Growth of shear failure in snow slab avalanche release: analytical solution for a compliant weak layer with finite softening

Johan Gaume, Francis Meloche, Ingrid Reiweger · 2026

Read Growth of shear failure in snow slab avalanche release: analytical solution for a compliant weak layer with finite softening by Johan Gaume, Francis Meloche, Ingrid Reiweger (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-05061.txt.

Introduction

Johan Gaume and three co-authors derive exact solutions for how failure spreads in the weak layer under a snow slab, the process that releases slab avalanches. Many earlier models treat the weak layer as perfectly brittle or ignore its elasticity before the peak load. Both softening after the peak and compliance before it shape stress redistribution and the critical crack length.

Their solution divides the failing zone into a softened core, a fracture process zone, and intact elastic material, recovering the classic brittle length when softening vanishes. Particle simulations confirm the predicted stress profiles and lengths. The same framework is then extended to collapse-driven anticrack propagation, linking two avalanche release pictures.

Catalog record

CREATORJohan Gaume, Francis Meloche, Ingrid Reiweger
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.05061

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Growth of shear failure in snow slab avalanche release: analytical solution for a compliant weak layer with finite softening Johan Gaume, Francis Meloche, Ingrid Reiweger Abstract Snow slab avalanches are among the most dangerous natural hazards in mountain regions. They are responsible for most avalanche accidents and fatalities among recreationists, while large events can also threaten settlements and infrastructure, with potentially severe consequences for human lives. Recent progress in numerical modelling, field measurements, and large-scale fracture experiments has renewed interest in shear-failure interpretations of avalanche release, particularly in connection with dynamic crack propagation and supershear fracture. Yet, most existing stress-based models of weak-layer shear failure either assume a perfectly brittle stress drop from peak strength to residual friction, thereby neglecting the energy dissipated during post-peak softening, or neglect the pre-peak elastic response of the weak layer, which can strongly influence stress redistribution and the resulting critical crack length. Here, we derive an analytical solution for shear failure propagation in a weak layer buried beneath an elastic snow slab, explicitly accounting for finite post-peak softening and for the elastic mismatch between the slab and the weak layer. Building on the one-dimensional weak-spot framework of 3 , we consider a symmetric failure composed of a fully softened zone at residual strength, a fracture process zone with linear softening, and an intact elastic region. In the limit of vanishing softening displacement δ \delta , the model recovers the classical stress-based critical length a c ​ 0 a_{c0} . For finite softening, the solution distinguishes between the fully softened crack length a c a_{c} and the total affected length b c b_{c} , which also includes the fracture process zone. This distinction is essential for comparison with numerical models, which may measure the complete damaged region rather than the fully softened zone alone. The presented model formulation provides a direct analytical link between stress-based weak-spot approaches and fracture-energy concepts, since the fracture-energy contribution enters through the constitutive softening law rather than through an externally imposed propagation criterion. For small softening, the exact solution yields a compact approximation for the fully softened crack length, a c ≃ a c ​ 0 ​ 1 + C a ​ δ / u p a_{c}\simeq a_{c0}\sqrt{1+C_{a}\delta/u_{p}} while the fracture-process-zone length grows linearly with the softening displacement, ω ∝ Λ ​ δ u p \omega\propto\Lambda\,\frac{\delta}{u_{p}} . The total affected length then follows as b c = a c + ω b_{c}=a_{c}+\omega , where u p u_{p} is the displacement at peak strength and C a C_{a} and C b C_{b} are dimensionless coefficients determined by the peak, residual, and gravitational shear stresses and Λ \Lambda is the characteristic elastic length of the system. Finally, we discuss how the same three-zone reasoning can be extended to the onset of anticrack propagation. In this case, slab bending introduces a distinct bending-controlled length scale proportional to δ 1 / 4 \delta^{1/4} , in contrast to the δ 1 / 2 \delta^{1/2} scaling of the shear problem. The corresponding compressive anticrack analogue admits an exact three-zone analytical reduction, although it does not reduce to a compact scalar expression comparable to the shear case. Three-dimensional MPM simulations support the resulting quarter-power dependence of the anticrack lengths on the compressive softening distance. 