Energy-error tradeoff in encoding quantum error correction
Josey Stevens, Sebastian Deffner · 2026
Read Energy-error tradeoff in encoding quantum error correction by Josey Stevens, Sebastian Deffner (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-04329.txt.
Introduction
Josey Stevens and Sebastian Deffner analyse how much energy it costs to encode protected quantum states, a practical question for building fault-tolerant quantum computers. Error correction is widely seen as necessary for useful quantum advantage, but whether its physical demands are feasible is less clear.
They work through three standard codes, from the simple repetition code to the Steane code, and find a universal trade-off between encoding precision and energy cost. The required energy depends strongly on the physical setup chosen, and it grows exponentially as the target precision rises. That scaling sets a concrete challenge for future hardware designs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Josey Stevens, Sebastian Deffner |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.04329
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Energy-error tradeoff in encoding quantum error correction Josey Stevens, Sebastian Deffner Abstract While it has been widely recognized that genuine quantum advantage for practical problems might only be achieved with fault-tolerant quantum computers, it is still not entirely clear whether the required quantum error correction will be physically feasible. In the present work, we carefully analyze the required energy resources to encode the logical qubit states for repetition, perfect, and Steane codes. We find that there is a universal trade-off between the target precision and the required energetic resources. Importantly, we find that the energetic resources intimately depend on the specific physical realization of a quantum error correction code, and that the required resources scale exponentially with the targeted precision of the encoding. I Introduction The development of practically useful quantum computers will require the realization of quantum error correcting (QEC) codes 37 in order to combat decoherence 44 ; 39 that is detrimental to the delicate nature of quantum correlations. Since it is exactly these quantum correlations from which quantum advantage can arise, realizing QEC might be the single most important challenge in the technological development of industry-scale quantum computers 25 ; 38 . To date, hundreds of QEC schemes 3 have been proposed that differ greatly in their fault-tolerant implementation, scalability, size, and distance. However, estimating the computational overhead required for QEC schemes is difficult due to challenges in simulating large quantum systems; yet, it is commonly expected that a single logical qubit will require hundreds to tens of thousands 13 ; 18 of physical qubits. This means that the vast majority of the computational complexity associated with quantum computing will be utilized in the overhead of QEC. In realizing a quantum computer, designers will have to determine the resources required to operate and run their devices. This will include overhead resources of materials and manufacturing costs as well as energy requirements for the sustainment of the coherent quantum system, i.e. maintaining vacuum, trapping ions, or cooling superconducting materials. These costs are difficult to accurately project into the future, as they are subject to the unpredictability of technology advancement. Thus, the collected efforts to precisely quantify the energy requirements for quantum technologies has led to the foundation of a “quantum energy initiative” 4 . However, energy is not only consumed in the technology surrounding the quantum processing unit, but also for the simple fact that any processing of information incurs a thermodynamic cost 22 . Thus in a complete assessment of the resources required for quantum computing, will account for the cost of maintaining the computing environment as well as the resources required to perform the computation, namely the number of quantum gates and the energies associated with operating them. Steps toward assessing the number of gates required for QEC exist in the form of threshold theorems 19 ; 1 which provide a poly-log upper bound on the number of gates required to implement a QEC code provided a given error threshold is satisfied. The primary purpose of this work is to analyze the energetic requirements for implementing QEC. Interestingly, it has already been recognized that the particular way any quantum algorithm is transpiled onto quantum hardware is of thermodynamic