Comparing Hemispheres: Anisotropy in the deceleration parameter q 0 q_{0}

Josue De-Santiago · 2026

Read Comparing Hemispheres: Anisotropy in the deceleration parameter q 0 q_{0} by Josue De-Santiago (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-03004.txt.

Introduction

Mauricio Lopez-Hernandez and Josue De-Santiago test whether the universe's slowing of expansion looks the same in every direction, using exploding stars as distance markers. The deceleration parameter sums up whether cosmic expansion is speeding up or slowing down. If the cosmos is isotropic, that value should not depend on which hemisphere of the sky supplies the supernovae.

Using a large modern supernova sample, the authors compare hemispheres under three redshift corrections. A directional variation persists in all frames, strongest where corrections for our own motion are incomplete, and weaker but present in the most corrected frame, aligned with the known cosmic microwave dipole. Inferring the dipole from the supernovae themselves gives a motion estimate mildly at odds with the microwave value. Adopting that estimate in the corrections removes the pattern.

Catalog record

CREATORJosue De-Santiago
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03004

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comparing Hemispheres: Anisotropy in the deceleration parameter q 0 q_{0} Josue De-Santiago Abstract We present a hemispherical comparison analysis of the deceleration parameter q 0 q_{0} using the Pantheon+ sample of Type Ia supernovae to test the isotropy of cosmic acceleration and the robustness of redshift corrections. We detect significant directional variations in q 0 q_{0} across all redshift frames. Even in the z HD z_{\mathrm{HD}} frame, where corrections for the CMB dipole and peculiar velocities are applied, a residual dipolar anisotropy persists with Δ ​ q 0 = 0.112 \Delta q_{0}=0.112 and a maximum signal to noise S / N = 2.155 S/N=2.155 , aligned with the CMB dipole direction and decreasing with increasing minimum redshift cut. As expected, the anisotropy is stronger in the z hel z_{\mathrm{hel}} and z CMB z_{\mathrm{CMB}} frames, where these kinematic corrections are incomplete, while the transition to z HD z_{\mathrm{HD}} substantially reduces the signal but does not fully remove it. We further show that inferring the dipole directly from the supernovae data yields v ⊙ = 307.26 − 22.28 + 32.00 , km ​ s − 1 v_{\odot}=307.26^{+32.00}_{-22.28},\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}} toward ( RA , DEC ) = ( 156.40 − 4.71 + 4.72 , , − 3.38 − 8.23 + 5.54 ) ∘ (\mathrm{RA},\mathrm{DEC})=(156.40^{+4.72}_{-4.71},,-3.38^{+5.54}_{-8.23})^{\circ} , mildly discrepant with the Planck CMB dipole at the ∼ 1.9 ​ σ \sim 1.9\sigma level and providing a better fit to the data. When this SNe inferred dipole is consistently incorporated into the redshift correction pipeline, the previously observed hemispherical anisotropy is largely suppressed, with the dipolar pattern disappearing and the maximum signal to noise reduced to S / N ≲ 1.75 S/N\lesssim 1.75 , while the remaining fluctuations become patchy and consistent with statistical noise, suggesting that part of the original signal arises from residual mismatches in the modeling of the local velocity field rather than from a genuine large scale cosmological anisotropy. Since current redshift corrections rely on peculiar velocity reconstructions based on the density field and improved methodologies implemented in Pantheon+, our results suggest the presence of a coherent residual bulk flow not fully captured by these models. The alignment of the preferred directions with previously reported cosmic dipoles supports a kinematic interpretation, and highlights a previously neglected source of systematic uncertainty in low redshift supernova cosmology, with direct implications for the inference of cosmic anisotropies. 