1 Introduction Snow slab avalanche release is commonly described as a fracture process occurring in a weak snow layer buried beneath a cohesive slab. Although many modern theories emphasize weak-layer collapse and anticrack propagation, the first analytical framework for snow slab avalanche release was fundamentally shear-based. Inspired by 16 , 13 formulated the onset of crack propagation as the unstable extension of a shear band in a strain-softening weak layer, introducing the key idea that post-peak weakening provides the mechanical driving mechanism for release. This approach established a direct link between weak-layer strength, softening, slab load, and critical crack length. Related shear-based models were later developed by 2 and 3 , the latter also including residual friction. However, these models not only neglected weak-layer elasticity, thereby leading to the unrealistic prediction of a zero critical crack length in the limit of vanishing softening distance, or fracture toughness, but also failed to explain key field observations such as remote triggering, whumpfs, and crack propagation on flat or low-angle terrain. The latter limitation motivated the anticrack theory of 9 , in which weak-layer collapse induces slab bending and drives a compressive fracture with the closure of the crack faces. This anticrack framework successfully explained several observations that were difficult to reconcile with shear-only models and strongly influenced subsequent analytical and numerical work. The anticrack concept was later incorporated into numerous numerical models. In particular, the finite-element models of 11 ; 26 and the discrete-element simulations of 6 ; 7 ; 1 highlighted the importance of weak-layer collapse, slab bending, and mixed-mode fracture processes in governing both the onset and the subsequent dynamics of crack propagation. These studies progressively shifted much of the theoretical interpretation of slab avalanche release from a purely shear-driven instability toward a collapse-driven anticrack mechanism. More recently, efficient closed-form analytical models were introduced by 20 ; 21 . These approaches capture not only failure initiation but also the onset of crack propagation, including the effects of layering in the overlying slab ( 27 ) , overcoming the limitations of previous effective-stiffness models ( 15 ) . However, recent work has shown that shear-based mechanisms remain essential, especially on steep slopes and at large propagation distances. Numerical simulations by 25 demonstrated a transition from sub-Rayleigh anticrack propagation to supershear crack propagation on slopes, indicating that once dynamic propagation is established, weak-layer collapse and slab bending may become secondary, with propagation then primarily driven by shear failure in the weak layer. This interpretation was further explored by 8 ; 14 , who used a depth-averaged Material Point Method (MPM) with a weak-layer shear-softening interface to study the onset and dynamics of crack propagation, crack arrest, and avalanche release size at slope scale. In parallel, 24 provided a theoretical framework for dynamic crack propagation regimes, extending the unbounded theory of 10 while explicitly incorporating weak-layer properties. These recent developments bring renewed relevance to 13 ’s original shear concept. They suggest that although weak-layer collapse is crucial for crack nucleation and anticrack propagation on flat or low-angle terrain and during the early stages of crack propagation on slopes, the dynamics of large slab avalanches on steep slopes may be governed to first order by shear failure and softening in the weak layer. The objective of the present paper is therefore to revisit softening shear-based theory within a modern analytical framework that extends 13 ’s model to a situation in which the elastic mismatch between the slab and the weak layer is considered. By explicitly accounting for weak-layer compliance and post-peak weakening, we derive a comprehensive analytical model that connects weak-layer and slab mechanical properties to the onset of crack propagation. The resulting formulation provides a mechanics-based criterion for evaluating crack propagation propensity in a slab–weak-layer system, while accounting for weak-layer elasticity, strength, residual friction, and fracture energy through the constitutive softening law itself. 2 Analytical model We first note that, for clarity, we use the notation a_{c} to denote the critical crack length for the onset

Read the complete text