A diagrammatic proof-theoretic semantics for the Greimas semiotic square
Michael D. Fowler · 2026
Read A diagrammatic proof-theoretic semantics for the Greimas semiotic square by Michael D. Fowler (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-05273.txt.
Introduction
Michael Fowler builds a diagrammatic proof system for a fragment of structural semantics based on the Greimas semiotic square, a classic square of opposed meaning terms. Basic terms become diagram layouts in a spider diagram system, and links such as contradiction and implication become changes ruled by inference rules. Proofs, shown by proof trees, carry out the meaning-building step by step.
Fowler's main result shows the four meta-terms of the square arise the same way, each derived from a pair of basic configurations through one fixed proof pattern. Negation in the diagrams turns out not to be a full Boolean flip but a narrow counter-stance set by zones. The framework gives the field a rule-based footing.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael D. Fowler |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.05273
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A diagrammatic proof-theoretic semantics for the Greimas semiotic square Michael D. Fowler Abstract We develop a diagrammatic proof system for a fragment of structural semantics inspired by the Greimas semiotic square, using spider diagrams as the underlying formalism. The basic terms are represented as diagrammatic configurations, and the relations of contradiction and implication are interpreted as transformations governed by a set of inference rules. These transformations are realised as derivations, with proof trees serving as witnesses. Our main result shows that the construction of the four meta-terms can be captured uniformly: each is derivable from a conjunctive pair of basic configurations via a fixed derivation schema composed of contour introduction and habitat transformation rules. This yields a proof-theoretic account of the combinatorial operation underlying meta-term formation, and provides a semantic interpretation of the Greimasian operation ‘+’ as a derivational construction rather than a logical combination. We further show that diagrammatic negation in this setting is not a Boolean complement, but a restricted, zone-determined semantic counter-position, reflecting the relational character of opposition in structural semiotics. The resulting framework provides a compositional, rule-based semantics in which complex configurations are generated constructively from simpler ones. In addition to extending the expressive scope of spider diagram calculi, the system illustrates how diagrammatic reasoning can be used to formalise non-classical semantic operations within a unified inferential setting. MSC Classification]03B47,03B20, 03B22 keywords diagrammatic reasoning, spider diagrams, semiotic square, structural semantics, proof-theoretic semantics, non-Boolean negation, diagrammatic logic, Greimas pacs [ 1 Introduction Diagrammatic reasoning systems provide formal frameworks in which logical structure is represented and manipulated visually through rule-governed transformations. Among such systems, spider diagrams offer a well-developed diagrammatic calculus for reasoning about set-theoretic and existential information, equipped with a sound and complete system of inference rules. In this paper, we develop a diagrammatic proof system based on unitary spider diagrams for representing and transforming a class of semantic configurations inspired by the semiotic square. The semiotic square is an analytic and heuristic tool for investigating signification in literary contexts and was developed in the early 1960s by Algirdas Julien Greimas (1917-1992) who initiated a research program to develop a structuralist theory of meaning that was based on how oppositional relations between concepts iterate within narratives. As Hawkes suggests, Greimas attempted “to describe narrative structure in terms of an established linguistic model derived from the Saussurean notion of an underlying langue or competence which generates a specific parole or performance, as well as from Saussure’s and Jakobson’s concept of the fundamental signifying role of binary opposition.” ( 12 , page 69) Greimasian structural semiotics establishes the notion of a seme (denoted /seme/) as the smallest irreducible unit of meaning for which when in combination, form a sememe, or the smallest unit of meaning that associates to a morpheme or lexeme, and is thus analogous to a phoneme in phonology. For example the sememe ‘cat’ contains the semes of /animal/, /pet/, /feline/ etc. What Greimas calls a homologation is defined as a structure in which two sememes S and S^{\prime} will be called homologous in relation to non- S and non- S^{\prime} if they have in common a semic content s (that is to say, at least one seme) which, considered as a positive term, is present at the same time, under its negative form of non- s , in the sememes non- S and non- S^{\prime} . ( 9 , page xxxi) As Hawkes suggests, this framing is heavily influenced by both the structural linguistics of 21 as well as how 17 identified constitutive units of myths as emerging from the condition: \frac{A}{\mathrm{non-}A}\,\,\cong\,\,\frac{B}{\mathrm{non-}B}\,\,. (1) Greimas and Courtés similarly consider this condition as not only relevant to myths or folktales, but more generally applicable to all semiotic domains of cultural production (i.e., texts, art, music). Homologation is thus considered a “procedure of structuration” ( 7 , page 144) which is commonly formulated as: A:B::A^{\prime}:B^{\prime}. (2) Under the analytic lens of the structural semiotics of Greimas, sign systems then become assemblages of differences where meaning arises not from inherent qualities but from relational positions within a structure. A seme itself is thus not autonomous or “atomistic,” but instead “exists only because of the differential gap that opposes it to other semes.” ( 7 , page 278) By this we mean that semes themselves follow the type of structure of opposition given in Equation ( 2 ), and form what Greimas calls semic categories ( 10 , page 16) . These semic categories constitute the content plane, and therefore are considered anterior to the collection of semes that form the categories themselves. But there is structure here too, which becomes fully formed and visualized through Greimas’ most well-known contribution, the semiotic square. Here, 8 define a family of relations that include: contrariety ( ), contradiction ( ) and implication ( ) between a seme pair (s_{1},s_{2}) and their negations (\neg s_{1},\neg s_{2}) , and visualise these relations through the diagram given in Figure 1 . s_{1} s_{2} \neg s_{2} \neg s_{2} \bf{S} \bf\bar{S} Positive Deixis Negative Deixis Figure 1 : The Greimas semiotic square. The seme pair of \{s_{1},s_{2}\} is known as the complex axis, and \{\neg s_{1},\neg s_{2}\} the neutral axis. The four central terms of \{s_{1},s_{2},\neg s_{1},\neg s_{2}\} thus allow for other meta-terms as sememes to be derived. The procedures for these constructions are found through the “combing of the four simple terms.” ( 13 , page 81) This yields \displaystyle\bf{S}= \displaystyle(s_{1}+s_{2}),\quad\mathrm{complex\,\,term}, \displaystyle\bf\bar{S}= \displaystyle(\neg s_{1}+\neg s_{2}),\quad\mathrm{neutral\,\,term}, as well as the Positive Deixis = ( s_{1}+\neg s_{2} ), and Negative Deixis = ( \neg s_{1}+s_{2} ). The Greimas square has become the most popular tool in the structural semiotics method for identifying and tracking of structures of homologation within narratives, with Greimas and Courtés arguing that it represents “a rigorous formulation of reasoning by analogy.” ( 7 , page 144) Yet, despite its importance, a formalisation of the process by which homologations are established within the semiotic square often remains under-specified. The contribution of this paper is to extend spider diagram calculi of 15 to a new semantic domain by providing a proof-theoretic reconstruction of the operations underlying the Greimas square. Specifically, spider diagrams allow for a formalisation of the under-specification found in the initial binary term-pair s_{1} and s_{2} . Here, Courtés describes this binary pair as formed through a ‘contrariety’ (denoted s_{1}/s_{2} ), which corresponds to the notion that two terms may be said to be contrary when the presence of one presupposes the presence of the other, and when the absence of one goes hand in hand with the absence of the other. More generally speaking, two terms (S1 and S2) are said to be contrary if the negation of one implies the affirmation of the other and vice versa. ( 2 ) Hébert acknowledges the subtleties of distinguishing between the relation of contrariety and contradiction in the square through defining contradiction as “categorical” and contrariety as “gradual”: . . . in classical logic, true and false are contradictories, since not-true equals false and not-false equals true; however, rich and poor are contraries, since not-rich does not necessarily equal poor, and not-poor does not necessarily equal rich . . . Opposition can be viewed in several