When AI Meets Science: Research Diversity, Interdisciplinarity, Visibility, and Retractions across Disciplines in a Global Surge

Andrés F. Castro-Torres, Joan Giner-Miguelez, Mercè Crosas · 2026

Read When AI Meets Science: Research Diversity, Interdisciplinarity, Visibility, and Retractions across Disciplines in a Global Surge by Andrés F. Castro-Torres, Joan Giner-Miguelez, Mercè Crosas (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-06033.txt.

Introduction

Andrés Castro Torres, Joan Giner-Miguelez, and Mercè Crosas measure how artificial intelligence has spread through global science. They analyze over 227 million scholarly works from OpenAlex, spanning 1960 to 2024 across four domains and 46 fields. A two step classification pipeline separates real use of AI as a method from mere mentions of AI terms.

Adoption grew in an exponential pattern after 2015, but stayed tied to a few topics close to computer science and standard statistics. AI supported work drew an unwarranted citation premium and faced much higher retraction rates than other work. Wealthy countries lead in AI papers per person, while a belt of global South countries leads in adoption relative to national output. The authors urge better practice on openness and ethics.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrés F. Castro-Torres, Joan Giner-Miguelez, Mercè Crosas
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE79 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY SA
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.06033

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

When AI Meets Science: Research Diversity, Interdisciplinarity, Visibility, and Retractions across Disciplines in a Global Surge Andrés F. Castro-Torres, Joan Giner-Miguelez, Mercè Crosas Abstract The extent to which Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies can trigger generalized paradigm shifts in science is unclear. Although these technologies have revolutionized data collection and analysis in specific fields, their overall impact depends on the scope and ways of adoption. We analyze over 227 million scholarly works from the OpenAlex collection (1960-2024) spanning four scientific domains and 46 fields. To distinguish the use of AI as research method (AI adoption) from mentioning AI-related terms (AI engagement), we developed a two-step AI-assisted semantic classification pipeline, validated through human coding of 911 abstracts and a robustness check on 348,000 full-text articles (PLOS One). We document differences in the timing and extent of AI adoption across domains, with generalized exponential growth after 2015. The transformative nature of this growth, however, is less apparent. AI-supported research is confined to a few topics with strong ties to Computer Science and conventional statistical frameworks, suggesting limited epistemological transformation. It is also associated with an unwarranted citation premium and substantially higher retraction rates than non-AI-supported. Geographically, while wealthy countries lead in AI publications per capita, global South countries in a belt from Indonesia to Algeria lead in AI adoption relative to their national output, signaling a distinctive resource concentration pattern. The transformative capacity of AI in science thus remains untapped, and its rapid adoption underlines challenges in research openness, transparency, reproducibility, and ethics. We discuss how best research practices could boost the benefits of AI adoption and highlight areas that warrant closer scrutiny. [ orcid=0000-0003-1032-3869, email= [email protected]] [orcid=0000-0003-2335-6977, [email protected] ] [orcid=0000-0003-1304-1939, [email protected] ] keywords Artificial Intelligence ,Scientific Discovery ,Global Science ,Research Integrity ,Bibliometrics † † copyrightyear: 2026 † † copyright: Copyright for this paper by its authors. Use permitted under Creative Commons License Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0). † † address: Computational Social Science and Humanities, Barcelona Supercomputing Center, BSC-CNS, Barcelona, Spain † † address: Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research, Rostock, Germany † † venue: Preprint article 1 Introduction Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies are influencing multiple sectors of society, including scientific research mitchell 2020 , driving a rapid increase in AI developments, adoption, and debate within academia. The existing literature, however, presents mixed arguments on the potential of AI for scientific innovation and discovery, with perspectives that range from enthusiasm and cautious optimism to skepticism, criticism, dissent, refutation, and outright rejection Guest et al. 2025 ; Channing and Ghosh 2025 ; Sourati and Evans 2023 ; Messeri and Crockett 2024 ; Bender et al. 2021 ; Swanson et al. 2025 ; Channing and Ghosh 2026 . The 2024 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, awarded to Hassabis, Jumper, and Baker for breakthroughs in