Efficient GMM and Weighting Matrix under Misspecification
Byunghoon Kang · 2026
Read Efficient GMM and Weighting Matrix under Misspecification by Byunghoon Kang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-04961.txt.
Introduction
Byunghoon Kang develops a more efficient version of the generalised method of moments, a workhorse estimation technique in econometrics, for cases where the model's conditions do not hold exactly. Under such misspecification, the standard estimator's behaviour depends on both those conditions and their slopes. Kang builds estimators from widened, shifted conditions that include that extra information.
Weighting the widened system optimally gives an estimator with the smallest large-sample spread for the same target quantity, with the standard method as a special case. Kang also proposes a feasible bootstrap version and proves uniform lower bounds over weighting choices. Simulations and two real-data examples show the gains.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Byunghoon Kang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 110 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.04961
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Efficient GMM and Weighting Matrix under Misspecification Byunghoon Kang Abstract This paper develops efficient GMM estimation when the moment conditions are misspecified. We observe that the influence function of the standard GMM estimator under misspecification depends on both the original moment conditions and their Jacobian, motivating a new class of estimators based on augmented moment conditions with recentering. The standard GMM estimator is a special case within this class, and generally suboptimal. By optimally weighting the augmented system, we obtain a misspecification-efficient (ME) estimator with the smallest asymptotic variance for the same GMM pseudo-true value. In linear models, the asymptotic variance of ME estimator reduces to the textbook efficient-GMM variance formula ( G ′ W ∗ G ) − 1 (G^{\prime}W^{*}G)^{-1} , where W ∗ W^{*} is the inverse of the variance of residualized moments after projection on the Jacobian G G . We consider a feasible double-recentered bootstrap estimator, which can be considered as a misspecification-robust and efficient version of Hall and Horowitz (1996) recentered bootstrap GMM estimator, and also consider a split-sample ME estimator. Finally, we establish uniform local asymptotic minimax bounds over a class of weighting matrices. We illustrate the proposed methods in simulation and empirical examples. Keywords: Generalized method of moments, misspecification, pseudo-true value, semiparametric efficiency, augmented moment conditions, bootstrap, instrumental variables JEL classification: C12, C13, C14, C26. 1 Introduction The generalized method of moments (GMM) offers a robust framework for estimation and inference, and is widely used in applied econometrics. When the model is over-identified, where the number of available moment conditions exceeds the number of parameters, the GMM estimator depends on the choice of weight matrix. Under the assumption of the correct model specification when there exists a unique true parameter that satisfies the population moment conditions exactly equal to zero, the efficient weighting matrix is the inverse of the variance-covariance matrix of the moments. This choice achieves the smallest asymptotic variance among standard GMM estimators (Hansen (1982), Chamberlain (1987)), and researchers often use this efficient weight in practice, for example, an inverse of the variance of the instruments in the instrumental variables (IV) setup, or a Heteroskedasticity and Autocorrelation Consistent (HAC) matrix estimator. However, economic models are inherently structural approximations, and the overidentifying restriction test is often rejected due to various forms of misspecification; candidate instruments may be invalid, lag structures or functional forms are misspecified or treatment effect heterogeneity makes no parameter satisfies all moment equations exactly. The presence of misspecification has significant implications for the properties of estimators, potentially affecting asymptotic distribution, and consequently, the validity of standard inference procedures. Recognizing this challenge, a growing literature studies the inference for the pseudo-true value, defined as the population minimizer of the objective functions, including Hall and Inoue (2003), Müller (2013), Hansen and Lee (2021), and Andrews and Kwon (2024) among others. 