Validity and Limits of Low Order Hybridization Expansion Approaches for Multi-Orbital Systems
Dolev Goldberger, Ido Zemach, Lei Zhang, Yang Yu, Emanuel Gull, Guy Cohen, André Erpenbeck · 2026
Read Validity and Limits of Low Order Hybridization Expansion Approaches for Multi-Orbital Systems by Dolev Goldberger, Ido Zemach, Lei Zhang, Yang Yu, Emanuel Gull, Guy Cohen, André Erpenbeck (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-02228.txt.
Introduction
Dolev Goldberger and colleagues test the validity of low-order hybridisation expansion methods for strongly correlated multi-orbital systems. Two solvers, the non-crossing and one-crossing approximations, are widely used for impurity problems, but their accuracy with several orbitals was poorly understood. The authors use a decoupled orbital limit as a controlled reference point.
They derive analytic links between multi-orbital propagators and Green's functions and their single-orbital counterparts. The diagrams behind the breakdown of low-order methods become visible in that limit. Their central finding is that accuracy is governed by the least correlated orbital, the one whose retarded Green's function decays fastest. Its traits spread to other orbitals through a spurious coupling from truncation, suppressing correlation effects.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dolev Goldberger, Ido Zemach, Lei Zhang, Yang Yu, Emanuel Gull, Guy Cohen, André Erpenbeck |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 90 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.02228
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Validity and Limits of Low Order Hybridization Expansion Approaches for Multi-Orbital Systems Dolev Goldberger, Ido Zemach, Lei Zhang, Yang Yu, Emanuel Gull, Guy Cohen, André Erpenbeck Abstract Low-order hybridization expansion methods such as the non-crossing approximation (NCA) and the one-crossing approximation (OCA) are widely used impurity solvers in the study of strongly correlated systems, yet their accuracy in genuine multi-orbital settings remains poorly understood. Using the decoupled orbital limit as a controlled reference point, we derive analytic results connecting multi-orbital restricted propagators and Green’s functions to their single-orbital counterparts, identify the diagrammatic mechanisms responsible for the breakdown of low-order methods in multi-orbital settings, and determine their regimes of applicability. Our central finding is that the accuracy of these methods is governed by the least correlated orbital: i.e., the orbital with the most rapidly decaying retarded Green’s function. That orbital’s properties are transferred to all other orbitals through a spurious coupling generated by the truncated expansion, thereby suppressing correlation-induced features such as the Kondo resonance. This occurs even in orbitals that are themselves strongly correlated within single-orbital calculations using the same approximation scheme. We confirm this numerically across representative two-orbital model systems in the steady-state, systematically identifying the parameter regimes in which low-order methods succeed or fail. Our results provide a practical guide for assessing when insights from single-orbital calculations carry over to multi-orbital settings, and serve as a benchmark for the development and validation of higher-order multi-orbital impurity solvers. I Introduction Quantum impurity models are systems where a small, interacting region is coupled to one or more infinite noninteracting baths. Their dynamics plays a central role in a variety of fields. For example, models of this type are used to describe transport through mesoscopic quantum dots 33 ; 60 and molecular electronics; 93 ; 116 ; 110 solvation dynamics; 92 ; 8 and, by means of the dynamical mean field theory (DMFT), 50 the electronic structure of strongly correlated materials. As these applications evolve, the need for reliable simulations of increasingly general models grows with them. An important class of diagrammatic methods relevant to quantum impurity models is often referred to as “non-crossing approximations” (NCA) because they sum certain subsets of Feynman diagrams where lines do not cross. Historically, these stem from early formulations of strong-coupling perturbation theory, 69 ; 70 and pioneering works expressed approximations of this type in terms of slave–bosons and later effective pseudoparticles representing many-body states and projected into a physical subspace. 10 ; 31 ; 83 ; 55 ; 56 ; 87 These ideas rapidly evolved into self-consistent large- N theories. 14 ; 15 Finite- U generalizations and conserving extensions broadened the formalism beyond the original setting, which addressed infinitely strong on-site interactions, and clarified the role of crossing diagrams and vertex renormalization. 