Turbophoresis of inertial particles in inhomogeneous turbulence produced by oscillating grids
E. Elmakies, O. Shildkrot, N. Kleeorin, A. Levy, I. Rogachevskii · 2026
Read Turbophoresis of inertial particles in inhomogeneous turbulence produced by oscillating grids by E. Elmakies, O. Shildkrot, N. Kleeorin, A. Levy, I. Rogachevskii (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-03646.txt.
Introduction
E. Elmakies and four co-authors study turbophoresis in the lab, the drift of inertial particles toward regions of weaker turbulence. The effect builds large-scale uneven particle patterns in uneven turbulent flows and depends on the Stokes and Reynolds numbers and on the turbulence gradient. Their test bed is air flow driven by oscillating grids.
Using one-grid and two-grid setups, they measure the flow with particle image methods and extract particle patterns from the images. To separate turbophoresis from ordinary mean-flow transport, they scale the inertial particle counts by tracer particle counts under the same conditions. The measurements show inertial particles accumulating where mean-square turbulent velocity is lowest, matching the turbophoretic behavior they expected.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | E. Elmakies, O. Shildkrot, N. Kleeorin, A. Levy, I. Rogachevskii |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03646
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Turbophoresis of inertial particles in inhomogeneous turbulence produced by oscillating grids E. Elmakies, O. Shildkrot, N. Kleeorin, A. Levy, I. Rogachevskii Abstract Turbophoresis in inhomogeneous turbulent flows leads to the formation of large-scale nonuniform particle number density distributions of inertial particles. This effect is associated with an effective drift velocity directed toward regions of lower turbulence intensity and proportional to the particle Stokes time and the spatial gradient of the turbulence intensity. In the present study, turbophoretic transport is experimentally investigated in air flows generated by one-grid and two-grid oscillating turbulence systems. The flow velocity field and particle spatial distribution are measured using Particle Image Velocimetry. To isolate the effect of particle accumulation due to turbophoresis from that associated with mean fluid flow, the measured particle number density of inertial particles is normalized by the corresponding distribution obtained for noninertial tracer particles under identical flow conditions. The measurements show preferential accumulation of inertial particles in regions of lower turbulence intensity, consistent with the expected behavior of turbophoretic transport. I Introduction Transport of particles in turbulent flows has been studied extensively through theoretical analysis, laboratory and field experiments, and numerical simulations; see, e.g., Refs. MY71 ; MY75 ; CSA80 ; MC90 ; ZRS90 ; F95 ; BLA97 ; P2000 ; SP06 ; LE08 ; ZA08 ; CST11 ; DA13 ; RI21 . Nevertheless, several important aspects of particle transport in turbulence remain unresolved, especially in geophysical and astrophysical flows, where the governing parameters are difficult to reproduce experimentally or numerically. A central problem in turbulent transport of inertial particles is the formation of large-scale inhomogeneous particle number density distributions at scales exceeding the integral turbulence scale. Two turbulence-related mechanisms can lead to such particle accumulation. The first mechanism is turbulent thermal diffusion in temperature-stratified turbulence, which causes inertial and noninertial particles to accumulate near regions of minimum mean fluid temperature EKR96 ; EKR97 . The second mechanism is turbophoresis, where inertial particles migrate toward regions of lower turbulence intensity in spatially inhomogeneous turbulent flows ( CTT75 ; RE83 ) . Turbophoresis is due to the joint effect of particle inertia and spatial inhomogeneity of turbulence and is commonly described in terms of an effective turbophoretic velocity of inertial particles ( CTT75 ; RE83 ) \displaystyle\overline{\bm{V}}_{\rm turboph}=-\kappa_{\rm turboph}\,\mbox{\boldmath$\nabla$}\left\langle{\bm{u}}^{2}\right\rangle, (1) where \kappa_{\rm turboph} is the turbophoretic coefficient, which depends on the Stokes number and the fluid Reynolds number. Turbophoresis has been studied extensively using analytical and numerical approaches in different types of turbulent flows ( CTT75 ; RE83 ; G97 ; EKR98 ; MS02 ; G08 ; SSB12 ; BFF14 ; LCB16 ; MHR18 ; JBM20 ; BV24 ; WZZ24 ) . Direct numerical simulations (DNS) demonstrated that inertial particles in inhomogeneously forced isothermal turbulence accumulate preferentially in regions of minimum mean-square turbulent velocity ( MHR18 ) . In these flows, the spatial distribution of inertial particles is governed by the competition between turbophoretic transport and turbulent diffusion. The DNS results also show that the product \kappa_{\rm turboph} and u_{\rm rms} increases linearly with {\rm St}_{\rm f} for {\rm St}_{\rm f}\ll 1 , reaches a maximum near {\rm St}_{\rm f}\sim 10 , and decreases as {\rm St}_{\rm