Nonuniform superconducting states from Majorana flat bands

Sushanth Varada, Aksel Kobiałka, Ankita Bhattacharya, Patric Holmvall, Annica M. Black-Schaffer · 2026

Read Nonuniform superconducting states from Majorana flat bands by Sushanth Varada, Aksel Kobiałka, Ankita Bhattacharya, Patric Holmvall, Annica M. Black-Schaffer (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-03859.txt.

Introduction

Sushanth Varada and four co-authors investigate nonuniform superconducting states that arise from Majorana flat bands, zero-energy bands of edge states inside a superconductor's energy gap. Flat bands can give rise to competing ordered phases. The team's platform is a topological superconductor built from magnetic adatoms hosting a flat band of Majorana edge states, studied with self-consistent calculations of the order parameter.

Two phases emerge: a pair density wave with edge-localized amplitude modulations, and a phase crystal with edge-localized phase modulations. Both lower the free energy by gapping out the Majorana flat band, and the uniform solution never survives at zero temperature. The pair density wave persists to about eighty percent of the bulk transition temperature, while the phase crystal appears only at lower temperatures.

Catalog record

CREATORSushanth Varada, Aksel Kobiałka, Ankita Bhattacharya, Patric Holmvall, Annica M. Black-Schaffer
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03859

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Nonuniform superconducting states from Majorana flat bands Sushanth Varada, Aksel Kobiałka, Ankita Bhattacharya, Patric Holmvall, Annica M. Black-Schaffer Abstract Zero-energy flat bands within the superconducting gap can give rise to competing ordered phases. We investigate such phases in topological superconductors based on the magnetic adatom platform hosting a flat band of Majorana edge states. Our self-consistent calculations of the superconducting order parameter show the emergence of both a pair density wave with edge-localized amplitude modulations and a phase crystal characterized by edge-localized phase modulations. These two phases lower the free energy of the system by gapping out the Majorana flat band, as dictated by winding numbers, which are primarily tuned by the chemical potential. In fact, at zero temperature the uniform superconducting solution with Majorana flat band never survives and the phase diagram features a pair density wave, while the order parameter transitions into a phase crystal when amplitude modulations are insufficient to hybridize all the Majorana states. A broad intermediate region connects these two phases with comparable modulations in both amplitude and phase. At finite temperatures, the pair density wave survives up to around 80% of the bulk superconducting transition temperature, while the phase crystal only appears at lower temperatures and the intermediate region is strongly suppressed. Our findings establish the ubiquity of emergent nonuniform superconducting phases and their temperature-dependent behavior in topological superconductors. I Introduction Nonuniform superconducting ground states provide a fascinating platform to study the interplay between spontaneous symmetry breaking and ordered states 1 ; 20 ; 34 ; 23 ; 7 ; 8 ; 5 . In particular, flat bands of zero-energy states within a superconductor can easily become thermodynamically unstable to interactions due to their extensive ground-state degeneracy, facilitating a competition between different symmetry-breaking instabilities 74 . This has been extensively studied at the (110) surface of d -wave superconductors, especially in the context of cuprate high-temperature superconductors 70 ; 40 ; 18 ; 27 ; 37 ; 9 ; 50 ; 21 ; 46 ; 25 ; 74 ; 26 ; 24 ; 39 ; 79 ; 69 . Notably, different superconducting states can occur 40 ; 27 ; 21 ; 46 ; 25 ; 39 , often highly nonuniform in space, that lower the free energy by shifting the zero-energy flat bands to finite energies. Among the competing orders for this surface, the superconducting phase crystal 21 ; 24 , a nonuniform superconducting ground state characterized by periodic spontaneous phase gradients, has gained attention because it remains robust in the presence of strong correlations, disorder, finite-temperature effects 11 ; 10 ; 68 and provides good agreement with experiments 11 ; 15 ; 2 ; 77 ; 17 ; 47 . In this work, we investigate prospects for the emergence of nonuniform superconducting ground states, including the phase crystal, in a topological superconductor hosting flat bands of topologically protected Majorana states. This addresses the