Proton probing measurements of filamentary electromagnetic structure in laser ablation of solids

J. L. Peebles, 1 P. V. Heuer, 1 D. H. Barnak, 1 Y. V. Zhang, 1 J. R. Davies 1 · 2026

Read Proton probing measurements of filamentary electromagnetic structure in laser ablation of solids by J. L. Peebles, 1 P. V. Heuer, 1 D. H. Barnak, 1 Y. V. Zhang, 1 J. R. Davies 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-05614.txt.

Introduction

Powerful lasers blasting solid targets create tangled electromagnetic fields that can drain energy and distort implosions. J. Peebles and four co-authors measured those filamentary fields with proton radiography at the OMEGA EP laser facility. Earlier shots of spherical implosions had shown odd field structures spread through the corona, the hot cloud around the target.

In simpler flat-target experiments, the team varied material, target size, pulse shape, and intensity. Field growth turned out to be dominated by laser energy and the target's atomic number. The data support a secondary instability, growing from the expansion-driven Weibel instability, as the main driver.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. L. Peebles, 1 P. V. Heuer, 1 D. H. Barnak, 1 Y. V. Zhang, 1 J. R. Davies 1
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.05614

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Proton probing measurements of filamentary electromagnetic structure in laser ablation of solids J. L. Peebles, 1 P. V. Heuer, 1 D. H. Barnak, 1 Y. V. Zhang, 1 J. R. Davies 1 Abstract Proton radiography of laser direct-drive spherical implosions has shown anomalous structures that correspond to strong electric or magnetic fields extending throughout the corona. These fields have the ability to affect laser–target interactions and act as an energy sink. To better understand the these fields, simplified experiments were conducted in planar geometry on the OMEGA EP laser at the Laboratory for Laser Energetics. Varying target material, target size, pulse shape, and intensity, and measured the field structure using dual-axis proton radiography and a 4 ω \omega probe. Proton radiographs were analyzed and quantitatively demonstrate that the growth of these features is dominated by laser energy and target Z. The data strongly supports that a secondary instability as a consequence of the expansion driven Weibel instability in these interactions is the primary driver for these fields. pacs numbers! I Introduction Over the previous decades proton radiography has been used to diagnose electric and magnetic fields in various laser plasma interactions. Early experiments by M. Borghesi, C. K. Li and F. Seguin et al. Borghesi2002 ; Li2009 ; Rygg2008 ; Seguin2012 ; Zylstra2012 used proton radiography to image electric and magnetic field structures around direct-drive spherical implosions and found a variety of features surrounding the laser-irradiated target, including radial structures emanating from the sphere for several millimeters. Years later, other experiments examining the growth of the Rayleigh-Taylor instability in laser-solid interactions found similar features, but in a very different target geometry GaoThesis ; Nilson . While these features were discovered, they were not the focus of their respective works and not analyzed in great detail. However, due to their large scale-length and presence in spherical implosions, it is important to ascertain whether these features could have an impact in ICF implosions. Large volume field structures could act as an energy sink, inhibit charged particle transport, and modify the laser-plasma interaction physics. The presence of large electric or magnetic fields has also been shown to confound charged-particle imaging diagnostics Heuer2025 . One of the major difficulties presented by this feature is that fact it does not arise in hydrodynamic simulations for the regimes of the given experiments. These features are observed to develop over several nanoseconds, over several millimeters, and appear to be non-neutral structures some tens of microns wide. While this presents a challenge to understanding the mechanism that generates these fields, further dedicated experiments can improve our understanding of the regimes where these effects are important, how they scale, and provide a reference for future, improved simulations. In this paper we explore some of the previous experimental work performed, disseminate our own experimental findings over a large parameter space and use these experiments to eliminate some possible mechanisms for the formation of filaments, while providing support for others. I.A Features seen in proton radiography for previous experiments Figure 1: Proton radiograph of a spherical implosion shot on OMEGA demonstrating the generation of web-like electro-magnetic filaments. An drawing of the target (diameter of 860 \mu m ) prior to being shot is overlayed with the radiograph showing the extent of the filaments in all directions. Experiments in the spherical regime encompass implosions with shells and shots on solid sphere targets. Proton radiography was used to measure the electromagnetic fields surrounding these implosions. In these experiments there are several distinguishing features; early in time for some shell targets, a “ripple” like feature developed at a fixed radius from the capsule Li2009 ; Igumenshchev . At later times, filamentary features that look like webbing, extending radially from the targets were observed. These features established themselves within 0.5 ns of the laser turning on and dissipate roughly 1 ns after the drive turns off. The center of the target exhibited focusing, defocusing and scattering effects depending on the experiment. These have not only been correlated to a decrease in proton energy for protons passing through the center of the target, they also appear to greatly affect charged particle diagnostics using high energy deuterons and protons Heuer2025 . Further experiments conducted later with offset shells show that these features are insensitive to quality of implosion, target offset or even missing many beams (Fig. 1 ). In the planar regime an analogous set of features are shown to evolve on similar time scales Manuel ; Sutcliffe ; GaoThesis ; Nilson . However, since the target is cylindrically rather than spherically symmetric, the filaments stay relatively coalesced, rather than breaking up into web like structure. As shown in Gao et al. GaoThesis in Figure 2 (a), the laser target interaction zone is surrounded by a strong circular shape indicating a Biermann battery field. The interior structure in the radiograph is characterized by electromagnetic fields from the Rayleigh-Taylor instability, while the outer radial filamentary structure is uncharacterized. Typically in the planar experiment case the filamentary structure was an unwanted feature, which was avoided by either probing early in time, or at lower drive intensity and energy. Reconnection experiments by P. Nilson et al. Nilson shown in Figure 2 (b) demonstrate similar features. These filamentary features increased the difficulty of measuring the Biermann battery reconnection and further experiments were conducted early in time to avoid the development of these features after 1 ns. Figure 2: (a) An experiment conducted by L. Gao et al. GaoThesis examining the electromagnetic fields generated via the Rayleigh–Taylor (RT) instability in thin target interactions. One can see both the lobes and nodes characteristic of RT and the radial filaments that stay coalesced as they move away from the target. (b) A similar experiment conducted by P. Nilson et al. Nilson examining magnetic reconnection of Biermann Battery ring-like fields between two laser spots. During and after the merge of the Biermann fields, radial filaments can be seen emanating from both spots. II Setup for experiments on OMEGA-EP To characterize the filamentary structures extending radially from the target we conducted several experiments using a dual-axis proton radiography platform on the EP laser facility at the Laboratory for Laser Energetics. The experimental setup, shown in Figure 3 utilized up to two long pulse beams at 351 nm, incident on a range of materials (CH, Cu, Si, Mo, Ta and Au), with diameters ranging between 1.0-1.4 mm and thicknesses between 20 and 200 \mathrm{\mu} m. The long pulse beams have a variety of distributed phase plates (DPP) available, which smooth the spot and enables the ability to change laser spot size and intensity on target. These experiments were diagnosed by a dual-axis proton radiography setup using the two orthogonal short pulse beams (1053 nm, 125 - 500 J in a 15 - 20 \mathrm{\mu} m spot over 0.7 ps). These beams were incident on 20 \mathrm{\mu} m thick copper foils encased in polyether-ether-ketone (PEEK) tubes with a 2 - 5 \mu m Ta shield to protect them from x-rays and other interactions from the long-pulse beams. The protons generated pass by the target and were detected by radiochromic film (RCF) stacks Roth . The radiography sources are nominally 5 to 8 mm away from the foil target

Read the complete text