Formal Stability of Tetrahedral Non-Zonal Flows on the Sphere
Yuri Cacchiò · 2026
Read Formal Stability of Tetrahedral Non-Zonal Flows on the Sphere by Yuri Cacchiò (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-06453.txt.
Introduction
Yuri Cacchiò studies the formal stability of non-zonal flows that branch off from rest in the two-dimensional Euler equations on a sphere. Such flows model large-scale planetary motion. Degeneracy in the spherical Laplacian and low-frequency instabilities make direct analysis hard, so the work restricts attention to a tetrahedral symmetry subspace.
Using Arnold's Energy-Casimir method, Cacchiò shows the linearized operator acts as the Hessian of a conserved functional. Tracking a critical eigenvalue along the branches classifies four profile families: polynomial and sine-Gordon flows achieve formal stability, while sinh-Gordon and Liouville flows form saddle points and are unstable. The result links branch shape to how long coherent waves last.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yuri Cacchiò |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.06453
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Formal Stability of Tetrahedral Non-Zonal Flows on the Sphere Yuri Cacchiò Abstract We investigate the formal stability of finite-amplitude non-zonal flows bifurcating from the trivial state in the unforced 2D Euler equations on the sphere. To bypass the degeneracy of the spherical Laplacian and filter out the low-frequency Fjørtoft instabilities, we restrict the functional space to the invariant subspace of the tetrahedral symmetry group. Using Arnold’s Energy-Casimir method, we prove that the linearized elliptic operator derived via Liapunov-Schmidt reduction acts as the Hessian of the conserved functional. By tracking the critical eigenvalue along the bifurcating branches via the Crandall-Rabinowitz theorem, we establish a relation between the bifurcation topology and formal stability. Applying this framework to four distinct geophysical profile functions, we demonstrate that subcritical polynomial and supercritical sine-Gordon flows achieve a negative-definite second variation, that is, their formal stability. In contrast, subcritical sinh-Gordon and supercritical Liouville exponential flows generate saddle points, making them unstable. This classification identifies the specific nonlinear interactions required for the persistence of large-scale coherent waves in planetary atmospheres. Keywords: 2D Euler equations; formal stability; Crandall-Rabinowitz stability; Energy-Casimir method; tetrahedral symmetry; non-zonal flows. 1 Introduction The formation and propagation of large-scale coherent structures in planetary atmospheres are modeled by the incompressible 2D Euler equations on the rotating sphere \mathbb{S}^{2} [ 8 , 16 , 24 , 25 ] . Let the physical domain be parameterized by longitude \varphi\in[0,2\pi) and latitude \theta\in\left(-\frac{\pi}{2},\frac{\pi}{2}\right) , with the polar axis denoted by x_{3}=\sin\theta . In a rotating frame with constant angular velocity \omega , the evolution of the stream function \psi(t,\varphi,\theta) is governed by the conservation of vorticity [ 20 ] , \partial_{t}(\Delta\psi)+J(\psi,\Delta\psi+2\omega x_{3})=0. (1.1) Here, the linear term 2\omega x_{3} represents the Coriolis parameter. The relative scalar vorticity is given by the spherical Laplace-Beltrami operator, written as \Delta\psi=\frac{1}{\cos\theta}\frac{\partial}{\partial\theta}\left(\cos\theta\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial\theta}\right)+\frac{1}{\cos^{2}\theta}\frac{\partial^{2}\psi}{\partial\varphi^{2}} (1.2) and the spherical Jacobian is defined as J(f,g)=\frac{1}{\cos\theta}(\partial_{\varphi}f\partial_{\theta}g-\partial_{\theta}f\partial_{\varphi}g). (1.3) Steady geophysical flows, such as atmospheric jet streams, are characterized by stationary condition \partial_{t}=0 . This assumption requires the stream function and the vorticity to commute, J(\psi,\Delta\psi+2\omega x_{3})=0. (1.4) Following Arnold’s argument [ 1 ] and the rigorous formulations of Constantin and Johnson [ 7 ] , the absence of Jacobian implies that, wherever \nabla\psi\neq 0 , the absolute vorticity is a functional of the stream function. This relation ensures the existence of a sufficiently smooth function F satisfying the nonlinear elliptic equation -\Delta\psi+F(\psi)=2\omega x_{3}. (1.5) The simplest solutions to ( 1.5 ) are zonal flows , which depend only on the latitudinal coordinate x_{3} [ 21 , 25 ] . However, at critical parameter thresholds, these symmetric states can undergo spontaneous symmetry breaking, generating two-dimensional, non-zonal Rossby-Haurwitz waves [ 14 , 22 ] via local bifurcation. The classical stability of these planetary waves has been investigated through numerical and spectral methods [ 4 , 17 ] . Analyzing this symmetry-breaking mechanism directly in the rotating frame is challenging because of the asymmetry introduced by the Coriolis force. To isolate the nature of the bifurcation, we