99 ; 71 As applications within DMFT emerged, 100 it became increasingly important to understand the limitations of the methods and improve accuracy by including higher-order self-energies and vertex corrections. 61 ; 75 ; 57 For example, several works closely examined the validity of the Fermi liquid picture at low temperatures, mostly in the single-orbital case 83 ; 90 ; 80 ; 76 ; 81 while later work focused on high-frequency coefficients of the self-energy and thermodynamic expectation values in two-orbital models. 106 Neither the inclusion of an additional expansion order (often called the one-crossing approximation, OCA) nor the incorporation of vertex corrections provides a fully satisfactory and systematic picture by itself. 61 ; 57 ; 109 Including higher orders — i.e. going to third 37 or, stochastically, fifth 62 order of some variation of the self-consistent expansion — improves the behavior at progressively lower temperatures, though at rapidly growing expense. Recent work has used decomposition techniques like the discrete Lehmann representation (DLR), 67 tensor train integration 94 ; 95 or sum-of-exponential (SOE) representations to significantly accelerate such summations, 68 ; 125 obtaining accurate fifth- and sixth-order results at massively reduced costs. 125 ; 66 In addition to renormalized expansions at low perturbation orders, the underlying hybridization expansions have been employed in very fruitful ways in their bare form within equilibrium applications where the imaginary time Matsubara formalism can be used. This allows summing the bare imaginary time expansion to extremely high orders within continuous-time quantum Monte Carlo methods 121 ; 58 and more recently tensor train techniques. 43 Where this approach is not limited by sign problems, it can provide quantitative accuracy. On the other hand, diagrammatic Monte Carlo methods are generally substantially more difficult to use in real time, due to dynamical sign problems. 89 ; 122 ; 107 ; 108 ; 113 ; 29 ; 114 ; 27 ; 118 Here, several modern pathways forward have emerged from hybridization expansions. For example, Inchworm expansions use short-time bare simulations to obtain numerically exact propagators, then extend them to later time by constructing renormalized perturbation expansions that leverage shorter-time propagators to obtain a mitigated sign problem. 28 ; 3 ; 35 ; 79 ; 77 ; 7 ; 78 ; 42 ; 45 ; 6 ; 40 ; 82 This can also be effective in imaginary-time expansions where sign problems result from multiorbital structure. 39 ; 52 ; 112 Within Inchworm methods, fast summation techniques can allow access to very high expansion orders, 104 ; 16 ; 124 and vertex corrections can be incorporated. 73 ; 72 Another set of promising pathways is once again based on the decomposition of high-dimensional integrals appearing within diagrammatic expansions into tractable objects that can be efficiently evaluated without the need for Monte Carlo integration. Examples include tensor train techniques 49 ; 74 and SOEs. 96 It is interesting at this point to make a connection with a broader literature surrounding quantum impurity models. Here, Jianshu Cao, to whom this special issue is dedicated, has made many major contributions. Particularly in the context of the spin–boson model, 85 Cao’s group has worked on understanding and extending the regime of validity of low-order perturbative approaches. Their work clarified the structure and limitations of second-order quantum master equations — which can be viewed as a renormalized hybridization expansion in Liouville space — emphasizing how the choice of representation and system–bath partitioning can qualitatively affect their accuracy. 20 ; 21 Building on this perspective, subsequent studies developed and benchmarked reorganized perturbative schemes, most notably polaron and variational polaron transformations, which interpolate between weak- and strong-coupling limits by partially resumming system–bath interactions before truncation. 84 ; 65 These approaches demonstrated that the apparent breakdown of low-order perturbation theory is often not simply a matter of missing higher-order diagrams, but of working in an inappropriate expansion frame, and that suitable transformations can substantially extend the quantitative reliability of second-order treatments; and have been useful in the NCA context for impurity models mixing fermionic and bosonic degrees of freedom. 22 Cao’s group also contributed to higher-order studies of the spin–boson model by extension of the Born–Markov expansion to higher orders. 64 We note that NCA-style methods and their high-order extensions were applied much later by others to many of the topics explored by the Cao group, including relaxation dynamics in the spin–boson model, 24 ; 25 ; 124 ; 18 ; 17 ; 19 ; 119 ; 120 ; 53 ;