The jet-shaped pipe morphology in planetary nebulae and core-collapse supernova remnants

Jessica Braudo, Noam Soker · 2026

Read The jet-shaped pipe morphology in planetary nebulae and core-collapse supernova remnants by Jessica Braudo, Noam Soker (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-03961.txt.

Introduction

Jessica Braudo and Noam Soker compare the shapes of core-collapse supernova remnants and jet-shaped planetary nebulae. Both can share an unusual feature: a narrow, faint zone, called a pipe, extending from side to side. They present two jet-shaped planetary nebulae with a pipe. They present three more with two opposite narrow jet-shaped lobes. The lobes, they argue, can later merge into a single pipe.

A three-dimensional hydrodynamic simulation reproduces two opposite narrow lobes similar to those observed. The simulation explodes a massive star with three pairs of jets, within the jittering jets explosion mechanism framework. The simulated and observed morphologies look alike in both object classes. From that similarity, the authors argue jets shaped the pipes in the supernova remnants as well. That strengthens the case for the jittering jets mechanism.

Catalog record

CREATORJessica Braudo, Noam Soker
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03961

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The jet-shaped pipe morphology in planetary nebulae and core-collapse supernova remnants Jessica Braudo, Noam Soker Abstract We compare images of core-collapse supernova (CCSN) remnants (CCSNRs) and jet-shaped planetary nebulae (PNe) that have a narrow, faint zone extending from side to side, termed a pipe, with a hydrodynamical numerical simulation exploding a massive star with three pairs of jets in the framework of the jittering jets explosion mechanism (JJEM), and conclude that jets shaped the pipes in these CCSNRs and PNe. We present two jet-shaped PNe with a pipe and three PNe with two opposite narrow jet-shaped lobes, and argue that in some cases the two opposite narrow lobes might merge to form one long, faint zone extending from side to side of the PN, namely, a pipe. From the qualitative similarity of the pipe morphology of the two CCSNRs we analyze with the pipe of the PNe, we suggest that jets also shaped the pipe of these CCSNRs. We strengthen this conclusion with a three-dimensional hydrodynamic simulation that reproduces two opposite narrow lobes, similar to those observed in PNe with lobes. These lobes can merge later to form a pipe. This paper is another in a series that strengthen the case for the JJEM as the primary explosion mechanism of CCSNe by comparing CCSNR morphologies with those of jet-shaped PNe. I Introduction The identifications of similar jet-shaped morphological features in planetary nebulae (PNe) and core-collapse supernova (CCSN) remnants (CCSNRs) in the last decade have strengthened the notion that jets play significant roles in powering and shaping their formation (for reviews see 100 ; 103 ). The similar morphological features include barrel-shaped and H-shaped structures (e.g., 2 ), point-symmetric structures, including multipolar structures (e.g., 14 ; 99 ; 12 ), the presence of opposite pairs of rings (e.g., 97 ), the presence of opposite pairs of ears, rims, and nozzles (e.g., 13 ; 11 ; 36 ; 102 ; 107 ). Point-symmetrical morphologies have two or more pairs of opposite structural features that do not share the same symmetry axis (e.g., 93 ). In some cases, the two opposite structural features are not exactly symmetric because, according to the JJEM, jets in a pair during the explosion process might differ substantially in their energy and momentum (e.g., 91 ). An ear is a protrusion from the main shell, which is smaller than the shell and has a decreasing cross-section with distance. The morphological similarities of hot gas in clusters of galaxies that are known to be shaped by jets with some PNe (e.g., 95 ) and with some CCSNRs (e.g., 101 ), further solidify the claim that jets shape the above-listed morphological features in PNe and CCSNRs. Many of the jet-shaped PNe have close central binary systems (e.g., 63 ; 44 ; 43 ), indicating