Measurement of the neutron shielding efficacy of magnetite for Proton Therapy Facilities and other applications Preprint: NIM-B

K. Park, C. Keppel, P. Ambrozewicz, K. Wright, M. Kosinski · 2026

Read Measurement of the neutron shielding efficacy of magnetite for Proton Therapy Facilities and other applications Preprint: NIM-B by K. Park, C. Keppel, P. Ambrozewicz, K. Wright, M. Kosinski (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-03931.txt.

Introduction

Kijun Park and four co-authors measure how well magnetite shields neutrons, with proton therapy centers in mind. High-density concrete and magnetite aggregates are common shielding choices around medical accelerators. Their behavior under neutron radiation must be characterized to keep doses safe. The team combined lab measurements with Monte Carlo simulations.

The lab results agreed well with the simulations, confirming the simulation approach. Attenuated neutron doses were computed for various shielding thicknesses. Dose ratios were then compared between the two materials. Magnetite provided superior shielding, with a shorter attenuation length than conventional concrete at the same barrier thickness. Neutron spectra typical of clinical proton therapy accelerators were studied for treatment rooms, primary and secondary barriers, and mazes. The results support better shielding design in medical and research facilities.

Catalog record

CREATORK. Park, C. Keppel, P. Ambrozewicz, K. Wright, M. Kosinski
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03931