1 Introduction The cosmological principle (CP), the assumption that the Universe is statistically homogeneous and isotropic on sufficiently large scales, has long served as a cornerstone of modern cosmology. When combined with General Relativity, it leads uniquely to the accepted concordance \Lambda CDM model through the Friedmann–Lemaître–Robertson–Walker (FLRW) metric. Within this framework, the large scale expansion of the Universe is fully characterized by time dependent, but direction and position independent, background quantities such as the Hubble parameter H(z) and the deceleration parameter q(z) . Any statistically significant directional dependence in these observables would therefore signal either a breakdown of the cosmological principle or the presence of unaccounted for physical or observational effects. The present day deceleration parameter q_{0} plays a central role in this context, as it directly characterizes the accelerated or decelerated nature of the cosmic expansion. Since the discovery of cosmic acceleration from Type Ia supernovae (SNe) observations [ 53 , 47 ] , q_{0} has become a key cosmological parameter closely linked to the energy content of the Universe. Within the FLRW framework, q_{0} is a global scalar quantity and is therefore expected to be isotropic when inferred from sufficiently large and well sampled data sets. In recent years, however, the CP has been increasingly confronted by the growing volume and precision of cosmological observations, some of which appear to challenge its assumptions. Evidence for this has emerged from measurements in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) [ 21 , 77 , 58 , 16 , 48 , 2 , 23 , 19 , 50 , 44 ] , SNe Ia [ 41 , 32 , 38 , 45 , 76 , 18 , 57 , 15 , 52 , 17 , 78 , 28 , 29 , 40 , 59 , 33 , 12 ] , the cosmic dipole anomaly [ 25 , 67 , 65 , 63 , 6 , 64 , 56 , 60 , 66 , 61 , 14 , 62 , 68 , 22 ] , structures that exceed \Lambda CDM expectations [ 37 , 5 , 26 , 74 , 13 , 51 , 24 , 27 ] and anomalous bulk flows [ 31 , 35 , 30 , 75 ] (for recent reviews on the validity of the cosmological principle see [ 34 , 46 ] ). While such observations do not necessarily imply a fundamental violation of large scale isotropy, they highlight the need for careful interpretation. Directional signatures may arise from a combination of local structure, peculiar velocities, survey systematics, uneven sky coverage, or the choice of observational frame. In this broader context, tilted cosmological models [ 70 , 71 , 69 , 72 ] provide a useful and physically motivated framework to explore how apparent anisotropies can emerge even when the underlying spacetime geometry remains close to FLRW. In tilted scenarios, the observer’s rest frame does not coincide with the cosmic rest frame, leading to relative bulk motions between different families of observers. Such relative motion effects alone can induce different locally inferred values of cosmological parameters in the two frames. In particular, observers embedded in large scale bulk flows may infer effective modifications to the local expansion history, including apparent acceleration even if the background Universe is globally decelerating. Although this effect is kinematic rather than due to a genuine dynamical acceleration, the relevant scales typically of order several hundred Mpc are sufficiently large to mimic a genuine cosmological signal. A key prediction of this framework is that relative motions introduce Doppler anisotropies in locally inferred observables. Consequently, tilted observers are expected not only to measure directional variations in the Hubble expansion, but also to see an apparent dipole in the sky distribution of the deceleration parameter q_{0} and the Hubble constant H_{0} , with an axis generically aligned with that of the CMB dipole if both effects share a common kinematic origin [ 73 , 4 ] . Indeed, such dipole like anisotropies have been reported in [ 40 , 33 , 57 , 15 , 39 , 42 , 7 , 9 , 79 ] . Among the works cited above, several have explicitly targeted anisotropies in q_{0} using complementary strategies and SNe compilations. Using the JLA sample, Ref. [ 15 ] modeled q_{0} as a monopole plus a redshift dependent dipole modulation, and found that the inferred dipole component dominates over any isotropic acceleration out to z\sim 0.1 and at 3.9\sigma of statistical significance, with the preferred dipole direction lying within the CMB dipole. Ref. [ 79 ] instead constructed anisotropic q_{0} maps from Union2 by splitting the sky into 12 Galactic regions and fitting q_{0} in each subset; they reported a nonzero dipole amplitude A_{1}=0.466^{+0.255}_{-0.205} at \gtrsim 2\sigma but with a dipole direction that is nearly perpendicular to the CMB kinematic dipole, highlighting that inferred q_{0} dipoles can depend sensitively on sky sampling

Read the complete text