On the Origin of Mass Ejection in Failed Supernovae FLASH ( 30 ) , MESA ( 58 ; 59 ; 60 ; 61 ; 62 ; 38 )
Daniel A. Paradiso, Sarah Vallejo, Eric R. Coughlin · 2026
Read On the Origin of Mass Ejection in Failed Supernovae FLASH ( 30 ) , MESA ( 58 ; 59 ; 60 ; 61 ; 62 ; 38 ) by Daniel A. Paradiso, Sarah Vallejo, Eric R. Coughlin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-05289.txt.
Introduction
Daniel Paradiso, Sarah Vallejo, and Eric Coughlin explain the origin of mass ejection in failed supernovae, the quiet collapses of massive stars that form black holes without a bright explosion. Neutrinos escaping the newborn neutron star launch a weak shock into the star's outer layers, producing a faint transient as it breaks out. Two self-similar solutions describe that shock, mixing outward ejecta with fallback onto the black hole.
The authors show the stronger-shock family is unstable, with its Mach number growing slowly away from the self-similar prediction, while the weaker family is stable. Above a reachable mass-loss threshold the shock strengthens toward the strong limit. Ejection, they conclude, is governed mainly by neutrino mass loss relative to the mass the shock encloses.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel A. Paradiso, Sarah Vallejo, Eric R. Coughlin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 83 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.05289
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the Origin of Mass Ejection in Failed Supernovae FLASH ( 30 ) , MESA ( 58 ; 59 ; 60 ; 61 ; 62 ; 38 ) Daniel A. Paradiso, Sarah Vallejo, Eric R. Coughlin Abstract Some high-mass stars likely end their lives in underluminous implosions that leave behind a black hole, known as failed supernovae (FSNe). However, neutrinos radiated during proto-neutron star formation generate a weak (Mach ≳ 1 \gtrsim 1 ) shockwave in the outer layers of the star, which produces a unique transient as it breaks out of the dying star and signals its imminent disappearance. It was recently shown that there are two self-similar solutions that describe the propagation of this weak shockwave, and these solutions simultaneously contain outward-moving ejecta and fallback accretion onto the black hole. Here we show that the larger Mach number solutions are unstable, such that the Mach number of the shock grows with time t t and deviates from the self-similar prediction as ∝ t α \propto t^{\alpha} , with α ≲ 0.1 \alpha\lesssim 0.1 , whereas the smaller Mach number solutions are stable. We also show that, above a critical mass loss that is readily achievable in core-collapse supernovae, the shock asymptotically strengthens and approaches the strong limit. Our results imply that it is the mass lost to neutrinos relative to the mass enclosed by the shockwave, as well as the stellar density gradient where the shock forms, that primarily dictate its strength and the amount of material it ejects. These criteria explain why red supergiants, which have relative mass losses well in excess of the critical value at the time of shock formation, more readily eject material and create more luminous explosions compared to more compact progenitors. I Introduction The birth of stellar mass black holes from failed supernovae (FSNe) – the unsuccessful explosions resulting from the core collapse of massive ( \gtrsim 8M_{\odot} ) stars – is indirectly evidenced by, for example, discrepancies between high mass star formation and core-collapse supernova (CCSN) rates ( 36 ; 73 ) , the observed mass distribution of compact objects (e.g., 41 ; 42 ; 68 ; 25 ; 77 ; 80 ; 46 ), and numerical simulations of CCSNe (e.g., 9 ; 75 ; 54 ; 11 ), and represent plausible progenitors of some luminous fast blue optical transients (LFBOTs; e.g., 26 ; 39 ; 52 ; 16 ; 35 ; 82 ; 14 ; 45 ; 63 ). Two supergiant stars in nearby galaxies have also recently been observed fading in luminosity before disappearing without an associated CCSN, tentatively making them the first direct detections of FSNe and stellar mass black hole formation ( 32 ; 1 ; 5 ; 43 ; 24 ; 23 ; 29 ; but see 6 ; 7 ; 74 ). In particular, observations and theory suggest that it is high mass ( \gtrsim 18M_{\odot} ; 