On the Emergence of Pendular Structure in Multi-Contact Locomotion

Lingxue Lyu, Zihui Liu · 2026

Read On the Emergence of Pendular Structure in Multi-Contact Locomotion by Lingxue Lyu, Zihui Liu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-05707.txt.

Introduction

Walking controllers almost always assume a pendulum model of the body, the linear inverted pendulum, by fiat. Lingxue Lyu and Zihui Liu ask whether an optimal controller would choose that behavior on its own. They start from a small centroidal control problem that penalizes how fast angular momentum changes.

With a full-rank stance, the optimum drifts toward a pendular force pattern at a rate set by foot-span geometry, matching experiments closely. With two feet down, as in trotting, friction limits impose a floor on angular momentum rate that no tuning removes. Pendular structure, they argue, is something good control discovers.

Catalog record

CREATORLingxue Lyu, Zihui Liu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.05707

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the Emergence of Pendular Structure in Multi-Contact Locomotion Lingxue Lyu, Zihui Liu Abstract LIPM is everywhere in legged-locomotion control, but almost always as a modeling choice rather than as something the controller’s cost actually prefers. This note tries to make that link more explicit. Working from a small centroidal OCP that penalizes the rate of angular momentum, we look at what its optimum tends to look like. Three things come out. With full-rank stance, the optimum drifts toward a pendular force pattern at a rate determined by the SVD of the moment Jacobian; the constant is set by foot-span geometry and matches the experiments to within ∼ 16 % {\sim}16\% . With N = 2 N{=}2 stance, as in trot, the friction cone introduces a lower bound on ‖ 𝑯 ˙ G ‖ \|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}\| that no amount of weight tuning fixes; we also see a non-smooth feasibility kink at a critical horizontal acceleration that we can write in closed form. Adding a task term that asks for a nonzero 𝑯 ˙ G \dot{\bm{H}}_{G} moves the optimum off the pendular set in a predictable way. None of this is far from the classical ZMP/DCM picture. We test these claims on a point-mass quadruped and on the Unitree Go1 in MuJoCo (open-loop QP and a torque-level closed-loop controller), and we note where the asymptotic story stops being a good description of what the closed loop actually does. I INTRODUCTION LIPM [ 14 ] is everywhere. It shows up as a building block in biped work [ 13 , 27 , 19 , 8 ] and in quadruped MPC [ 7 , 2 ] , in trajectory generation, in capture-region analyses, and in countless control papers in between. Mostly it is just assumed : the CoM moves along a fixed-height surface above a virtual pivot, and the rest of the controller is built on top. There are extensions that drop one assumption or another—variable height [ 12 ] , non-coplanar contacts [ 4 ] , angular-momentum corrections [ 8 , 15 ] —but the pendular form is still added by hand. Chen and Posa [ 5 ] ask the more general question of which reduced-order models are task-optimal. We have a narrower question: what kind of objective makes the pendular form fall out, and where does the picture break. The other thread we want to flag is the body of work that uses optimal control directly on multi-contact behaviors—hand-contact fall recovery [ 23 , 24 ] , contact-transition trees [ 25 ] , balance under heavy underactuation [ 20 ] , and runtime dynamics calibration [ 22 ] . The optima in those settings often look pendular, even when nothing in the formulation is asking them to. We do not have a complete answer for why, but the pieces below at least explain part of it. Fig. 1: (a) Pendular direction (foot \to CoM) versus the friction cone of half-angle \arctan\mu=31^{\circ} at \mu=0.6 . Diagonal trot ( N=2 ): the pendular direction tilts 40.6^{\circ} from vertical, outside the cone, so \|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}\| has an \alpha -independent floor (Thm. 5 ). Four-foot stance ( N=4 ): tilt is \sim\!18^{\circ} , inside the cone, floor is zero. (b) Go1 numerical \|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}\|/m vs. \alpha : N=4 follows K/\alpha with K=8.4 (Thm. 1 ); N=2 saturates at 0.44~\mathrm{m^{2}\!