Quantifying Trade-Offs Between Stability and Goal-Obfuscation

Yixuan Wang, Dan P. Guralnik, Warren E. Dixon · 2026

Read Quantifying Trade-Offs Between Stability and Goal-Obfuscation by Yixuan Wang, Dan P. Guralnik, Warren E. Dixon (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-06630.txt.

Introduction

Yixuan Wang, Dan P. Guralnik, and Warren E. Dixon study how an autonomous agent can reach its goal without revealing that goal to a watching adversary. Any stable tracking controller is legible: its pull toward a target lets a Bayesian observer concentrate beliefs about the hidden intent. The authors frame intent privacy as a joint control problem over the physical state and the observer's belief state.

The observer runs a particle filter over possible goals, and privacy means keeping information leakage above a set threshold with high probability, enforced through probabilistic barrier functions. Separate results for the filter's update and resampling steps combine into one guarantee. A feasibility analysis then maps where privacy and tracking demands can hold together.

Catalog record

CREATORYixuan Wang, Dan P. Guralnik, Warren E. Dixon
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.06630

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantifying Trade-Offs Between Stability and Goal-Obfuscation Thanks: This research was supported in part by Air Force Office of Scientific Research award number FA9550-22-1-0429. Any opinions, findings and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the sponsoring agency. Yixuan Wang, Dan P. Guralnik, Warren E. Dixon Abstract Safety-critical autonomy in adversarial settings demands more than Lyapunov stability of tracking error signals. An agent executing a goal-directed trajectory is intrinsically legible to a passive observer running online Bayesian inference, because the contractive dynamics of any Lyapunov basin of attraction concentrates posterior belief over the latent intent parameters. This article initiates the study of intent privacy over a continuous state space as a joint control problem on the physical state combined with the latent belief state of a putative observer. With the main challenges concentrated around the analysis of the belief-state dynamics, the agent dynamics is assumed to be simple, modeled by the differential inclusion x ˙ ∈ u + d ¯ ​ 𝔹 \dot{x}\in u+\bar{d}\mathbb{B} . That is, the agent is fully actuated with bounded unknown disturbance to the control input. The observer’s intent inference process is modeled as a discrete-time stochastic dynamical system evolving over the belief state space of a Rao–Blackwellized particle filter (RBPF) reasoning over large random samples of possible agent goals. The agent’s control input is modeled as a piecewise constant signal, with jumps matching the RBPF update times. Building on a prior intent-inference framework and its online-computable, KL-based information leakage measurement, a privacy constraint is imposed, which amounts to maintaining information leakage above a prescribed threshold with high probability, using probabilistic discrete-time control barrier functions (PCBFs). A key technical contribution is the derivation of separate PCBF results for the Bayesian update step and the resampling step of the RBPF, enabling a PCBF result for the full update as well as integration of the privacy constraint with the agent’s task-side tracking requirement. Finally, a joint feasibility analysis is carried out by examining the interplay between the privacy constraint and the tracking envelope. 1 Introduction Control Lyapunov functions and control barrier functions provide a standard mechanism for synthesizing real-time safety critical controllers through online convex programs 1 ; 2 . In this paradigm, a controller is minimally perturbed at each timestep so that the resulting input simultaneously drives a Lyapunov function toward zero and keeps a barrier function nonnegative, yielding joint guarantees of stability and constraint satisfaction through a single quadratic program 1 . The framework has been deployed across a wide range of domains including legged locomotion, adaptive cruise control, and multi-robot coordination 2 . An implicit assumption underlying Lyapunov-based controller synthesis is that closed loop stability is decidedly a desirable property. Classically, the structural aim of Lyapunov-based design is to produce closed loop dynamics with normally hyperbolic invariant manifold (NHIM) structure 8 , in which the basin of attraction decomposes as a product of the goal-parameterized attractor with a normal fiber on which the dynamics acts contractively. Consequently, if the attractor structure is known to (or could be inferred by) an external observer up to a finite-dimensional parameter vector, the contractive geometry of the closed loop