Classical General Relativity as a Non-Conservative Action-Dependent Field Theory

Callum Bell, David Sloan · 2026

Read Classical General Relativity as a Non-Conservative Action-Dependent Field Theory by Callum Bell, David Sloan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-05817.txt.

Introduction

General relativity is usually written as a textbook theory, but Callum Bell and David Sloan recast it in first-order form as an action-dependent, non-conservative one. They apply earlier results on scaling symmetries for theories with special Lagrangians. Einstein's theory splits into conformal spacetime geometry plus a dissipative sector.

The dissipative part makes up for removing scale, which the conformal factor normally encodes. The linearized equations give the free wave equation one expects for metric ripples. At second order, covering gravity's backreaction, the behavior departs from the standard story in ways the authors examine.

Catalog record

CREATORCallum Bell, David Sloan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE88 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.05817

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Classical General Relativity as a Non-Conservative Action-Dependent Field Theory Callum Bell, David Sloan Abstract Scaling symmetries have previously been examined for classical field theories described by singular Lagrangians; in this article, we apply these results to the first-order formulation of General Relativity. It is shown that the dynamical content of the Hilbert action may be formulated in terms of the conformal spacetime geometry, together with a dissipative sector, which is required in order to compensate the elimination of the notion of scale encoded by the conformal factor. Further, we consider the linearisation of the equations of motion of the scale-invariant action, demonstrating that the first-order metric perturbations satisfy a free wave equation, as expected. The second-order dynamics, describing gravitational backreaction, are found to be sourced by quadratic combinations of the first-order perturbations. However, these dynamics are non-conservative, as is made manifest by the presence of terms which couple the action sector with the geometrical degrees of freedom. I Introduction As a classical field theory, General Relativity may be formulated in a variety of equivalent ways, each highlighting a different structural aspect of the theory. Amongst these diverse formulations, those in which the conformal mode - representing a local choice of ‘metre stick’ - is treated separately are particularly interesting, both in classical and quantum contexts brown2005conformal ; york1973conformally . In such approaches, the remaining geometrical degrees of freedom are contained within a symmetric covariant tensor of rank two, whose components describe the conformal structure of the underlying spacetime. In parallel, there has been growing interest in non-conservative extensions of classical field theory, such as those based on Herglotz variational principles cannarsa2019herglotz , in which the action itself is incorporated into the space of dynamical variables. These frameworks are naturally able to capture dissipative or non-conservative effects, that cannot be replicated by adding terms to a standard Lagrangian. Such theories have recently been explored in gravitational settings gaset2022variational ; lazo2017action ; however, the nature of the action dependence of these models is relatively simplistic, and somewhat lacks physical motivation. In this work, we combine the above-mentioned ideas, studying a reformulation of General Relativity, in which the conformal degree of freedom is identified as redundant, from the perspective of the closure of the algebra of dynamical observables. This observation allows us to eliminate the conformal factor, passing to a description which is dynamically equivalent to standard General Relativity, but exhibits a reduced gauge symmetry and a non-conservative structure. This is made manifest within both the Lagrangian and the corresponding field equations through their action dependence. Our objective is to present this novel construction, and to analyse its implications, which we do both generically at the level of the field theory, as well as in the particular setting of gravitational wave dynamics. The first part of our work contains the required background material, with section ( III ) introducing the notion of scaling symmetries, and how the presence of such symmetries allows a reduction process to be carried out. Following this, sections ( IV ) and ( V ) detail the first-order formulation of General Relativity, expressed in frame field variables, together with the geometrical setting in which we shall make the symmetry reduction. The main results of our work, in which we obtain a first-order action-dependent description of General Relativity, are the subject of section ( VI ). As explained here, working with the first-order formalism is somewhat of a formal requirement, for the multisymplectic bundle corresponding to the velocity phase space is the first jet bundle over the space of fields. In this way, in order for the reduction process to be mathematically well-defined, we are in some sense obliged to work within the first-order formalism. However, having made the reduction, there is no impediment to our passing to the second-order metric formalism, which is both more familiar and convenient. Indeed, in section ( VII ), we recover the second-order formalism, expressed exclusively in terms of the metric and its derivatives. From the corresponding action, we compute the field equations, which are shown to contain precisely the same dynamical information as the more standard G_{\mu\nu}=0 expression. Finally, as an interesting application of our work, we consider the linearisation of the above-mentioned field equations around a flat background. In particular, we find that, at first order, the dynamics of the perturbation are unaffected by the action-dependent nature of our theory. The sole effect of this ‘dissipative’ sector is to reorganise the gauge degrees of freedom. At second order, by contrast, where the corresponding perturbation is associated with gravitational backreaction, we do encounter qualitative modifications from the presence of the action-density sector. Unlike the standard picture, in which the self-interaction of gravitational waves can be described in terms of an effective conserved energy-momentum tensor, here the dynamics are intrinsically non-conservative. The exchange of energy between the metric perturbations and the action degrees of freedom leads to a qualitatively different interpretation of gravitational wave propagation. We emphasise that such differences are wholly interpretational - our construction is, mathematically speaking, identical in dynamical content to standard General Relativity. We then conclude our work with a brief summary of the results obtained, together with a discussion of interesting lines of further investigation. II Leibniz’s Principle: The Identity of Indiscernibles Whilst philosophical argumentation is frequently used in conjunction with physical insight, there are several notable instances in which the deduction of natural law has only been possible because of philosophical reasoning. In the current context, we refer to a principle due to Leibniz, known as the Identity of Indiscernibles leibniz1989discourse . This posits that if one has a theory that grants ontological distinction to two scenarios, for which the outcome of all measurements is identical, and whose differences lie solely within unobservable features, then this theory should be rejected, or at least considered non-fundamental. Such reasoning was employed most notably by Einstein in reference to accelerating frames of reference. In particular, the Equivalence Principle is an inevitable (albeit highly non-trivial) consequence of the refusal to grant ontological significance to unobservable differences between physical scenarios. An accelerating frame is indistinguishable from one which experiences a local gravitational field (of magnitude equal to the acceleration it induces), and so any theory which deems accelerating frames to be ontologically separate from those subject to a gravitational field should not be considered a faithful description of reality. The recurrent success of this line of philosophical argumentation is the principal motivation behind our study of a class of symmetry known as dynamical similarities sloan2018dynamical . Mathematically, the deduction of the dynamics of a classical system may be considered an exercise in either functional extremisation or symplectic geometry; whilst not independent of one another, it is useful to consider each of them separately. From the extremisation perspective, it is often found that certain combinations of rescalings of the canonical variables (e.g x\rightarrow\lambda^{2}x , \dot{y}\rightarrow\lambda^{-1}\dot{y} , for \lambda\in\mathbb{R} ) have the sole effect of transforming the Lagrange density by an overall multiplicative factor ( \mathcal{L}\rightarrow\lambda^{\Lambda}\mathcal{L} ). Such a rescaled object clearly shares its extremal points with the original Lagrange density, and so describes the same classical dynamics. From the symplectic viewpoint, the rescaled variables are not merely a reparameterisation, or change of coordinates, but

Read the complete text