f}^{-1/3} for large {\rm St}_{\rm f} . Here, u_{\rm rms}\equiv\sqrt{\langle{\bm{u}}^{2}\rangle} and {\rm St}_{\rm f}=\tau_{\rm p}/\tau_{0} is the Stokes number defined as a ratio of the Stokes time \tau_{\rm p} and the characteristic turbulent time scale \tau_{0} associated with the integral turbulence scale. Numerical studies of turbophoresis in inhomogeneous turbulent Kolmogorov flows also demonstrate that the large-scale clustering of inertial particles increases at small {\rm St}_{\rm f} and gradually weakens at larger {\rm St}_{\rm f} . Although these studies did not explicitly interpret the results in terms of a balance between turbophoretic and turbulent diffusive fluxes, the observed particle accumulation reflects the combined action of turbophoretic and turbulent diffusive transport ( LCB16 ) . Turbulent thermal diffusion produces an additional nondiffusive turbulent flux of particles {\bm{J}}_{\rm TTD}=\overline{n}\,\overline{\bm{V}}_{\rm TTD} RI21 ; EKR96 ; EKR97 , where \displaystyle\overline{\bm{V}}_{\rm TTD}=-\alpha\,D_{\rm T}\,{\bm{\nabla}}\ln\overline{T}, (2) and \overline{\bm{V}}_{\rm TTD} is the effective drift velocity. Here \overline{n} is the mean particle number density, \overline{T} is the mean fluid temperature, D_{\rm T} is the turbulent diffusion coefficient, and the parameter \alpha depends on the Stokes and Reynolds numbers for inertial particles, while \alpha=1 for noninertial particles. Turbulent thermal diffusion has been investigated theoretically RI21 ; EKR96 ; EKR97 ; EKR00 ; EKRS00 ; EKRS01 ; PM02 ; RE05 ; AEKR17 , numerically HKRB12 ; RKB18 , in laboratory experiments BEE04 ; EEKR04 ; EEKR06a ; EEKR06b ; EKRL22 ; SKRL22 ; EKRL23 ; ZEKRL25 ; EKRL26 as well as in geophysical, planetary science and astrophysical applications EKPR97 ; SSEKR09 ; H16 ; KR25 . It is important to distinguish between turbulent thermal diffusion and turbophoresis, since these mechanisms originate from different physical processes. Turbulent thermal diffusion occurs in temperature-stratified turbulence and is associated with turbulent particle fluxes coupled to turbulent heat fluxes. In contrast, turbophoresis originates from averaging of particle velocity, and it is due to particle inertia in spatially inhomogeneous turbulence, leading to preferential accumulation of particles in regions of lower turbulence intensity. Despite substantial progress in theoretical and numerical studies, direct experimental investigations of turbophoresis remain relatively limited, particularly in nearly unbounded turbulent flows generated away from solid boundaries. Most previous experimental studies of particle accumulation were conducted in wall-bounded turbulent flows, where turbulence inhomogeneity is strongly affected by walls and mean shear SE91 ; KHB95 ; RR04 . The experimental identification of turbophoretic transport is therefore challenging, especially in flows where multiple particle transport mechanisms may coexist. In the present study, we experimentally investigate the formation of large-scale concentrations of inertial particles in strongly inhomogeneous isothermal turbulence generated by one and two oscillating grids in air flows. Oscillating-grid turbulence provides a controlled laboratory configuration with relatively weak mean flow and spatially varying turbulence intensity, allowing direct investigation of particle accumulation induced by turbophoresis. Simultaneous measurements of turbulent velocity fields and particle number density distributions allow direct comparison between the spatial distribution of inertial particles and the turbulence intensity. To isolate the turbophoretic contribution, the measured particle number density fields for inertial particles are normalized using corresponding measurements obtained with noninertial particles under identical flow conditions. This paper is organized as follows. Section II discusses the physical mechanisms associated with turbophoresis. Section III describes the experimental setup and measurement techniques. Section IV presents and analyzes the experimental results. Section V outlines the conclusions. II Physics of turbophoresis In this section, we briefly discuss the physical mechanisms underlying turbophoresis and estimate the effective turbophoretic velocity \overline{\bm{V}}_{\rm turboph} of inertial particles (see, e.g., Refs. EKR98 ; RI21 ). The equation of motion for inertial particles with the material density \rho_{p} that is much larger than the fluid density \rho , is given by \displaystyle{{\rm d}{\bm{U}}^{\rm(p)}\over{\rm d}t}=-{{\bm{U}}^{\rm(p)}-{\bm{U}}\over\tau_{p}}+{\bm{g}}, (3) where {\bm{U}}^{\rm(p)} is the particle velocity, {\bm{U}} is the fluid velocity, {\bm{g}} is the acceleration caused by the gravity field, and \tau_{\rm p}=m_{\rm p}/(3\pi\rho\,\nu\,d_{\rm p}) is the Stokes time of spherical solid particles having the diameter d_{\rm p} and mass m_{\rm p}=\left(\pi/6\right)\,\rho_{p}\,d_{\rm p}^{3} . Here \nu is the kinematic viscosity of the fluid. The Stokes number {\rm St} based on the Kolmogorov time \tau_{\nu}=\ell_{\nu}/u_{\nu}=\tau_{0}/{\rm Re}^{1/2}=\ell_{\nu}^{2}/\nu is given by \displaystyle{\rm