trajectories concentrates the observer’s posterior over those parameters with increasing speed as the agent converges to the goal. For a goal-directed agent, the relevant latent parameters are the goal location, goal radius, and desired arrival time, and this legibility problem is exacerbated by the fact that task optimal trajectories are precisely those most concentrated near the attracting manifold. The work of 5 showed that trajectories optimizing a task cost are inherently legible: a Bayesian observer can rapidly concentrate posterior belief over the agent’s goal from a short observation window, and intentional departure from task optimality is necessary to reduce this legibility. Complementary work treats the observer’s inference problem as inverse planning 9 ; 3 or maximum entropy inverse reinforcement learning 12 , confirming that goal-stabilizing trajectories are informationally richest in precisely the regimes where Lyapunov methods are most effective. Prior work 11 formalized and quantified this legibility for continuous-state systems of the form studied here. There, the adversary models the agent’s intent and maintains N\gg 0 weighted particles to recursively estimate the agent’s intent from noisy position measurements via a Rao-Blackwellized particle filter (RBPF), demonstrating that under nominal conditions the adversary rapidly recovers the agent’s true intent, underscoring the practical severity of the legibility problem for any agent operating under Lyapunov-based control. The present paper addresses the control synthesis question left open by 11 : given a capable adversary running the RBPF inference framework, how should the agent select its control input to delay inference concentration while simultaneously satisfying task stability and tracking requirements? Contributions. The contributions of this paper are as follows. First, the intent privacy task is formulated as a piecewise constant (intermittent actuation) control problem over the latent belief dynamics on the probability simplex induced by RBPF weight updates (extended by the RBPF’s state estimation variables), rather than as an auxiliary objective on the physical state. Second, a finite horizon privacy-in-probability guarantee for the RBPF update cycle is derived. The technical challenge of analyzing the resampling step is overcome by observing that the RBPF update may be regarded as the composition of two probabilistically independent random transformations of the belief state space: the Bayesian update, and the resampling step. Probabilistic bounds on the increment in information leakage are derived for each of these transformations, and combined into a PCBF result for the overall RBPF update, following the PCBF framework developed in 7 . It is noteworthy that the bound for the resampling transformation is completely independent of the dynamics and control input, motivating future work on extensions to more complex dynamics of the agent. Third, a joint feasibility analysis is carried out, examining the interplay between the privacy constraint and the tracking constraint via affine interpolation between two types of control input, one selected for obfuscation and the other for optimized tracking. The tensions between the constraints are revealed as inequality constraints on the interpolation parameter, which may be seen to be jointly feasible when the prescribed tracking error envelope is not overly restrictive. Further study of convergence properties of the RBPF is necessary to produce results establishing the infeasibility of obfuscation if practical stability of tracking errors is enforced. 2 Background This article leans mainly on development from two sources. Section 2.1 reviews 11 , where RBPFs for intent inference were introduced. Section 2.2 reviews necessary results from 7 on probabilistic barrier functions. 2.1 Intent Inference Intent Model. The agent’s intent is modeled as a triple \theta^{{\ast}}\triangleq(x^{{\ast}},r^{{\ast}},t^{{\ast}}) , constrained to a compact domain \Theta , where x^{{\ast}}\in\mathds{R}^{n} is the goal center, r^{{\ast}}>0 is the goal radius, and t^{{\ast}}>0 is the desired arrival time; the corresponding goal set is the ball x^{{\ast}}+r^{{\ast}}\mathbb{B} , which the agent aims to reach by time t^{{\ast}} . The adversary assumes that, if the (unknown) intent were \theta , then the agent’s closed-loop motion is goal-stabilizing up to an unknown disturbance bounded in norm by a known \bar{d} : \dot{\hat{x}}\in f_{\theta}(\hat{x})+\bar{d}\mathbb{B},\quad f_{\theta}(\hat{x})\triangleq-\lambda(\theta)(\hat{x}-x(\theta)), where \lambda(\theta)\triangleq\max\left\{\frac{\bar{d}}{r(\theta)},\frac{1}{t(\theta)}\log\frac{R}{r(\theta)}\right\} , ensuring that the agent will enter the goal ball x^{{\ast}}+r^{{\ast}}\mathbb{B} by time t^{{\ast}} . RBPF

Read the complete text