/s^{2}} . The setup is a small centroidal OCP with a quadratic penalty on \|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}\| , the usual contact-force regularizer, a normal-acceleration term, and (if we want a non-balance task) an explicit \dot{\bm{H}}_{G} -tracking term. Three things show up (Fig. 1 ). For full-rank stance the optimum drifts toward the pendular force pattern at O(1/\alpha) , with a constant we can read off the moment-Jacobian’s SVD; that constant turns out to just be the foot-span geometry. For N=2 stance the situation is qualitatively different. The moment operator drops to rank 1 , so a \hat{\bm{D}} -aligned residual remains for any force distribution, and on top of that the friction cone imposes its own lower bound that becomes binding at a finite horizontal acceleration. Adding the task term, finally, just slides the optimum off the manifold by a factor \lambda/(\alpha+\lambda) . We are not claiming any of this is far from ZMP [ 21 ] /DCM [ 8 , 15 ] thinking; the goal here is to write the connection down explicitly so that the constants and limits become checkable. II PROBLEM FORMULATION Let \bm{c}\in\mathbb{R}^{3} be the CoM, m>0 the total mass, \bm{g}=[0,0,-g]^{\top} . With N_{c}\geq 1 contact points \bm{r}_{i} exerting forces \bm{f}_{i} , the centroidal dynamics [ 17 ] read \displaystyle m\ddot{\bm{c}} \displaystyle=\textstyle\sum_{i}\bm{f}_{i}+m\bm{g}, (1) \displaystyle\dot{\bm{H}}_{G} \displaystyle=\textstyle\sum_{i}(\bm{r}_{i}-\bm{c})\times\bm{f}_{i}, (2) so the full-body dynamics affect the CoM only through the net wrench. Each contact obeys friction \bm{f}_{i}\in\mathcal{K}_{i}=\{\bm{f}:f_{n,i}\geq 0,\,\|\bm{f}_{t,i}\|\leq\mu_{i}f_{n,i}\} , and the ZMP is \bm{p}_{\mathrm{ZMP}}=\bm{c}_{xy}-(h/g)\ddot{\bm{c}}_{xy} [ 21 ] . Definition 1 (Net-Wrench OCP) . For \alpha,\beta,\gamma\geq 0 , \lambda\geq 0 , target \dot{\bm{H}}_{G}^{\mathrm{task}}(t) , and support normal \bm{n}\in\mathbb{S}^{2} : \displaystyle\min_{\bm{c}(\cdot),\,\{\bm{f}_{i}(\cdot)\}}\;\int_{0}^{T}\!\!\Bigl[ \displaystyle\alpha\left\|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}\right\|^{2}+\lambda\left\|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}-\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}^{\mathrm{task}}\right\|^{2} \displaystyle+\beta(\bm{n}^{\top}\ddot{\bm{c}})^{2}+\gamma\textstyle\sum_{i}\left\|\bm{f}_{i}\right\|^{2}\Bigr]dt (3) subject to ( 1 ), \bm{f}_{i}\in\mathcal{K}_{i} , and boundary conditions. The \lambda=0 case is the balance-dominated OCP; \lambda>0 is task-dominated . Definition 2 (Pendular Manifold) . \mathcal{P}(\bm{n},h)=\{(\bm{c},\bm{F}):\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}=\bm{0},\;\bm{n}^{\top}(\bm{c}-\bm{p})=h,\;\bm{F}=(mg/h)(\bm{c}-\bm{p}),\;\bm{p}\in\Pi\} . Assumption 1 (Feasibility/Regularity) . The OCP is feasible with bounded cost, friction cones are non-empty and convex, and h^{*}=\bm{n}^{\top}(\bm{c}^{*}-\bm{p}^{*})\geq h_{\min}>0 . III ASYMPTOTIC STRUCTURE WITH FULL-RANK STANCE Set \lambda=0 for now. A simple cross-product calculation shows that the pendular force \bm{F}_{\mathrm{pend}}=(mg/h)(\bm{c}-\bm{p}) achieves \dot{\bm{H}}_{G}=\bm{0} pointwise. Theorem 1 below combines this pointwise observation with the asymptotic implications of the cost. Theorem 1 . Let Assumption 1 hold and let (\bm{c}^{*}_{\alpha\beta},\{\bm{f}^{*}_{i,\alpha\beta}\}) minimize ( 3 ) with \lambda=0 . (i) Pointwise certificate. Among all net forces \bm{F} achieving a prescribed horizontal acceleration, the pendular force \bm{F}_{\mathrm{pend}} uniquely minimizes \|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}\|^{2} . (ii) Asymptotic collapse. \displaystyle\int_{0}^{T}\!