Time-dependent variational Monte Carlo without bias
Wladislaw Krinitsin, Markus Schmitt · 2026
Read Time-dependent variational Monte Carlo without bias by Wladislaw Krinitsin, Markus Schmitt (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-03930.txt.
Introduction
Wladislaw Krinitsin and Markus Schmitt remove a subtle bias from time-dependent variational Monte Carlo, a workhorse method for simulating quantum many-body systems with flexible trial states such as neural quantum states. The traditional formulation's bias causes inaccuracies. They are especially damaging for real-time dynamics, where errors compound step by step.
Their unbiased variant uses self-normalized importance sampling with respect to a cutoff-based deformation of the Born law. They show its feasibility and accuracy on extreme and generic quench dynamics. They also explore a second sampling strategy, based on tensor cross interpolation and active learning. That route's tensor network lacked the needed low-rank property. But the algorithm complements conventional importance sampling and may guide future work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wladislaw Krinitsin, Markus Schmitt |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03930
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Time-dependent variational Monte Carlo without bias Wladislaw Krinitsin, Markus Schmitt Abstract When combined with highly expressive ansatz functions such as neural quantum states, variational Monte Carlo (VMC) constitutes a versatile numerical approach to tackle the quantum many-body problem in and out of equilibrium. However, its traditional formulation exhibits a subtle estimation bias leading to inaccuracies, which can be particularly detrimental when addressing real time dynamics. In this work, we investigate two avenues to circumvent said estimation bias. First, we propose an unbiased variant of time-dependent VMC using self-normalized importance sampling with respect to a cutoff-based deformation of the Born distribution. We demonstrate the feasibility and accuracy of the approach in pathological and generic cases of quench dynamics. Furthermore, we explore an alternative sampling strategy based on active learning via the tensor cross interpolation (TCI). While we find that our choice of tensor network architecture lacks the required low rank property, the proposed TCI-based algorithm complements the conventional importance sampling paradigm, providing an alternative perspective that may be further explored in future work. I Introduction The simulation of strongly correlated quantum many-body systems remains one of the central challenges in condensed matter physics. The exponential growth of the Hilbert space with system size limits exact approaches to the smallest systems, forcing the development of sophisticated approximation methods. In recent years, the introduction of Neural Quantum States (NQS) – artificial neural networks used as variational wave functions – have emerged as a promising new approach for compressed quantum state representations 3 . Leveraging the universal approximation theorem and the ability to capture complex, non-local correlations 35 , NQS have been shown to achieve state-of-the art accuracy for a wide range of models and physical situations, including strongly correlated spin systems 17 ; 33 ; 1 ; 39 ; 10 ; 6 ; 7 ; 41 , electrons 31 ; 28 ; 13 ; 8 ; 11 ; 40 , or lattice gauge theories 21 ; 19 . Dynamical situations, where established numerical methods face severe challenges due to rapidly growing entanglement or due to the Monte Carlo sign problem, is a particularly relevant field of application for NQS 15 ; 33 ; 30 ; 22 ; 25 ; 10 ; 23 ; 24 ; 19 ; 28 ; 34 ; 7 ; 38 ; 37 . Typically, these neural networks are optimized using the time-dependent variational principle (TDVP), which allows to perform ground state search or dynamics via imaginary- or real-time evolution within the variational manifold, respectively. Despite the remarkable successes of NQS, a fundamental and often overlooked technical bottleneck persists: the evaluation of the TDVP step relies on Monte Carlo techniques, which is commonly referred to as time-dependent variational Monte Carlo (t-VMC) 2 , to estimate all quantities of interest by sampling from the probability distribution defined by the squared amplitude of the wave function—the Born distribution. This approach may, however, exhibit a systematic estimation bias 36 , the result of a mismatch between the supports of the Born distribution and the quantity to be estimated. While this bias will vanish in the thermodynamic limit for typical many-body states 34 , it leads to wrong evaluations of the TDVP update step when encountering pathological states 36 . This is especially detrimental for real-time dynamics where a high level of accuracy needs to be maintained at each step. In this paper, we investigate different approaches to circumvent said estimation bias, considering quench dynamics in the one dimensional transverse field Ising model (TFIM) as an exemplary application. On the one hand, we introduce an alternative, cutoff-based sampling probability through the framework of importance sampling. Similar approaches have been attempted in the past 32 ; 18 ; 26 ; 42 : while they mainly focus on decreasing the statistical noise of the estimator, the recently published Ref. 42 also reduces the estimation bias via post-processing of the samples given a problem specific, sparse kernel. In contrast, our work shows that a suitably chosen probability function allows