The formation of the C-19 progenitor: a primordial cluster heated by gas expulsion

Zhen Wang (王震), Long Wang (王龙), Zhen Yuan (袁珍), Jiang Chang (常江) · 2026

Read The formation of the C-19 progenitor: a primordial cluster heated by gas expulsion by Zhen Wang (王震), Long Wang (王龙), Zhen Yuan (袁珍), Jiang Chang (常江) (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-05622.txt.

Introduction

The C-19 stellar stream is a puzzle: its stars are extremely metal-poor, like a globular cluster's, yet they move with the hot spread expected of a dwarf galaxy. Zhen Wang, Long Wang, Zhen Yuan, and Jiang Chang test whether the cluster's own birth could explain both traits. Earlier work blamed encounters with dark matter subhalos for heating the stream.

The authors instead simulate internal processes during cluster formation, especially the expulsion of leftover gas. Losing that gas unbinds the outer stars and inflates the velocity spread. A top-heavy initial mass function shapes the outcome further, reconciling cluster chemistry with galaxy-like dynamics.

Catalog record

CREATORZhen Wang (王震), Long Wang (王龙), Zhen Yuan (袁珍), Jiang Chang (常江)
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.05622

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The formation of the C-19 progenitor: a primordial cluster heated by gas expulsion numpy ( 32 ), matplotlib ( 34 ), sdar ( 85 , https://github.com/lwang-astro/SDAR), petar ( 82 , https://github.com/lwang-astro/PeTar), mcluster ( 53 , https://github.com/lwang-astro/mcluster) Galpy ( 11 , https://github.com/jobovy/galpy) Zhen Wang (王震), Long Wang (王龙), Zhen Yuan (袁珍), Jiang Chang (常江) Abstract The extremely metal-poor nature of the C-19 stream indicates that its progenitor was a primordial stellar system born in the very early Universe. Current observations show that it has a small metallicity dispersion (0.18 at the 95% confidence level), which is the signature of a globular cluster origin, while at the same time displaying an unusually large velocity dispersion ( ∼ 10 \sim 10 km/s) typical of dwarf galaxies. To reconcile this conflicting observational evidence, previous simulations have focused on potential interactions with dark matter subhalos, which can efficiently make a cluster stream dynamically hot. In this work, we explore internal dynamical processes in star cluster formation, focusing on initial conditions shaped by gas expulsion and a top-heavy initial mass function. We find that the large observed velocity dispersion and broad stream morphology can be reproduced by a cluster that underwent severe gas expulsion and expansion during its birth phase, which is potentially a typical formation scenario of extremely metal-poor star clusters. A top-heavy IMF and binaries can also increase the velocity dispersion. The formation of C-19 may involve a combination of these effects. show][email protected] show][email protected] I Introduction Stellar streams are the relics of globular clusters (GCs) or dwarf galaxies which follow similar orbits after their progenitor systems are tidally disrupted by the galaxy’s potential. In the era of Gaia ( 27 ; 26 ; 28 ) , about 100 stellar streams are discovered and characterized by combining ground-based photometric and spectroscopic observations ( 38 ; 54 ; 59 ; 39 , see e.g., ) . Most of these streams are thin and dynamically cold, originated from dense stellar systems, i.e., GCs, compared to wide and hot streams from dwarf galaxies, such as the Sagittarius ( 56 ; 7 ; 37 ; 73 , see e.g., ) , Orphan ( 6 ; 47 ) , Cetus streams ( 65 ; 94 ; 91 ) and LMS-1 ( 90 ; 57 ) . Streams with very low metallicities, provide precious fossils to study the formation and evolution of their progenitor stellar systems born at very early Universe. Compared to the direct observations from JWST, such as GN-z11, possibly a star cluster born at 440Myr after the big bang ( 12 ; 13 , see e.g., ) , Galactic Archaeology studies the relics of these primordial systems accreted to the Milky Way. This alternative approach has its own unique advantage: the vicinity of these stellar debris allows us to study their progenitor in a star-by-star manner. Among all the known low-metallicities streams, the C-19 stream is the most metal-poor stellar structure identified to date ( 60 ) , with an average metallicity [Fe/H] =-3.38\pm 0.06 