\left\|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}^{*}\right\|^{2}dt\leq\frac{C_{0}}{\alpha},\quad\int_{0}^{T}\!(\bm{n}^{\top}\ddot{\bm{c}}^{*})^{2}dt\leq\frac{C_{0}}{\beta}, (4) \displaystyle\int_{0}^{T}\!\left\|\bm{F}^{*}-\tfrac{mg}{h^{*}}(\bm{c}^{*}-\bm{p}^{*})\right\|^{2}dt\leq\tfrac{C_{1}}{\alpha}+\tfrac{C_{2}}{\beta}. (5) (iii) Tightness. Any trajectory with pendular deviation \varepsilon_{P} incurs \int\|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}\|^{2}dt\geq(h_{\min}^{2}/K^{2})T\varepsilon_{P} , matching ( 5 ) up to constants. Proof. (i) Pointwise certificate. For prescribed horizontal acceleration \ddot{\bm{c}}_{xy} , Newton’s law ( 1 ) fixes \bm{F}_{xy} . Decompose \bm{F}=\bm{F}_{\parallel}+\bm{F}_{\perp} with \bm{F}_{\parallel}\parallel(\bm{c}-\bm{p}) . Substituting in ( 2 ) gives \dot{\bm{H}}_{G}=(\bm{c}-\bm{p})\times\bm{F}_{\perp} , hence \|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}\|^{2}=\|\bm{c}-\bm{p}\|^{2}\|\bm{F}_{\perp}\|^{2} , which equals zero iff \bm{F}_{\perp}=\bm{0} , i.e. \bm{F} is co-linear with \bm{c}-\bm{p} . The pendular force \bm{F}_{\mathrm{pend}}=(mg/h)(\bm{c}-\bm{p}) is the unique co-linear choice that also satisfies Newton’s law for the prescribed acceleration. (ii) Asymptotic collapse. The cost upper bound J^{*}_{\alpha\beta}\leq C_{0} gives \alpha\int\|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}^{*}\|^{2}dt\leq C_{0} and \beta\int(\bm{n}^{\top}\ddot{\bm{c}}^{*})^{2}dt\leq C_{0} directly. Using \dot{\bm{H}}_{G}^{*}=(\bm{c}^{*}-\bm{p}^{*})\times\bm{F}^{*}=\|\bm{c}^{*}-\bm{p}^{*}\|\|\bm{F}^{*}\|\sin\theta^{*} where \theta^{*} is the angle between \bm{F}^{*} and \bm{c}^{*}-\bm{p}^{*} : \int\|\bm{c}^{*}-\bm{p}^{*}\|^{2}\|\bm{F}^{*}\|^{2}\sin^{2}\theta^{*}dt\leq C_{0}/\alpha . By Assumption 1 \|\bm{c}^{*}-\bm{p}^{*}\|\geq h_{\min} , and gravity support gives \|\bm{F}^{*}\|\geq mg , so \int\sin^{2}\theta^{*}dt\leq C_{0}/(\alpha h_{\min}^{2}m^{2}g^{2}) , i.e. \bm{F}^{*} becomes co-linear with \bm{c}^{*}-\bm{p}^{*} at rate O(1/\sqrt{\alpha}) in L^{2} . Projecting ( 1 ) onto \bm{n} : m\bm{n}^{\top}\ddot{\bm{c}}^{*}=\lambda^{*}h^{*}-mg , so \lambda^{*}=mg/h^{*}+O(1/\sqrt{\beta}) . Combining the two estimates and squaring yields ( 5 ). (iii) Tightness. For an arbitrary feasible trajectory write \bm{F}=\lambda(\bm{c}-\bm{p})+\bm{F}_{\perp} with \bm{F}_{\perp}\perp(\bm{c}-\bm{p}) . Then \dot{\bm{H}}_{G}=(\bm{c}-\bm{p})\times\bm{F}_{\perp} and \|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}\|^{2}\geq h_{\min}^{2}\|\bm{F}_{\perp}\|^{2} . The pendular deviation expands as \|\bm{F}-(mg/h)(\bm{c}-\bm{p})\|^{2}=\|\bm{F}_{\perp}\|^{2}+(\lambda-mg/h)^{2}\|\bm{c}-\bm{p}\|^{2}\leq K^{2}(\|\bm{F}_{\perp}\|^{2}+(\lambda-mg/h)^{2}) for a geometric constant K bounding \|\bm{c}-\bm{p}\| . Integrating gives the claimed lower bound. ∎ The rate is sharp; the next proposition makes the constant explicit. Proposition 2 . Stack the equilibrium-null-space forces into the moment Jacobian \bm{J}_{H}\in\mathbb{R}^{3\times 3(N-1)} with SVD \bm{J}_{H}=\bm{U}\bm{\Sigma}\bm{V}^{\top} and \sigma_{1}\!\geq\!\sigma_{2}\!\geq\!\sigma_{3}\!>\!0 . Let h_{k}(t)=(\bm{U}^{\top}\dot{\bm{H}}_{G,0}(t))_{k} be the excitation projection from gravity and inertia. For \alpha\sigma_{k}^{2}\!\gg\!\gamma , \tfrac{\|\dot{\bm{H}}_{G}^{*}\|}{m}\;\approx\;\tfrac{\gamma}{\alpha}\,K,\quad

Read the complete text