adopt the reduction strategy of Constantin and Germain [ 6 ] by passing to the non-rotating limit ( \omega=0 ). In this regime, the problem simplifies to the unforced semilinear equation -\Delta\psi+F(\lambda,\psi)=0\quad\text{on }\mathbb{S}^{2}, (1.6) where the non-linearity is parameterized by the bifurcation variable \lambda\in\mathbb{R} , under the trivial-branch condition F(\lambda,0)=0 . Notice that this irrotational simplification does not compromise physical relevance. Constantin and Germain [ 6 ] established that any stationary solution \psi_{0}(\varphi,\theta) of the non-rotating problem ( 1.6 ) corresponds to a non-zonal traveling wave on the rotating sphere via the transformation \psi_{\omega}(\varphi,\theta,t)=\psi_{0}(\varphi+\omega t,\theta)+\omega x_{3}. (1.7) This mapping ensures that our analysis of stationary states at \omega=0 characterizes planetary waves propagating westward with a phase velocity c=\omega relative to the planetary surface. A central problem in this framework is the stability of the finite-amplitude non-zonal flows emerging from ( 1.6 ). It is a well-known consequence of Fjørtoft’s theorem [ 11 , 25 ] and Arnold’s classical nonlinear stability criteria [ 2 , 1 ] that stationary flows dominated by spherical harmonics of degree l\geq 2 act as saddle points in the energy-enstrophy invariant manifold. Consequently, these high-frequency structures are unstable to large-scale, low-frequency perturbations. In a previous work [ 5 ] , we investigated the emergence of these solutions from the trivial state. To bypass the (2l+1) -dimensional kernel degeneracy of the spherical Laplacian, which prohibits the direct application of classical local bifurcation theorems [ 9 , 19 ] , we restricted the functional space to the invariant subspace of the tetrahedral symmetry group \mathbf{T} using equivariant bifurcation theory [ 13 ] . This constraint filters out the large-scale asymmetric modes and collapses the null space to a single dimension spanned by the l=3 real tetrahedral harmonic Y^{*} . By applying a Liapunov-Schmidt reduction, we demonstrated that the topology of the resulting bifurcating branches, \psi(\varepsilon)=\varepsilon Y^{*}+\mathcal{O}(\varepsilon^{2}) , is strictly determined by the chosen non-linearity F(\lambda,\psi) and the mass constraint. Specifically, we proved that generalized polynomial and sinh-Gordon models bifurcate subcritically, whereas sine-Gordon and Liouville exponential models bifurcate supercritically. Having established the existence and the geometry of these tetrahedral non-zonal flows, the aim of the present paper is to evaluate their robustness against perturbations, a property we define as tetrahedral formal stability . Because the geometric restriction to the tetrahedral subgroup projects out the unstable low-frequency modes l=1,2 , it provides a mathematical setting to test the stability of the l=3 bifurcating branches without the onset of Fjørtoft’s instability. Since the 2D Euler equations describe a conservative Hamiltonian system [ 3 ] , stability cannot be established by treating the dynamics as a standard gradient flow. Instead, we evaluated it through the second variation of the Arnold Energy-Casimir functional. In this paper, we prove that, when restricted to the invariant subspace X_{\mathbf{T}} , the linearized elliptic operator resulting from the Liapunov-Schmidt reduction acts as the second variation of the Energy-Casimir functional. Employing the Crandall-Rabinowitz theorem [ 10 ] , we trace the critical eigenvalue \mu(\varepsilon) of the differential operator along the bifurcating curves. This spectral link allows us to relate the bifurcation direction to the definiteness of the restricted Energy-Casimir functional. By evaluating the polynomial, sine-Gordon, sinh-Gordon, and exponential tetrahedral flows, we demonstrate that formal stability is not governed by the bifurcation topology alone. Our analysis reveals that both subcritical and supercritical branches can achieve formal stability, depending on the nonlinear interactions governing the perturbation of the critical eigenvalue. The organization of this paper is as follows. In Section 2 , we introduce the Arnold Energy-Casimir functional, define the criteria for formal stability on the restricted tetrahedral subspace, and state the main stability theorem. Section 3 is devoted to the rigorous proof of the main result, utilizing a perturbative spectral expansion to link the geometric Hessian to the Crandall-Rabinowitz bifurcation framework. In Section 4 , we apply this criterion to evaluate the formal stability of the four geophysical profile functions. Finally, Section 5 provides a summary and discusses the physical implications of these stability classifications. 2 Preliminaries and Main Result 2.1 Energy-Casimir Functional and Formal Stability In dissipative systems, the derivative of the stationary problem often acts as the linearized operator, making its spectrum sufficient to determine asymptotic linear stability. However, the 2D Euler equations