they are post-common-envelope (CEE) binaries. One of the main conclusions from jet-shaped PNe with post-CEE binary systems is that jets are the most robust observable ingredient of CEE ( 105 ) , besides the close binary systems that define these systems as post-CEE binaries. This implies that jets play a substantial role in CEE, and that the standard CEE should include, in addition to the orbital energy of the binary systems, the energy of the jets launched by the more compact companion as it enters the envelope, possibly also within the envelope, and as it emerges from the common envelope. Studies show that, in many analyzed post-CEE cases, the orbital energy alone was insufficient to eject the common envelope (e.g., 37 ; 54 ). In many cases, the jets can supply more energy than the orbital energy released by the binary system. The jet-shaped CCSNRs imply that one or more pairs of jets supply most of the energy to the ejecta, as predicted and fully compatible with the theoretical jittering-jets explosion mechanism (JJEM; e.g., 5 ; 18 ; 108 ; 110 ; 109 , for papers from 2026; for earlier reviews, see, 104 ; 106 ). On the other hand, the neutrino-driven (delayed neutrino; neutrino heating) explosion mechanism (e.g., 7 ; 19 ; 24 ; 33 ; 57 ; 60 ; 66 ; 72 ; 74 ; 83 ; 114 ; 120 , for several papers from 2026; 42 for an earlier review) cannot account for the morphological properties of point-symmetric CCSNRs. Hydrodynamical simulations of the neutrino-driven mechanism to the CCSNR phase do not address point-symmetric morphologies (e.g., 69 ; 68 ; 70 ; 71 ). The morphologies of CCSNRs are the only property that can robustly decide between these two heavily studied theoretical explosion mechanisms (e.g., 106 ). Therefore, the above-listed (and more) papers on the solid claim that jets shape and power many CCSNRs have established the JJEM as the primary explosion mechanism of these CCSNRs, and most likely of all CCSNe. This claim is still in dispute, as the above-listed papers on the neutrino-driven mechanism present a counter view; the community is far from any consensus on the primary explosion mechanism of CCSNe. To further understand the CCSN explosion mechanism by identifying jet-shaped morphological features in CCSNRs, we identify another morphological feature common to some PNe and some CCSNRs, termed a pipe. It is a structure that exists within the inner PN or CCSNR; hence, it cannot be shaped by an interaction with circumstellar material (CSM) or the interstellar medium (ISM). It results solely from the formation process of the PN or the CCSN. Also, it is symmetric around the center and, therefore, it is highly unlikely that instabilities form such a structure. It is most likely a jet-shaped structure. The approach we adapt in this study is the same that has been successfully used in understanding the shaping of PNe by jets and binary interaction (e.g., 65 ; 98 ; 87 ; 4 ; 25 ; 112 ; 9 ; 28 ; 29 ; 20 ; 81 ; 22 ; 64 ; 1 ; 23 ; 49 ; 62 ; 85 ; 58 ; for a recent review see 48 ), including precessing jets (e.g., 39 ; 61 ; 84 ; 16 ; 111 ; 82 ; 38 ; 20 ). The method starts with an eye inspection and classification of PNe based on morphology (e.g., 10 ; 78 ; 86 ; 49 ). The qualitative classifications and morphological identifications yield a robust identification of jet-shaped morphological features (e.g., 87 ). The jet-like morphological features have driven a wide range of hydrodynamic numerical simulations of PN shaping. The comparisons of simulations with observations (e.g., 2 ; 29 ; 30 ; 27 ; 3 ; 45 and references to earlier studies therein) have established jets as a major player in powering and shaping PN outflows. Simulations of the JJEM in the last year showed that jittering jets can reproduce many observed jet-shaped morphological features in CCSNRs ( 17 ; 18 ; 94 ; 5 ; 6 ) . In this study, we identify a pipe morphological feature that we attribute to a late pair of jets. In Section II , we identify the pipe in CCSNRs, and in Section III , we identify the pipe in PNe. In Section IV we present PNe that exhibit morphologies bridging jet-shaped bipolar lobes and pipes, indicating

Read the complete text