us to directly adapt the support of the sampling distribution in order to obtain an unbiased estimator, while preserving the favorable computational scaling of Monte Carlo methods. On the other hand, we propose an alternative to the sampling paradigm, using tensor cross interpolation (TCI) 27 as an active learning approach to obtain low-rank approximations of the relevant objects, that can be evaluated efficiently by tensor contraction. Our empirical study, however, indicates that the relevant objects within the t-VMC framework lack the low-rank property required for the TCI approach. We start by sketching the general framework and working equations of the TDVP, followed by an introduction of the proposed alternative approaches in the form of importance sampling and TCI in Section II . The results outlining their efficacy in enabling an unbiased TDVP are presented in Section III . We close this work by providing a summary and discussion of the main findings. II Methods II.1 Time Dependent Variational Principle In the following, we will be interested in solving the time-dependent Schrödinger equation \displaystyle i\frac{d}{dt}\ket{\psi}=\hat{H}\ket{\psi}\,. (1) Approximate solutions within the manifold of states obtained from a variational ansatz \ket{\psi_{\theta}} can be found by employing a TDVP, in order to obtain the corresponding optimal trajectory in parameter space, \theta(t) . In infinitesimal formulations which assume, that optimal solutions for \theta(t) are continuous in time, the quantum geometric tensor (QGT) \displaystyle\hat{\mathcal{S}}_{k,k^{\prime}}=\frac{\braket{\partial_{k}\psi_{\theta}|\partial_{k^{\prime}}\psi_{\theta}}}{\langle\psi_{\theta}|\psi_{\theta}\rangle}-\frac{\braket{\partial_{k}\psi_{\theta}|\psi_{\theta}}}{\langle\psi_{\theta}|\psi_{\theta}\rangle}\frac{\braket{\psi_{\theta}|\partial_{k^{\prime}}\psi_{\theta}}}{\langle\psi_{\theta}|\psi_{\theta}\rangle} (2) and the force vector \displaystyle\hat{\mathcal{F}}_{k}=\frac{\braket{\partial_{k}\psi_{\theta}|\hat{H}|\psi_{\theta}}}{\langle\psi_{\theta}|\psi_{\theta}\rangle}-\frac{\braket{\partial_{k}\psi_{\theta}|\psi_{\theta}}}{\langle\psi_{\theta}|\psi_{\theta}\rangle}\frac{\braket{\psi_{\theta}|\hat{H}|\psi_{\theta}}}{\langle\psi_{\theta}|\psi_{\theta}\rangle}\ . (3) play a central role. Here we define the derivative with respect to the k -th variational parameter \partial_{k}\equiv\partial/\partial\theta_{k} . Assuming a real-valued parameterization, \theta\in\mathbb{R} , one can derive two versions of the time-dependent variational principle, depending on the starting point 14 . Each of them leads to a first-order differential equation prescribing the dynamics of the parameters of the form \displaystyle S_{k,k^{\prime}}\dot{\theta}_{k^{\prime}}=F_{k}\ , (4) where, doubly occurring indices are summed over, and \dot{\theta}\equiv\frac{d}{dt}\theta . In the following we will be choosing the stationary action principle as the starting point, corresponding to setting S_{k,k^{\prime}}=\text{Im}[\hat{\mathcal{S}}_{k,k^{\prime}}] and F_{k}=\text{Im}[-i\hat{\mathcal{F}}_{k}] , which leads to an explicitly energy-conserving solution. When implementing a TDVP with NQS, a central question is how \hat{\mathcal{S}}_{k,k^{\prime}} and \hat{\mathcal{F}}_{k} can be computed efficiently. As an example, the first term of the force vector ( 3 ) takes on the following form: \frac{\braket{\partial_{k}\psi_{\theta}|\hat{H}|\psi_{\theta}}}{\langle\psi_{\theta}|\psi_{\theta}\rangle}=\sum_{\mathbf{s}}\frac{\braket{\partial_{k}\psi_{\theta}|\mathbf{s}}\braket{\mathbf{s}|\hat{H}|\psi_{\theta}}}{\langle\psi_{\theta}|\psi_{\theta}\rangle}\,. (5) Here, \{\ket{\mathbf{s}}\} with \ket{\mathbf{s}}\equiv\ket{s_{1}}\otimes\ldots\otimes\ket{s_{N}} denotes a computational basis of the N -body Hilbert space. While \braket{\mathbf{s}|\hat{H}|\psi_{\theta}}=\sum_{\mathbf{s}^{\prime}}\hat{H}_{\mathbf{s},\mathbf{s}^{\prime}}\,\psi_{\theta}(\mathbf{s}^{\prime}) can be calculated efficiently for sparse Hamiltonians, the sum over all computational basis configurations \mathbf{s} becomes exponentially prohibitive with increasing system size. One way of addressing this problem is to approximate the full sum via a finite number of samples drawn from a suitable probability distribution, leading to the notion of Monte-Carlo sampling. II.2 Self-normalized Importance Sampling Monte-Carlo sampling techniques allow to approximate expectation values of the form \mu(f)\equiv\mathbb{E}_{P}[f]=\sum_{\mathbf{s}}P(\mathbf{s})f(\mathbf{s})\ , (6) by evaluating the sum on N_{S} samples drawn according to a given, normalized probability distribution \mathbf{s}\propto P(\mathbf{s}) , resulting in the estimator \hat{\mu}_{P}(f)\equiv\ \frac{1}{N_{S}}\sum_{\mathbf{s}\propto P}f(\mathbf{s}). (7) Generally, Eq. ( 6 ) can be rewritten as an expectation value with respect to an arbitrary probability distribution Q(\mathbf{s})=q(\mathbf{s})/\mathcal{N}_{q} \displaystyle\mu(f) \displaystyle=\mathbb{E}_{P}[f]=\sum_{\mathbf{s}}P(\mathbf{s})f(\mathbf{s})=\sum_{\mathbf{s}}Q(\mathbf{s})\frac{P(\mathbf{s})}{Q(\mathbf{s})}f(\mathbf{s}) \displaystyle=\frac{\mathcal{N}_{q}}{\mathcal{N}_{p}}\sum_{\mathbf{s}}Q(\mathbf{s})\frac{p(\mathbf{s})}{q(\mathbf{s})}f(\mathbf{s})=\frac{\mathcal{N}_{q}}{\mathcal{N}_{p}}\mathbb{E}_{Q}\big[p/q\cdot f\big], (8) with the weights q(\mathbf{s}) and the corresponding normalization constant \mathcal{N}_{q}=\sum_{\mathbf{s}}q(\mathbf{s}) . Analogously, P(\mathbf{s})=p(\mathbf{s})/\mathcal{N}_{p} . One distinguishes between two different cases; on the one