Numerical quality factor statistics for SRF cavities with spatially inhomogeneous multilayer coatings modeled by Gaussian random fields
Aaron Gobeyn, Wolfgang Ackermann, Herbert De Gersem · 2026
Read Numerical quality factor statistics for SRF cavities with spatially inhomogeneous multilayer coatings modeled by Gaussian random fields by Aaron Gobeyn, Wolfgang Ackermann, Herbert De Gersem (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-05505.txt.
Introduction
Superconducting radio-frequency cavities need coatings that survive curved shapes. Aaron Gobeyn, Wolfgang Ackermann, and Herbert De Gersem model what uneven coating does to a cavity's quality factor. Their multilayer coatings stack superconductor, insulator, and superconductor, allowing brittle materials that bulk niobium cannot offer.
They generate the thickness unevenness with Gaussian random fields at eight length scales, with over two thousand samples each. Quality factors came out normally distributed, with spread growing as the length scale grew. Mean values barely moved, though in extreme cases the quality factor shifted by a few percent.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aaron Gobeyn, Wolfgang Ackermann, Herbert De Gersem |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.05505
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Numerical quality factor statistics for SRF cavities with spatially inhomogeneous multilayer coatings modeled by Gaussian random fields Aaron Gobeyn, Wolfgang Ackermann, Herbert De Gersem Abstract Bulk niobium has long been the material of choice for superconducting radio-frequency applications. An alternative approach is the superconductor-insulator-superconductor multilayer structure, which enables the use of brittle high- T c T_{c} materials such as NbTiN. At present, SIS coatings are limited to flat samples, with the single-cell TESLA cavity representing a key milestone. Extending coating processes to non-flat geometries is expected to introduce macroscopic inhomogeneities in coating thickness. We model these variations using Gaussian random fields parametrized by a length scale, and generated by solving a stochastic partial differential equation. The resulting field is incorporated into the boundary condition of the cavity eigenvalue problem, from which quantities of interest—such as resonant frequency and quality factor—are computed. This procedure is repeated for eight length scales, with 2048 2048 samples per length scale, where the resulting quality factors are recorded. Our results show that the quality factors follow a normal distribution. The standard deviation increases with the length scale and can be statistically distinguished. In contrast, the mean values remain largely unchanged, with only a few significant differences. In extreme cases, depending on the length scale, the quality factor may differ from the uniform case by 2 % to 6 % 2\text{\,}\mathrm{\%}6\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} . I Introduction Bulk niobium (Nb) has long been the material of choice for superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities in accelerator physics applications, and has therefore been extensively studied to approach its theoretical capabilities. A variety of surface preparation techniques have been developed to improve RF performance. Electropolishing produces smoother surfaces, reducing local enhancement due to roughness, but introduces hydrogen absorption that must be removed by subsequent heat treatment. High-pressure rinsing with ultrapure water is then applied to remove microparticles and reduce field emission Padamsee 2009 . More recent advances include nitrogen doping and diffusion Dhakal 2020 , as well as low-temperature baking Grassellino et al. 2018 ; Wenskat et al. 2020 . These methods have significantly improved the quality factor and the achievable accelerating fields. However, such approaches remain fundamentally limited by the critical magnetic field of Nb ( H_{c}{\sim}$200\text{\,}\mathrm{mT}$ ). Additionally, the operating temperature of bulk Nb cavities is currently 2\text{\,}\mathrm{K} , and is limited by the critical temperature T_{c} of Nb. Using higher T_{c} superconductors could enable operation at 4.2\text{\,}\mathrm{K} , substantially reducing cryogenic costs Valente-Feliciano 2016 . Because RF fields penetrate only a very thin surface layer in superconductors (typically less than 1\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m} Valente-Feliciano 2016 ), the superconducting properties relevant for cavity performance are governed almost entirely by this thin layer. This has motivated the development of thin-film cavities, in which a superconducting coating is deposited onto a bulk substrate. This approach has been successfully implemented in Nb/Cu cavities at CERN facilities such as LEP-II and LHC Calatroni 2006 . An extension of this concept is the use of superconductor-insulator-superconductor (SIS) multilayer structures Gurevich 2006 . Here, a bulk superconducting substrate is coated with a thin insulating layer \mathcal{O}($10\text{\,}\mathrm{nm}$) followed by a superconducting thin film \mathcal{O}($100\text{\,}\mathrm{nm}$) with higher T_{c} and H_{c} . The superconducting thin film partially screens the RF field, reducing the field strengths encountered by the substrate such that it maintains the superconducting state at higher fields than possible by bulk only. The insulator layer prevents vortex penetration and suppresses Josephson coupling effects Kubo 2016 . One promising candidate is the NbTiN-AlN-Nb multilayer Burton et al. 2016 ; Díaz-Palacio et al. 2023 ; Asaduzzaman et al. 2025 . Other approaches include superconductor-superconductor bilayers, such as \text{Nb}_{3}\text{Sn} on Nb produced via e.g. co-sputtering Schäfer et al. 2020 ; Sayeed et al. 2023 , as well as \text{Nb}_{3}\text{Sn} thin films on Cu substrates, expanding on the successes of Nb/Cu cavities Fonnesu et al. 2026 . All of these approaches rely on thin-film deposition techniques, e.g. atomic layer deposition, co-sputtering and DC magnetron sputtering, and are typically investigated on flat samples for quadrupole resonator (QPR) measurements Tikhonov et al. 2021 ; Fonnesu et al. 2026 . Under such conditions, film thickness is generally uniform, globally speaking. However, extending these techniques to complex geometries, e.g. TESLA-type cavities, is expected to produce large-scale thickness inhomogeneities, with spatial distributions that depend on the particular deposition method. The influences of such inhomogeneities on relevant quantities of interest, e.g. quality factor, remains largely unexplored and is difficult to assess experimentally. In this work, we perform a numerical study to quantify the impact of coating thickness variations on the quality factor for a single cell TESLA cavity. We outline a simulation scheme that is applicable to the mentioned thin-film approaches, though we focus on SIS structures in particular. The coating thickness distribution is emulated through Gaussian random fields, hence remaining agnostic of the deposition method. Different length scales of the variations are considered and compared statistically. II Methods II.1 Eigenproblem formulation In order to obtain the quality factor of the cavity, we use the finite element (FE) method. In particular, we numerically solve the eigenvalue problem: \displaystyle\curl(\curl\bm{E})=\left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right)^{2}\bm{E}, \displaystyle\text{on }\Omega (1) \displaystyle\bm{n}\times\bm{E}=Z(\bm{r},\omega)\left[\bm{n}\times\left(\bm{n}\times\bm{H}\right)\right], \displaystyle\text{on }\partial\Omega (2) where \bm{E} and \bm{H} denote the electric and magnetic field strengths respectively, \omega\in\mathbb{C} is the angular frequency, c is the speed of light, \bm{n} is the normal to the surface \partial\Omega and Z(\bm{r},\omega) is the frequency-dependent and position-dependent surface impedance. The former, eq. 1 , is obtained from Maxwell’s equations in frequency domain, without sources, and with homogeneous, linear and isotropic constitutive relations. The latter, eq. 2 , is the Leontovich surface impedance boundary condition (SIBC) Yuferev and Ida 2018 . The boundary conditions can be specified fully in terms of the electric field through Faraday’s law \bm{H}=(j/\omega\mu)\curl\bm{E} . To write down the weak formulation, we define the space H_{t}(\text{curl};\Omega)=\left\{\bm{u}\in H(\text{curl};\Omega)\mid\gamma_{t}(\bm{u})\in L^{2}(\partial\Omega)^{3}\right\} (3) where the tangential trace operator \gamma_{t} is defined by \gamma_{t}:H(\text{curl};\Omega)\to H^{-1/2}(\text{div}_{\partial\Omega};\partial\Omega):\bm{u}\mapsto\bm{n}\times\bm{u}\mid_{\partial\Omega} (4) We further define the inner product \langle.,\!.\rangle_{\Omega}:L^{2}(\Omega)^{3}\times L^{2}(\Omega)^{3}:(\bm{u},\bm{v})\mapsto\int_{\Omega}\differential\mu\,\bm{v}^{\dagger}\bm{u} (5) where \differential\mu is the appropriate Lebesgue measure and \bm{v}^{\dagger} denotes the Hermitian conjugate. Finally, we assume that, for all \omega\in\mathbb{C} , the function Z^{-1}(\bm{r},\omega)\in L^{\infty}(\partial\Omega) , such we may define the bounded operators M_{Z^{-1}}^{\omega}:L^{2}(\partial\Omega)^{3}\to L^{2}(\partial\Omega)^{3}:\bm{u}\mapsto Z^{-1}\bm{u} (6) whose action is effectively multiplication by Z^{-1} . The weak formulation then reads: find \bm{u}\in H_{t}(\text{curl};\Omega) and \omega\in\mathbb{C} such that \forall\bm{v}\in H_{t}(\text{curl};\Omega) Monk 2003 ; Brenner and Scott 2008 : \displaystyle\langle\curl\bm{u},\curl\bm{v}\rangle_{\Omega} \displaystyle+jZ_{0}\frac{\omega}{c}\langle M_{Z^{-1}}^{\omega}\gamma_{t}(\bm{u}),\gamma_{t}(\bm{v})\rangle_{\partial\Omega} (7) \displaystyle-\left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right)^{2}\langle\bm{u},\bm{v}\rangle_{\Omega}=0 where Z_{0} is the impedance of free space. The domain \Omega is discretized into tetrahedral elements, and the H_{t}(\text{curl};\Omega) space is approximated via Nédélec basis functions of the first kind \left\{\bm{w}_{i}\right\}_{i=1,\dotsc,N} , where N denotes the number of degrees of freedom (DOF) Nedelec 1980 . The test and trial functions are expanded in this basis, i.e. \bm{u}(\bm{r},\omega)=\sum_{i=1}^{N}x_{i}(\omega)\bm{w}_{i}(\bm{r}) (8) which reduces the continuous problem eq. 7 to the discrete eigenvalue problem \left[\bm{K}+jZ_{0}\frac{\omega}{c}\bm{B}(\omega)-\left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right)^{2}\bm{M}\right]\bm{x}=0 (9) where the components of the stiffness matrix \bm{K} , boundary matrix \bm{B}(\omega) and mass matrix \bm{M} are given by \displaystyle K_{ij} \displaystyle=\langle\curl\bm{w}_{i},\curl\bm{w}_{j}\rangle_{\Omega}, (10) \displaystyle B_{ij}(\omega) \displaystyle=\langle M_{Z^{-1}}^{\omega}\gamma_{t}(\bm{w}_{i}),\gamma_{t}(\bm{w}_{j})\rangle_{\partial\Omega}, (11) \displaystyle M_{ij} \displaystyle=\langle\bm{w}_{i},\bm{w}_{j}\rangle_{\Omega} (12) for i,j=1,\dotsc,N . The resonance frequency of an eigenmode f and the quality factor Q , which quantifies the damping, can be obtained from the eigenvalue \omega via f=\frac{1}{2\pi}\real(\omega),\quad Q=\frac{\real(\omega)}{2\imaginary(\omega)} (13) We solve the eigenvalue problem eq. 9 via a fixed point iteration as