significance 32 ; 7 ; 11 . However, a detailed looked a specific realizations of QEC appears to be lacking. Building off our recent work on the energetic requirements of single gate operations 41 , in the present work we develop a comprehensive understanding of the energetic requirements for reptition, perfect, and Steane QECs. To this end, in section II we introduce both the computational model, energy definitions, and noise types to be utilized throughout the treatment. Section III then provides an overview of QEC before exploring the tradeoff of energy and computation errors for the quantum repetition codes (subsection III.1 ) and the five qubit perfect code (subsection III.2 ) and finally compare these with the Steane code (subsection III.3 ). Particular attention is paid on exploring how changing the encoding circuits of a QEC affects the error performance. II Computational model Since our goal is to explore both the lower bound resource requirements and effects of gate-level noise on error corrected computations, we need a qubit control scheme that includes both a noise model and provides insight into the energetic requirements required to implement a gate. To this end, we utilize the precision-noise model previously developed only recently in Ref. 41 , in which we demonstrated that the lower-bound on the energy in the classical electromagnetic field used to control a quantum system is inversely related to the square of the gate-errors. These errors arise from quantum fluctuations in the coherent electromagnetic field and allow us to analyze the energy-error tradeoff with true gate-level noise model that does not rely on insertion of random Pauli-errors. Since classical magnetic and electric fields serve as the foundational control for trapped ion 34 ; 10 , semiconducting 20 ; 42 ; 33 , and superconducting qubits 23 ; 24 ; 36 ; 5 , these models provide insight into idealized implementations of these quantum computing platforms. In this error scheme, a quantum gate, U_{G} , is implemented efficiently using a constant Hamiltonian 2 via a tensor-product decomposition of the form, H_{G}=\frac{i}{\hbar\tau}\text{ln}(U_{G})=-i\sum_{i}\lambda_{i}\bigotimes_{j=1}^{N}C_{i,j} (1) where C_{i,j} are Hamiltonian terms that act on individual degrees of freedom and satisfy \left[\bigotimes_{j=1}^{N}C_{i,j},\bigotimes_{j=1}^{N}C_{k,j}\right]=0 , and \tau is the period over which the gate is driven. This control scheme allows for the formulation of a tight lower bound on the control-energy required to implement the gate, \braket{E_{L}^{G}}\geq\frac{\hbar\omega_{0}}{4}\sum_{i}\frac{\left|\lambda_{i}^{G}\right|^{2}}{\epsilon_{i}^{2}}. (2) where \omega_{0} is the lowest frequency in the control field, and \epsilon_{i} is the standard deviation of the associated coefficient \lambda_{i} resulting from the quantum fluctuations in the classical electromagnetic control field modes that couples to their respective term in the interaction Hamiltonian. The bound is tight for all Hamiltonians of this form and it is a universal lower-bound for gates provided that a Hamiltonian is decomposed into an efficient minimal coefficient multiset, \lambda^{G} . A list of efficient coefficient multisets and lower bounds on the required control energy for common one and two-qubit gates is provided in Tab. 1 . Gate \lambda^{\text{G}} \frac{\braket{E_{L}^{\text{G}}}}{\hbar\omega_{0}}\,\left[\frac{\pi^{2}}{\epsilon^{2}}\right] X \{\pi/2,\pi/2\} 1/8 Y \{\pi/2,\pi/2\} 1/8 Z \{\pi/2,\pi/2\} 1/8 C-X \{2\cdot\pi/4,2\cdot-\pi/4\} 1/16 C-Y \{2\cdot\pi/4,2\cdot-\pi/4\} 1/16 C-Z \{2\cdot\pi/4,2\cdot-\pi/4\} 1/16 H \{\pi/2,\pi/2\} 1/8 Q \{\pi/2,2\cdot-\pi/\sqrt{8}\} 1/8 S \{\pi/2\} 1/16 Table 1: Table of common quantum gates, and the coefficient multisets that implement them efficiently, and the resulting lower bound on the control-energy needed to implement them. X, Y, and Z are the Pauli spin operators, and C- are their associated controlled variants. H is the Hadamard gate, \text{Q}=(\text{Z}+\text{Y})/\sqrt{2} , and S is the P(\pi/2) phase shift gate. Note the use of multiset notation where \{N\cdot\lambda\} indicates N independent but repeated inclusions of \lambda . Figure 1: The gate error (one minus the average gate fidelity) as a function of the lower bound on the control energies required to implement the gates. Shown here are the Pauli- X gate (green), controlled-NOT gate (blue), Q=\left(X+Y\right)\sqrt{2} (gold-dashed), and the phase gate, S=\sqrt{Z} (red). Not shown here are the remaining Pauli gates and their controlled variants which show identical behavior to the Pauli- X and controlled-NOT gates respectively. For all