interplay between, on one hand, forming non-uniform superconducting states to lower the energy, and, on the other hand, the topological protection of the Majorana states. In particular, we are interested in understanding how the topological protection affects, or possibly hinders, the emergence of nonuniform superconducting phases. Similar avenues have previously been explored in the context of stability of Majorana states in stacked nanowires 36 ; 75 and small-scale cold-atom systems 42 ; 76 ; 52 ; 28 . So-called edge-induced pairing fluctuations in amplitude 52 and phase 42 ; 76 of the superconducting order parameter have been shown to break symmetries and hybridize Majorana states. Here, we aim to identify and characterize the landscape of possible nonuniform phases through energy-based arguments and their connection to topology. Specifically, we determine which ground states are stabilized and how the underlying topological phase influences their competition. Importantly, we also expand the study of the stability of different phases to finite temperatures, with results differing from previous studies on the stability of Majorana flat bands. To this end, we consider a Majorana flat band model based on atomic spin chains with a helical magnetic texture deposited on an s -wave superconducting substrate 14 ; 38 ; 49 ; 32 ; 61 ; 44 ; 51 ; 66 , see Fig. 1 . Arrays of such magnetic adatoms have been shown to lead to multiple spin polarized sub-gap states that hybridize to form bands 4 . These bands can enter a topologically non-trivial superconducting phase 54 ; 35 ; 63 ; 12 supporting flat bands of Majorana edge states protected by chiral symmetry 66 ; 67 . Developments in single-atom manipulation techniques based on scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) have enabled the fabrication, detection, and control of these superconducting sub-gap states 22 ; 29 ; 56 ; 30 ; 80 ; 64 ; 41 . This offers a promising experimental route to realize topological superconductivity in atomic spin chains on a superconductor 53 ; 45 ; 62 ; 16 ; 71 . To identify the possible ground states in such systems, we start from a tight-binding model for coplanar spin spirals on a 2D s -wave superconductor 66 and perform self-consistent calculations of the effective superconducting order parameter to find the ground state. We find that Majorana edge states, present for a uniform superconducting state, is unstable towards the formation of both a pair density wave 8 and a phase crystal 24 along the edges of the system. The pair density wave exhibits edge localized superconducting amplitude modulations without any spatial variation in phase. The pair density wave predominantly displays short-range modulations on the atomic scale, thus even approaching a bond wave order 76 . In contrast, the phase crystal is characterized by strong superconducting phase modulations at the edges on the superconducting coherence length scale, which drive spontaneous current loops and weak modulations in amplitude. Both of these nonuniform superconducting states split and shift the Majorana flat band away from zero energy, and thereby lower the overall free energy of the system. The competition between the pair density wave and the phase crystals is governed by the proportion of non-trivial winding numbers with different signs, which is tunable by the chemical potential. This results in an experimentally accessible tunability between the pair density wave and the phase crystal. We find that the pair density wave and phase crystal are roughly as abundant as ground states in the phase diagram, where the order parameter only develops phase modulations when amplitude modulations are not sufficient to shift the Majorana states away from zero energy. In the zero-temperature limit, these two phases are connected by a large intermediate region, where the superconducting order parameter exhibits comparable modulations in amplitude and phase. However, this intermediate region diminishes at finite temperatures. The pair density wave also typically exhibits a higher transition temperature, reaching up to around 80% of the superconducting transition temperature T_{c} , while the phase crystal survives up to around 10% of T_{c} . We trace this behavior to the phase crystal only emerging in a parameter regime where both the number of Majorana states and the magnitude of the bulk superconducting gap are relatively small, making it more sensitive to thermal excitations. Above the transition temperatures of these nonuniform superconducting states, the uniform superconducting state with its

Read the complete text