly described here. The model solves Eq. ( 1 ) by using 18 latitudinal bands spaced ten degrees apart, with a \Delta t=12 hr finite differencing time step. Each latitudinal band has a fixed land fraction and is assigned an initialization temperature. Seasonal variation in instellation is captured as a time-dependent function for S , with the mean value of S specified at runtime. Heat capacity, C , is a weighted average based on surface coverage, with a value of C_{\text{land}}=5.25\times 10^{6} J m -2 K -1 for land, C_{\text{ocean}}=40C_{\text{land}} for ocean, and C_{\text{ice}}=2C_{\text{land}} for ice. The diffusive parameter is a constant 0.58 W m -2 K -1 (note that D=0.38 W m -2 K -1 was used by 15 ). The model calculates surface albedo at each latitudinal band (which will be used in the functional forms of \alpha and F discussed next). Surface albedo depends on surface coverage, with a value of 0.2 for unfrozen land, 0.663 for ice, and a zenith-angle dependent value for unfrozen ocean ( 37 ) . The values of planetary albedo and outgoing infrared radiation are obtained by interpolating