protein structure prediction and design, epitomized the optimistic pole of this debate and amplified expectations about AI’s widespread adoption in research Wang et al. 2023 . More skeptical voices, however, have highlighted the potential pitfalls of AI adoption, including power imbalances vis-à-vis big tech corporations, the dehumanizing consequences of some AI technologies (primarily so-called generative AI), the ethical aspects of data collection and use for model training, and the environmental implications of the infrastructure that supports these technologies Bender and Hanna 2025 ; Crawford 2021 ; Denton et al. 2021 . The lack of a widely accepted definition of what AI is, and the fact that the term has been used to group a multiplicity of things from automatic translation tools, classification and clustering methods to expert systems, and more recently, Large Language Models (LLM), further complicates the conversion Guest et al. 2025 . As depicted metaphorically in Figure 1 , AI technologies are diverse from roots to stems, branches, and fruits implying different user types and diverging levels of engagement from developers to end users. In this proposed conceptualization of AI technologies, AI adoption in science corresponds to the underneath part of the tree mainly driven by AI developments and applications for data collection, processing, and analysis, all of which imply a deep understanding of the theoretical, technical and social implications of AI applications. Importantly, critical perspectives, represented by the three’s split appearance, spread along the engagement distribution from critical adopters and critical users including those who reject specific uses of these technologies, speaking of AI’s susceptibility to create contrasting views at all levels. Figure 1: Artificial Intelligence users’ typology along engagement levels and use examples. The tree represents the collection of AI technologies, including its roots on basic research and technology development which nurture AI adoption in science represented by the “Adopters and Engaged users” category. The tree’s stem represents policy makers, government, and other regulatory institutions which we deem crucial for developing responsible AI-based products and services offered by multiple companies (tree’s branches). In contrast to researchers and technology developers (tree’s roots), end users’ engagement with AI, defined as the level of understanding of how the supporting AI systems, models and methods work, is minimum. The two-sided color of the tree represents contrasting views across all user types, from rejection to critiques to heightened optimism, that are very apparent in existing literature, social media, and public discussions. The fundamental role played by AI in the 2024 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, awarded to Hassabis, Jumper, and Baker for breakthroughs in protein structure prediction and design, epitomized the potential of AI for science and it increased the already heightened optimism about its widespread adoption in research Wang et al. 2023 . More skeptical voices, however, have also highlighted the potential pitfalls and shortcomings of AI adoption including the influence and power imbalances vis a vis big tech corporations, the dehumanizing consequences of some AI technologies (primarily the so-called generative AI), as well as the ethical aspects of data collection and usage for models’ training and the environmental implications of the infrastructure that supports AI technologies Bender and Hanna 2025 ; Crawford 2021 ; Denton et al. 2021 . The lack of a widely accepted definition of what AI is, and the fact that the term has been used to group a multiplicity of things from automatic translation tools, classification and clustering methods to expert systems, and more recently, Large Language Models (LLM), further complicates the conversion Guest et al. 2025 . As depicted metaphorically in Figure 1 , AI technologies are diverse from roots to stems, branches, and fruits implying different user types and diverging levels of engagement from developers to end users. In this proposed conceptualization of AI technologies, AI adoption in science corresponds to the underneath part of the tree mainly driven by AI developments and applications for data collection, processing, and analysis, all of which imply a deep understanding of the theoretical, technical and social implications of AI applications. Importantly, critical perspectives, represented by the two-side colors, spread along the engagement distribution from critical adopters and critical users including those who reject specific uses of these technologies, speaking of AI’s susceptibility to create contrasting views at all levels. Despite these contrasting views and diverse engagement levels, scholars with both enthusiastic and critical perspectives on AI would agree that its most durable impacts in science are likely to come from adopters and engaged users, as the Nobel

Read the complete text