The Ambivalent Experience of Eye Contact for People with Visual Impairments: Mechanisms and Design Challenges DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: Designing Interactive Systems Conference; June 13–17, 2026; Singapore, Singapore Designing Interactive Systems Conference (DIS ’26), June 13–17, 2026, Singapore, Singapore DOI: 10.1145/3800645.3813067 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2563-0/2026/06 CCS: Human-centered computing Accessibility CCS: Human-centered computing Accessibility design and evaluation methods

Markus Wieland, Phillip Koch, Michael Sedlmair · 2026

Read The Ambivalent Experience of Eye Contact for People with Visual Impairments: Mechanisms and Design Challenges DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: Designing Interactive Systems Conference; June 13–17, 2026; Singapore, Singapore Designing Interactive Systems Conference (DIS ’26), June 13–17, 2026, Singapore, Singapore DOI: 10.1145/3800645.3813067 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2563-0/2026/06 CCS: Human-centered computing Accessibility CCS: Human-centered computing Accessibility design and evaluation methods by Markus Wieland, Phillip Koch, Michael Sedlmair (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-05437.txt.

Introduction

Eye contact quietly runs most face-to-face teamwork, deciding who speaks and who is heard. Markus Wieland, Phillip Koch, and Michael Sedlmair interviewed seventeen people with visual impairments about such mixed-ability settings. Their question was how eye contact feels when the visual signal itself is not accessible.

Three patterns stood out. When gaze cannot hand over the floor, being named directly becomes essential. Unclear turn cues and constant access work tire people out, sometimes to withdrawal. Norms around eye contact also skew how participation is judged. The authors turn these findings into five design challenges for fairer collaboration tools.

Catalog record

CREATORMarkus Wieland, Phillip Koch, Michael Sedlmair
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.05437