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Measurement of the neutron shielding efficacy of magnetite for Proton Therapy Facilities and other applications Preprint: NIM-B K. Park, C. Keppel, P. Ambrozewicz, K. Wright, M. Kosinski Abstract The neutron shielding properties of high-density concrete and magnetite aggregates were evaluated using both experimental measurements and Monte Carlo simulations. Because these materials are commonly used in medical accelerator facilities, it is essential to characterize their behavior under neutron radiation to ensure adequate shielding performance. Our experimental results show good agreement with the Monte Carlo calculations, confirming the reliability of the simulation approach. The attenuated neutron doses for various shielding thicknesses were determined for each aggregate type based on simulation and then compared as dose ratios. The findings indicate that magnetite provides superior neutron shielding, exhibiting a shorter attenuation length than conventional concrete for the same barrier thickness. The neutron attenuation characteristics of both concrete and magnetite were studied for typical neutron spectra encountered in clinical proton-therapy accelerators, including treatment rooms, primary, secondary barriers, and mazes. These results can support the optimization of radiation-shielding designs in medical and research facilities. I Introduction Ion beam therapy, such as proton therapy for cancer treatment, has been increasingly implemented worldwide due to its advantages, including a lower total dose and the presence of the Bragg peak associated with tissue sparing Proton . The typical proton beam energy used for such medical treatment ranges from 70 to 230 MeV and is mostly generated by either a cyclotron or a synchrotron accelerator. The construction of proton therapy facilities is significantly more complex and time-consuming than conventional photon-based therapy due to fundamental differences in physics interaction mechanisms, energy deposition, and radiation shielding requirements. One of the major challenges in proton therapy is shielding against neutrons, which are produced as secondary particles from nuclear interactions with protons. A 250 MeV proton beam produces around 35% of the neutron ambient dose equivalent per proton dose in Gray (Gy) from direct neutrons, which peaks in energies close to 100 MeV. Howell2014 Neutrons are neutral particles with a mass similar to that of protons and a strong penetration capability, making neutron radiation shielding particularly challenging. Neutrons exhibit a high cross-section for scattering and absorption when interacting with low-Z materials, such as hydrogen-containing objects. As a result, high-density concrete (HDC) is commonly used for neutron shielding in proton therapy facilities. However, the conventional construction with HDC takes many feet of concrete to reduce the high energy neutron enough to optimize these interactions. The molding and curing process of concrete requires several days for stabilization and involves complex procedures to ensure uniformity. This entire process significantly impacts the overall construction timeline and imposes restrictions on building design. Furthermore, the rising cost of HDC is another major concern. There is an ongoing question about whether alternative aggregates can replace the HDC to achieve better neutron shielding efficiency with reduced thickness while also being easier to handle. A recent study introduced magnetite and hematite ores as potential candidates for neutron shielding MDPI . Since magnetite is more abundant on Earth than hematite, we expect that ore factories can supply it in sufficient quantities at a reasonable cost. Additionally, a novel construction technique by Rad Technology Medical Systems, LLC offers a modular construction approach RADTech , enabling faster assembly and disassembly. This method utilizes steel structures that can be filled with shielding aggregates in powder form, eliminating the need for curing time and facilitating re-assembly and removal. The motivation for this study was to simulate neutron dose attenuation using GEANT4 GEANT4 and is to validate the simulation to experimental measurement. The measurement of the neutron dose has been carried out with a novel shielding material using the proton beam at the NASA Space Radiation Laboratory (NSRL) at the Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL) NSRL . The results from both simulations and experiments were then analyzed simultaneously through comparison. II Method The neutron dose for various barrier thicknesses of magnetite shielding material was calculated using Monte Carlo simulations (GEANT4) and then the calculations were compared to experimental measurements. We conducted both methods under the same configuration and compared the results with each other. Concrete was also both measured and simulated for further validation of the procedure and compared to existing global data. The detailed methodology is presented in the following sections. II.1 Simulations GEANT4 GEANT4 was chosen to estimate the neutron shielding dose beyond the barrier given attenuation through the shielding barrier. We utilized standard CERN libraries GEANT4 of events and physics models for cross-section calculations in GEANT4 and developed custom shielding materials to assess neutron dose attenuation. Simulations were performed with various shielding barrier configurations, considering factors such as thickness, compound ratio, density, and primary beam energy. In the simulation, we replicated the experimental setup as closely as possible by incorporating the dimensions of the experimental hall and the major equipment surrounding the detector device. The simulation was conducted for all planned measurement configurations. Figure 1 illustrates the simulation setup for the shielding. We defined three coordinate axes: longitudinal (Z), transverse (X), and diagonal (XZ), ensuring accurate application of distances for the inverse square law equation. Shielding blocks were placed directly behind the water tank target with the same beam centering height and attached to its side, minimizing systematic uncertainties in shielding distance determination. The number of shielding blocks directly influenced the interpretation of the results, ensuring consistency in the analysis. Figure 1: (color online) GEANT4 simulation setup with water tank as target, shielding blocks, and detectors. Measurements were carried out with various detector positions of D1, D2 and numbers of shielding block. Since the experimental measurement used a finite-volume shielding block, the neutron dose detected after the shielding block was larger than initial Monte Carlo estimates due to significant background noise. The primary source of this background was a large number of neutrons scattered from the target and surrounding objects including the walls. We defined these scattered neutrons as the main background component, which we aimed to eliminate from the signal detector (D2). To estimate this background, we utilized two identical detectors in both the simulation and the experiment to measure the neutron dose behind the shielding blocks in signal detector (D2) and to simultaneously measure the dose from scattered background neutrons in background detector (D1) outside the shielding block area. To calculate the neutron dose from the measured counts in the detector, we utilized the relationship between dose, neutron energy, and flux at a virtual detector positioned at the survey point, as described in reference MPelliccioni . We simulated neutrons scattered from the water tank and measured them using the WENDI-II detector through a counting method. By knowing the number of neutrons, their energy, and the geometrical conditions of irradiation, we parameterized the energy dependence and calculated the dose using fluence-to-effective dose conversion coefficients based on an anthropomorphic mathematical model. This model is applicable for neutron energies ranging from 0.0025 eV to 10 TeV. The final dose calculation was determined by averaging the doses from different orientations, including Anterior-to-Posterior (AP), Posterior-to-Anterior (PA), Lateral (Lat), and Iso-symmetric (ISO) configurations. To accurately identify direct and indirect background neutron contributions, we specifically constrained the angle between the water tank and detector in the Monte Carlo simulation data by applying

Read the complete text