73 ) stars with a high central mass concentration — commonly referred to as “compactness” — at the onset of core-collapse that are prone to failure ( 56 ; 75 ; 27 ; 51 ) . Therefore, unless the rotation of the progenitor facilitates the formation of a disk — which could lead to the launching of jets in an accretion-powered transient (e.g., 81 ; 50 ; 66 ; 33 ) — these compact stars experience a higher accretion rate onto the neutron star formed during core-collapse, thereby expediting black hole formation and precluding traditional stellar explosion. Nevertheless, even these “failed” explosions are capable of producing a transient that signifies the death of the star and formation of a solar mass black hole, i.e., failed supernovae are not identically “disappearing stars.” Specifically, neutrino emission during neutron star formation reduces the gravitational mass of the core by \sim 0.1-0.5M_{\odot} ( 12 ; 44 ) . While \sim 1\% of these weakly interacting neutrinos deposit energy in the region behind the stalled neutron star bounce shock — i.e., the typical “neutrino explosion mechanism” (e.g., 15 ; 8 ) — the vast majority stream unimpeded through the overlying stellar envelope. In the outer regions of the star, this reduction in the gravitational potential of the core occurs effectively instantaneously, as the time it takes for neutrinos to stream out of the progenitor — the combination of the neutrino diffusion time ( \sim 1-10~\rm seconds ; e.g., 10 ; 65 ) and the light crossing time ( \sim hours) — is negligible in comparison to the local dynamical time near the stellar surface ( \sim weeks to months). At these large radii the stellar envelope then responds dynamically and outwardly to this liberation of mass-energy, and this outward-moving region is connected to the inner and infalling region (where material is accreting onto the black hole) via a second, relatively weak (Mach number order unity) shockwave (e.g., 49 ; 18 ; 28 ), a mechanism first considered by 55 . The formation of these weak, neutrino mass loss-induced shockwaves and their potential to unbind the envelopes of supergiant stars has since been studied analytically (e.g., 64 ; 18 ; 19 ; 20 ) and numerically (e.g., 49 ; 48 ; 28 ; 78 ; 37 ; 22 ; 2 ). This work has shown that the result of the explosion is heavily dependent on the type of supergiant, the overall stellar structure, and the neutron star equation of state ( 28 ; 37 ; 22 ) . Specifically, stars with extended and shallow envelopes, as is common in red supergiants, are conducive to generating longer-duration explosions with up to a few solar masses of material ejected, whereas more compact stars such as blue and yellow supergiants generate shorter duration transients with only a few\times 0.1M_{\odot} of ejecta ( 28 ) . Additionally, it has been shown that angular momentum due to convective motions in the outer regions of the infalling stellar envelope can inhibit accretion onto the nascent black hole, leading to the formation of a disk, launching of jets, and unbinding of the stellar envelope (e.g., 34 ; 67 ; 3 ; 4 ). The propagation of a weak shockwave in a point-mass gravitational field of mass M that forms in response to an instantaneous loss of mass \delta M was shown to have a self-similar solution by Coughlin ( 21 ; hereafter 21 ), provided that the relative neutrino mass loss \delta M/M is below a critical value that is typically a few percent the mass of the star. These shockwaves have Mach numbers of at most a few, exhibit accretion onto the nascent black hole, and are dependent on the relative amount of mass lost to neutrinos, \delta M/M , for which two self-similar solutions exist below the critical value. We characterize these solutions by their Mach number, and refer to them as the “strong” and “weak” solutions, with the strong (weak) solution having the larger (smaller) Mach number of the two. These solutions also depend on the ambient medium into which the shock is propagating, which is non-hydrostatic as a consequence of the neutrino mass loss, with the self-similar ambient fluid profiles being characterized by the ambient density power-law index n , adiabatic index \gamma , and relative mass