Higher-order interactions in ecology can be hidden in plain sight
Violeta Calleja-Solanas, Santiago Lamata-Otín, Carlos Gómez-Ambrosi, Jesús Gómez-Gardeñes, Sandro Meloni · 2026
Read Higher-order interactions in ecology can be hidden in plain sight by Violeta Calleja-Solanas, Santiago Lamata-Otín, Carlos Gómez-Ambrosi, Jesús Gómez-Gardeñes, Sandro Meloni (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-06301.txt.
Introduction
Violeta Calleja-Solanas and four co-authors show that higher order interactions in ecosystems can hide behind ordinary pairwise models. Ecologists increasingly treat group interactions, where several species jointly shape each other's growth, as a key part of community dynamics. The natural hope is that rich abundance time series can reveal whether such higher order effects are at work in a given system.
The authors show that higher order Lotka-Volterra dynamics can often be reproduced accurately by an effective pairwise model fitted to the same data. Higher order structure therefore cannot, in general, be inferred from time series alone. Distinct mechanisms can generate nearly identical dynamics, a problem of mechanistic identifiability that risks accurate yet misleading readings. Time series need support from other ecological information before interaction structure can be trusted.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Violeta Calleja-Solanas, Santiago Lamata-Otín, Carlos Gómez-Ambrosi, Jesús Gómez-Gardeñes, Sandro Meloni |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.06301
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Higher-order interactions in ecology can be hidden in plain sight Violeta Calleja-Solanas, Santiago Lamata-Otín, Carlos Gómez-Ambrosi, Jesús Gómez-Gardeñes, Sandro Meloni Abstract Higher-order interactions are increasingly recognized as a key component of ecological dynamics. However, we show that higher-order Lotka–Volterra dynamics can, in some scenarios, be accurately reproduced by effective pairwise models fitted to the same abundance time series. Consequently, higher-order interactions cannot, in general, be inferred from time-series data alone. We further identify a fundamental problem of mechanistic identifiability, whereby distinct interaction mechanisms generate nearly indistinguishable dynamics, potentially leading to accurate yet misleading ecological interpretations. Our results highlight the need to complement time-series data with additional ecological information to infer interaction structure reliably. Introduction Higher-order interactions (HOIs) in ecology attracted much attention in ecological research several decades ago, in part because their nonlinearity promised greater realism than the classical pairwise Lotka–Volterra equations 1 ; 7 . After their popularity waned amid debates over their definition 38 ; 46 and their inference 10 ; 47 , HOIs are currently enjoying a revival 17 ; 6 ; 14 . The renewed interest is reflected in empirical and semi-empirical studies that increasingly incorporate HOI terms into phenomenological models fit to data 9 ; 8 . The original quarrels about their definition and interpretation in nature are slowly settling. Higher-order interactions broadly refer to non-additive effects of density on per capita growth 25 . HOIs derive from mechanisms that exist only when three or more species are present. Then, group interactions, multivariate interactions, and interaction modifications fall under the umbrella of HOIS. 20 ; 39 . In parallel, recent theoretical work has clarified that HOIs can stabilize dynamics in multispecies communities 5 ; 15 ; 17 and be a predictor of community dynamics 34 . However, the rationale for adding HOIs to models used to fit data is rarely justified, and doing so moves us away from parsimonious descriptions based on a minimal set of ecologically meaningful parameters 3 ; 2 . Even though Nature rarely operates in an additive fashion 43 , our models should be based on a set of parameters identified by the researchers as meaningful, including, when necessary, covariates and higher-order terms, but with as few parameters as possible (being as simple as possible, but no simpler). Critically, when comparing a more complex model with HOIs to an effective pairwise one, the inclusion of higher-order terms almost always improves explanatory power in a statistical sense 4 . Any claimed biological role for a higher-order mechanism must therefore be weighed against the baseline expectation that additional flexibility improves predictive power even in the absence of true HO mechanisms 20 ; 22 . In practice, HOIs are often inferred by extending generalized Lotka–Volterra equations with higher-order terms and fitting them to time series of species abundances 29 ; 13 ; 32 ; 35 , or fitting to a model of interaction data/neighborhoods 9 . The key difficulty is that standard tools of model comparison and goodness of fit are silent about mechanistic