1 1 1 Defining the pseudo-true value as minimizers of population criterion has a long tradition in econometrics, including White (1982), Hall and Inoue (2003), Müller (2013), Hansen and Lee (2021), etc. In the asset pricing literature, such as Kan and Robotti (2009) and Gospodinov, Kan, and Robotti (2014), the GMM pseudo-true value can be defined as a minimizer of the distance metric of Hansen and Jagannathan (1997). Under misspecification, the asymptotic variance of the GMM estimator has different forms than the standard GMM variance estimator, and ignoring this can lead to inconsistent standard error estimation and asymptotically invalid confidence intervals for the pseudo-true values, which was also highlighted in Andrews, Chen and Techhio (2025). More importantly, misspecification fundamentally changes the role of the weighting matrix, and has different implications than the correct specification setup. The choice of the weighting matrix no longer merely affects the statistical efficiency of the estimator, but it also affects what is being estimated; different weighting matrices corresponds to different target parameters. 2 2 2 We are well aware that pseudo-true values, in general, may be possibly different from quantities of economic interest (Müller (2013), Andrews, Barnhard, and Carlson (2024)). The main focus of this paper is not on the identification and the causal interpretation of the widely used GMM/TSLS estimators, but on the valid and improved inference for the same GMM/TSLS estimand under moment misspecification. We refer the readers to other influential papers (and references therein) such as Kolesár (2013), Mogstad et al. (2021), Blandhol et al. (2025), and Sloczyński (2024) for advances in this direction in the linear IV model under treatment effect heterogeneity. See also Andrews, Barahona, et al. (2025) for the potentially misspecified general structural model. This dual role of the weighting matrix under misspecification raises a number of questions that the standard GMM literature does not directly address. Is the “standard” optimal weight, defined under correct specification, still efficient under misspecification? Does any other class of estimators exist with a smaller asymptotic variance than the standard GMM under misspecification for the same target? How should we think about asymptotic efficiency across different weighting matrices when each weighting matrix targets a different estimand? This paper addresses these challenging questions and provides theoretical and some empirical guidance for researchers using overidentified GMM models. First of all, by focusing on the fixed weighting matrix W and the associated pseudo-true parameter \theta_{W} , we consider the class of M-estimator where the original moment functions and the Jacobian moments are “stacked” to form a vector of augmented moment conditions with recentering. This is based on the novel observation that the “standard” GMM estimators under misspecification can be expressed as an influence function of the augmented moments. The proposed M-estimator is a general class of estimators that include the “standard” misspecified-GMM as a special case. We then define the “efficient estimator” within this class, which we label as a “misspecification-efficient” (ME) estimator, that has the smallest asymptotic variance that is consistent for the same GMM pseudo-true value. By applying the optimal weighting derived from the inverse of the variance matrix of the augmented moments, the proposed ME estimator captures the correlation between the moments and the Jacobian and extracts additional identifying information from the moment misspecification; while the standard misspecified-GMM is suboptimal with particular linear combination of the available moments dictated by the usual GMM first-order condition. The ME estimator is not directly feasible because its construction requires the population recentering of the original and Jacobian moments. However, our asymptotic result of the oracle-ME estimator is constructive in the sense that the variance of ME estimator can be easily estimated (without knowing these unknown quantities) and reported as a measure of efficiency frontier; showing researchers what could be gained by imposing an additional information from the misspecification and identification strength. Furthermore, our results provide new insights into the conventional (correct-specification) optimal weighting matrix and variance of the efficient GMM. Under the linear model, the asymptotic variance of the ME estimator simplifies to V_{ME}(W)=(G^{\prime}\Sigma_{11,2}^{-1}G)^{-1} , where G is Jacobian, \Sigma_{11,2}=\Sigma_{11}-\Sigma_{12}\Sigma_{22}^{-1}\Sigma_{21} , and \Sigma=(\begin{smallmatrix}\Sigma_{11}&\Sigma_{12}\\ \Sigma_{21}&\Sigma_{22}\end{smallmatrix}) is the variance of the augmented moments. The weighting matrix W^{*}=\Sigma_{11,2}^{-1} is the inverse of the variance of residualized moment after projection on the Jacobian, while the conventional (correct-specification) efficient weighting matrix W_{0}=\Sigma_{11}^{-1} is the inverse of the variance of the original moments. This variance expression in linear models has two notable