Agentic Coding Needs Proactivity, Not Just Autonomy

Nghi D. Q. Bui, Georgios Evangelopoulos · 2026

Read Agentic Coding Needs Proactivity, Not Just Autonomy by Nghi D. Q. Bui, Georgios Evangelopoulos (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-06717.txt.

Introduction

Nghi D. Q. Bui and Georgios Evangelopoulos argue that coding agents need proactivity, not just autonomy. Today's agents already edit repositories, open pull requests, and run scheduled routines. The next step is agents that notice relevant changes before being asked, connect signals across tools, choose when to interrupt, and remember preferences across sessions. Yet proactivity itself lacks a clear definition or measures.

The authors ground the idea in mixed-initiative interaction: what matters is the agent's insight policy, deciding what deserves attention and whether to surface it. They propose three levels of proactivity, compare current agents against five practical criteria, and sketch a user-simulation protocol with three evaluation targets.

Catalog record

CREATORNghi D. Q. Bui, Georgios Evangelopoulos
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.06717

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Agentic Coding Needs Proactivity, Not Just Autonomy Nghi D. Q. Bui, Georgios Evangelopoulos Abstract Coding agents are rapidly changing the landscape of software development, moving from inline completion to autonomous systems that edit repositories, open pull requests, respond to issues, and run scheduled or webhook triggered routines across the development life cycle. The next generation is increasingly described as proactive and long-horizon: agents should notice relevant changes before the developer asks, connect signals across tools, decide when to interrupt, and carry preferences across sessions. Yet the field still lacks a clear account of what proactivity means for software development, how it differs from autonomy, what acceptance criteria proactive long-horizon tasks should satisfy, and which metrics determine whether unsolicited agent behavior is useful rather than merely active. Proactive coding agents should be evaluated by the quality and improvement of their insight policy : the policy that decides what matters next, what evidence supports it, whether to show it, and how to adapt after feedback. This view is grounded in the principles of mixed initiative interaction. We propose a three level taxonomy of proactivity ( Reactive, Scheduled, and Situation Aware ), compare contemporary coding agents against five practical criteria, and sketch an active user simulation protocol with three evaluation targets: Insight Decision Quality (IDQ) , Context Grounding Score (CGS) , and Learning Lift (LL) . † † footnotetext: Correspondence: {nghib, gevang}@google.com 1 Introduction Coding assistants have moved from inline completion to autonomous coding agents that participate in the full software development life cycle (SDLC) ( Tufano et al. 2024 ; Jin et al. 2024 ; Li et al. 2025b ; Hassan et al. 2025 ) . The next shift is toward proactive agents that continuously absorb repository, toolchain, and workflow context, infer what matters from high-level developer needs, identify emerging problems or opportunities, and decide what to do next before a narrowly specified prompt arrives. This trajectory did not happen in one step: language model agents learned to combine reasoning with external actions ( Yao et al. 2023 ) and executable code changes ( Wang et al. 2024a ) ; software engineering gave those agents repository interfaces, real issue-resolution benchmarks, and reusable platforms ( Yang et al. 2024a ; Jimenez et al. 2024 ; Wang et al. 2024b ) ; and deployed tools moved them into the places where developers already work. Claude Code ( Anthropic 2025 ) , OpenAI Codex ( OpenAI 2025a ) , Gemini CLI ( Google 2025a ) , Jules ( Google 2025e ) , Google Antigravity ( Google 2025c ) , and OpenDev ( Bui 2026 ) place agents in terminals, IDEs, repositories, pull requests, and remote virtual machines. The resulting systems can edit files, run commands, inspect failures, and produce patches; the open question is no longer whether an agent can act, but whether it can decide when action should start and which contribution matters next. Recent products also move initiation away from the explicit prompt. Cursor Automations ( Cursor 2026 ; TechCrunch 2026 ) , Claude Code Routines ( Anthropic 2026b ) , and Jules Scheduled Tasks ( Google 2025d ; Jules 2026 ) let coding agents run from schedules, webhooks, GitHub events, integrations, or monitored repository state. These are important triggers, but not yet situation aware proactivity. Triggered runs still differ from agents that notice context shifts on their own, infer whether those shifts matter, and choose whether to notify, question, draft, or stay silent. One stream of work treats proactivity as anticipating useful tasks from user activity and environment state ( Lu et al. 2024 ; Yang et al. 2025b ; Yang et al. 2025a ) ; another treats it as asking before acting on uncertain intent ( Gan et al. 2024 ; Sun et al. 2025 ; Zhou et al. 2026 ) . Both fit the mixed initiative framework of Horvitz 1999 : reason about interruption cost, expected utility, and the benefit of leaving the user in control. Public documentation shows substantial autonomy and trigger coverage, but no clear evidence that production coding agents compute interruption cost, treat silence as an explicit action, or update what they show after developer feedback. Proactive coding agents should be evaluated by the quality and improvement of their insight policy , not by autonomous task completion alone. We call the unit of proactive behavior an insight : a context grounded, time sensitive hypothesis about what matters next for the developer, paired with a decision to notify , question , draft , or stay silent . This makes the central question sharper. A proactive coding agent is not merely an agent that can do more work. It is an agent that learns which potential contributions deserve the developer’s attention, which evidence makes them credible, and which future decisions should change after feedback. To make this gap precise we propose a three level taxonomy, drawn from Horvitz 1999 and Händler 2023 . Level 1, Reactive agents run only when prompted. Level 2, Scheduled agents run from schedules or predefined triggers and may filter, batch, or rank outputs, but do not learn a cross context, per developer interruption policy. Level 3, Situation Aware agents monitor a continuous event stream, compare expected benefit with interruption cost, treat silence as an explicit action, and update a per developer model from feedback. Figure 1 expresses the taxonomy as numbered interaction flows to separate three properties that are easy to conflate: what initiates the agent, whether the developer may respond, and whether that response changes future policy. This distinction matters most for Level 2: scheduled automation may still produce artifacts that developers review, accept, dismiss, or edit, but that response is not equivalent to a learned policy over when to interrupt, ask, draft, or remain silent. The systems audited in Section 4 cluster around Level 2; the gap is judgment: when to interrupt, what to show, and when to remain silent. Figure 1 : Three levels of proactivity as numbered interaction flows. Level 1 begins with a developer prompt and ends after the agent response. Level 2 begins with a predefined schedule or event trigger; the developer may respond to the produced artifact, but this response does not automatically update a learned interruption policy. Level 3 monitors context continuously, chooses between staying silent and showing an insight, and uses developer feedback to update future timing, action selection, and framing. Figure 2 sketches a Level 3 engine: context streams into an engine that maintains development state and a developer mental model, emits insights in the four actions used later (notify, question, draft, stay silent), and learns from response. A Level 3 engine is always deciding, but not always speaking; the quality of its insight policy is what a proactivity benchmark should measure. Figure 2 : Prototype proactive agentic coding engine. Context streams into an engine that maintains development state and a developer model, emits insights (notify, question, draft, stay silent), and learns from response. The contribution is a framework for making proactive coding agents easier to define, compare, and evaluate. Rather than treating proactivity as a loose product label, the paper turns it into a set of design commitments and measurement targets centered on insights, interruption cost, silence, and learning from developer feedback. Concretely,

Read the complete text