identifiability: they indicate which model fits better, but not whether HOIs are genuinely required or simply absorbed into effective pairwise interactions that yield almost-indistinguishable dynamics. Implicitly, these fittings assume that given sufficiently rich data, we can decide whether the underlying dynamics is fundamentally pairwise or genuinely higher-order. However, this assumption has rarely been examined in its most favorable light. Suppose we are in an idealized setting with high-resolution abundance trajectories, no observation error, and full control over the functional form of the model. Under such conditions, one might expect identifiability to be limited only by data quantity or by the magnitude of HOI effects. Here we ask the disquieting question: even under these idealized conditions, can the presence or absence of HOIs always be deduced from abundance dynamics alone? To address this question, we developed a systematic computational pipeline to test whether higher-order interactions leave a unique, detectable dynamical signature. Using second-order Lotka-Volterra systems as our general framework, we generated in silico, high-resolution time series of species abundances for communities with known higher-order interactions. We then inferred a standard pairwise Lotka-Volterra model from the same data by evaluating the per capita growth rates from these trajectories and fitting them to a hyperplane. Finally, we integrated this pairwise system and compared its resulting dynamics, attractors, and interaction coefficients against those of the original higher-order model to determine if the underlying mechanisms could be distinguished. We show that the answer to our question is no: even under ideal observation conditions, the presence of HOIs cannot always be deduced from abundance dynamics alone. We constructed scenarios in which dynamics with substantial HOIs can be approximated with striking accuracy by a pairwise model to the same time series. Furthermore, the inferred pairwise model not only reproduces the observed trajectories but also assigns qualitatively different ecological roles to species, reversing the direction or sign of their interactions. These phenomena reflect a fundamental problem of structural non-identifiability: along a given trajectory, higher-order contributions can be flattened into effective pairwise coefficients. Consequently, HOIs are practically invisible to time-series inference, meaning standard pairwise fits can yield compelling but mechanistically different ecological interpretations, making the presence of HOIs intrinsically model-dependent rather than empirically decidable 28 . The practical cost of this invisibility is highest precisely when we care most about the consequences of interventions, biological invasions, climate anomalies, or management actions —because models may fail when the system is forced into regions of state space where higher-order effects become decisive. Figure 1: Workflow to assess whether higher-order interactions are detectable from abundance time series. From the time series of abundances obtained by integrating the original higher-order system, we evaluate the per capita growth rates, fit them to a hyperplane to infer interaction coefficients and intrinsic growth rates, and integrate the resulting pairwise system. The final comparison between the inferred and original dynamics reveals whether higher-order interactions are detectable. Material and methods Pairwise and higher-order Lotka-Volterra models We begin by recalling the pairwise (generalized) and higher-order Lotka-Volterra models, and then explain how to obtain a pairwise Lotka-Volterra model from a time series of species abundances generated by a higher-order Lotka-Volterra model. We consider a population of n interacting species whose dynamics is governed by a system of ecological (or Kolmogorov) equations 40 ; 36 of the form \dot{N}_{i}=N_{i}F_{i}(N_{1},\ldots,N_{n}),\quad i=1,\ldots,n, (1) where N_{i} is the abundance of species i , \dot{N}_{i} its time derivative, i.e. the growth rate of species i , and F_{i} a sufficiently smooth function that encodes the per capita growth rate ( \dot{N}_{i}/N_{i} ) of species i . In the simplest case of the generalized Lotka-Volterra (gLV) equations, F_{i}(N_{1},\ldots,N_{n})=r_{i}+\sum_{j}a_{ij}N_{j}, (2) where r_{i} is the intrinsic growth rate of species i , and a_{ij} measures the direct effect of species j on the per capita growth rate of species i . The intra-specific coefficient a_{ii} accounts for the self-regulation of species i , whereas the inter-specific coefficients a_{ij} , for j\not=i , account for the pairwise interactions between species. Depending on the signs of a_{ij} and a_{ji} , these interactions are interpreted as predator-prey (+\,-) , competitive (-\,-) , mutualistic (+\,+) , etc. The matrix A=(a_{ij}) is the interaction matrix of the system, and the vector \mathbf{r}=(r_{1},\ldots,r_{n}) is