and an extremely small metallicity dispersion ( \sigma_{\rm[Fe/H]}<0.18 , at 95% confidence level) via high-resolution spectroscopy. The tiny Fe dispersion as well as the scatter seen in light elements (Na, Mg, Al) strongly indicate its GC origin ( 92 ; 10 ) . However, compared to the other GC streams with similar progenitor mass ( \approx 10^{4}~\rm{M}_{\odot} ), C-19 is usually wide and dynamically hot, which favors a dwarf galaxy origin. The radial velocity dispersion ( \sigma_{\rm v} ) determined from 9 members reaches 6~\mathrm{km~s^{-1}} ( 92 ) , consistent with results from sub-giants 10 . The tension of its origins is further heightened after doubling the number of confirmed members spanning over 100 ∘ on the sky 93 . The \sigma_{\rm v} is revised to be \sim 10\,\mathrm{km~s^{-1}} , whereas the stellar mass remains several 10 4 \rm M_{\odot} by counting its bright stars. To reconcile the dynamically hot C-19 stream with the assumption of its cluster origin, several studies include the impacts from dark matter. 23 explored a scenario that low-density GCs are embedded in a cuspy cold dark matter halo and showed the pre-heating by the halo is able to produce the large \sigma_{\rm v} of C-19. 15 tested a scenario that streams keep being heated by the subhalos in the MW based on a series of cosmological simulations. This study found that gravitational heating by cold dark matter subhalos over \sim 1.1 Gyr can produce the observed width and \sigma_{\rm v} of C-19, which could explain other hot streams ( 38 ) , such as OmegaCen, M29, NGC288, NGC1851, and NGC1261. In this work, we try to simulate the C-19 stream on a star-by-star numerical basis. Instead of considering the potential interaction with dark matter halo, we focus on the internal dynamical processes associated with star cluster formation, including initial mass function, the effects of early gas expulsion, binary fraction, which would critically influence the dynamical state of the stream. The formation of extremely metal-poor (EMP) star clusters is closely related to their pristine environment. First of all, metallicity may be a factor that determines the initial mass function (IMF) of stars. 58 studied present-day Galactic GCs and ultra-compact dwarf galaxies and derived their initial conditions, finding systematically top-heavy IMFs in dense and metal-poor environments. The IMF slope becomes flatter with increasing cloud density and decreasing metallicity. 18 also showed with hydrodynamic simulations that the IMF varies with metallicity: low metallicity leads to inefficient cooling and favors the formation of massive stars, while higher metallicity supports fragmentation and produces a Chabrier-like IMF ( 16 ) . Secondly, when massive stars form, their feedback can expel gas, suppressing new star formation, reducing gravitational potential, and driving rapid cluster expansion ( 30 ; 2 ; 3 ; 48 ; 25 ; 24 ; 22 ; 69 ) . 3 studied the effect of gas expulsion with N-body simulations and found that the star formation efficiency (SFE) and the timescale of gas removal determine the survival and expansion of clusters. 69 found the observed evidence of gas expulsion in NGC 2232 and LP 2439. The low metallicity of C-19 suggests that it may form with a top-heavy IMF, which would yield many massive stars, whose strong feedback could drive rapid, violent gas expulsion, with their resulting black holes (BHs) providing strong dynamical heating ( 29 ; 86 ; 88 ; 74 ) . Such feedback can quickly disrupt the cluster, leaving only a dynamically hot stellar stream with no surviving host GC. To assess how different initial conditions shape the C-19 progenitor cluster and its stream, we run N-body simulations and compare them with observations. The structure of this paper is as follows. In Section II , we describe the details of the simulations and the data processing methods used in this work. Section III presents the results. Section IV discusses the results and addresses the limitations of this study as well as future plans. Section V provides the conclusions. II Method II.1 N-body code In this study, we use the high-performance N-body code PeTar ( 82 ; 83 ) to simulate the dynamical evolution of star clusters. The code combines the particle-tree particle-particle method ( 67 ) with the slow-down algorithmic

Read the complete text