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Ambivalent Experience of Eye Contact for People with Visual Impairments: Mechanisms and Design Challenges DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: Designing Interactive Systems Conference; June 13–17, 2026; Singapore, Singapore Designing Interactive Systems Conference (DIS ’26), June 13–17, 2026, Singapore, Singapore DOI: 10.1145/3800645.3813067 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2563-0/2026/06 CCS: Human-centered computing Accessibility CCS: Human-centered computing Accessibility design and evaluation methods Markus Wieland, Phillip Koch, Michael Sedlmair Abstract . In mixed-ability collaboration, eye contact is often treated as a default cue for attention and turn-taking. As these signals are primarily visual, they are not reliably accessible to people with visual impairments. While prior work emphasized technical solutions, mechanism-level explanations of their experiences with sighted partners remain scarce. We interviewed 17 people with visual impairments about everyday interactions across work, education, and social settings. Using a critical-realist lens, we link events to plausible causal mechanisms and identify three recurring mechanisms: First, when gaze cannot allocate the floor, addressability hinges on explicit naming. Second, unclear speech entry cues and ongoing access work split attention and build fatigue, sometimes leading to withdrawal. Third, eye-contact norms can skew judgments of participation, prompting active management of visibility. We translate these mechanisms into five design challenges that reframe accessible eye contact as supporting configurable interaction contracts rather than merely making gaze visible. Figure 1. Overview of our findings: three mechanisms underlying accessible eye contact breakdowns and the five design challenges they motivate. Design challenges are situated within the mechanism containers that inform them; Design Challenge 4 appears across all three mechanisms. Overview diagram showing three mechanisms underlying accessible eye contact breakdowns and the five design challenges they motivate. The diagram is organized into three horizontal containers representing the mechanisms. The top-left container shows Mechanism 1 (Addressability and Turn Coordination) with two nested boxes: Design Challenge 1 (Make addressability explicit) and Design Challenge 4 (Support configurable interaction contracts). The top-right container shows Mechanism 2 (Access Work, Effort, and Withdrawal) with two nested boxes: Design Challenge 2 (Reduce access work) and Design Challenge 4 (Support configurable interaction contracts). The bottom container shows Mechanism 3 (Norms, Stigma, and Negotiated Visibility) with three nested boxes: Design Challenge 3 (Negotiate visibility and consent), Design Challenge 4 (Support configurable interaction contracts), and Design Challenge 5 (Make norms negotiable). Design Challenge 4 appears in all three mechanism containers, indicating it addresses issues across all three mechanisms. † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Social interactions are an intrinsic part of being human. From school to professional life, humans learn to collaborate toward shared goals. This cooperative and collaborative behavior has shaped human society and underpins the evolution of cumulative culture ( 41 ) . Being able to collaborate is also linked to the evolutionary development of the human eyes ( 20 ) . The eyes or gaze serve a dual role in social interactions: they allow individuals to perceive information about the environment and conversation partners and also enable the conveyance of meaning through gaze, such as by staring ( 14 ) . Gaze plays a multifaceted role in social interactions ( 19 ; 32 ) , for example, a person who maintains strong eye contact is often perceived as competent, dynamic, and sociable ( 8 ) , which can positively influence their ability to achieve goals in social interactions ( 7 ; 9 ; 27 ) . Yet gaze is not only a “cue” that can be missing or substituted. Conversation-analytic work has shown that gaze is a resource for organizing participation. For instance, by establishing addressability, coordinating turn transitions, and monitoring uptake ( 35 ) . Complementing this, a systematized review synthesizes evidence that eye gaze supports turn regulation and ongoing monitoring and can help prevent and repair conversational breakdowns ( 11 ) . Despite the multifaceted functions of gaze, people with visual impairments face difficulties in perceiving and recognizing these cues during conversations ( 34 ; 44 ; 15 ) . In mixed-ability teams, they report concerns about effective participation ( 23 ) and about keeping up when eye contact is used as a turn-taking signal ( 34 ) . Several assistive technologies have attempted to make gaze accessible for people with visual impairments, for example by providing haptic cues ( 36 ; 33 ) , by simulating avatar gaze in VR ( 18 ; 10 ; 43 ) , or by supporting blind children in joint attention attempts ( 29 ; 17 ) . Although such systems address challenges of nonverbal communication, they often remain signal-centric, focused on substituting visual information (e.g., “who looks where”). As a result, they risk reproducing dominant gaze norms and neglecting the psychological, emotional, and cultural dimensions of eye contact. This echoes broader critiques in disability studies: rather than reducing disability to a single explanatory model, critical realism conceptualizes it as a “necessarily laminated system” 1 1 1 Here, “laminated” follows critical realist usage and refers to a layered/stratified system of interacting levels, not to lamination in the everyday material sense. To avoid confusion, we use “layered” as shorthand for this critical-realist notion throughout the remainder of the paper. encompassing physical, biological, psychological, psychosocial, socio-economic, cultural, and normative layers ( 4 ; 38 ) . Building on this perspective, Frauenberger ( 12 ) has argued that assistive technology research benefits from non-reductionist framings. Reductionist approaches, which identify a functional limitation and design a technical intervention to address it, can obscure how technologies are entangled with social practices, cultural expectations, and the lived experience of disability. To move beyond functional views of accessible eye contact, we conducted 17 interviews with people with visual impairments, focusing on their experiences in everyday interactional contexts, including professional, educational, and social or romantic encounters. To interpret these perspectives, we draw on critical realism and disability studies ( 4 ; 12 ) , which foreground layered understandings of disability experience beyond biological or perceptual limitations. Building on recent work that situates gaze and joint attention in everyday practice ( 17 ) , our study explicitly connects participants’ reports of eye contact to this non-reductionist theoretical lens. Our analysis identifies three mechanisms that explain why “making gaze visible” is only a partial response: addressability breakdowns in gaze-based floor allocation, accumulating access work that can tip into fatigue and withdrawal, and normative misreadings that make participation socially risky. From a critical-realist perspective, these mechanisms are co-produced by layered conditions such as perceptual access, cognitive and emotional demands, and cultural/normative expectations about what eye contact “means” in a given situation. This helps explain why the same technical intervention can feel supportive in one context but burdensome or stigmatizing in another. We translate this mechanism-oriented synthesis into five design challenges ( Figure 1 ) for assistive technologies that reframe accessible eye contact as designing a configurable interaction contract. Our contributions are threefold: • An empirical characterization of how people with visual impairments experience and negotiate eye contact in collaborative scenarios, based on 17 qualitative interviews. • A theoretical framing that connects these experiences to critical realism and disability studies, conceptualizing eye contact as a layered phenomenon shaped by perceptual, psychosocial, and cultural/normative layers. • Five design challenges for assistive technologies that move beyond cue substitution toward making addressability explicit, reducing access work and split attention, designing for negotiated visibility and consent, supporting

Read the complete text