RenCon 2025: Revival of the Expressive Performance Rendering Competition

Huan Zhang, Taegyun Kwon, Anders Friberg, Junyan Jiang, Hayeon Bang, Hyeyoon Cho, Gus Xia, Akira Maezawa, Simon Dixon, Dasaem Jeong · 2026

Read RenCon 2025: Revival of the Expressive Performance Rendering Competition by Huan Zhang, Taegyun Kwon, Anders Friberg, Junyan Jiang, Hayeon Bang, Hyeyoon Cho, Gus Xia, Akira Maezawa, Simon Dixon, Dasaem Jeong (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-02059.txt.

Introduction

Huan Zhang and colleagues document RenCon 2025, the revival of a competition for expressive performance rendering at the ISMIR conference in Daejeon, Korea. Rendering systems turn a score into a piano performance with human-like timing and dynamics. Nine entries from groups around the world took part, using varied approaches to musical expression.

Assessment ran in two phases: an online round first, then live real-time rendering at the conference. The authors analyse the format, who took part, how systems performed, and lessons for future editions. Results show clear advances in expressive rendering since earlier contests. At the same time, reaching human-level musical expression remains an open challenge for the field.

Catalog record

CREATORHuan Zhang, Taegyun Kwon, Anders Friberg, Junyan Jiang, Hayeon Bang, Hyeyoon Cho, Gus Xia, Akira Maezawa, Simon Dixon, Dasaem Jeong
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.02059

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

RenCon 2025: Revival of the Expressive Performance Rendering Competition Huan Zhang, Taegyun Kwon, Anders Friberg, Junyan Jiang, Hayeon Bang, Hyeyoon Cho, Gus Xia, Akira Maezawa, Simon Dixon, Dasaem Jeong Abstract . This paper presents a comprehensive documentation of RenCon 2025, the revival of the expressive performance rendering competition which took place at ISMIR 2025 in Daejeon, Korea. The competition attracted 9 entries from international research groups, representing diverse approaches to expressive piano performance rendering. The two-phase assessment structure comprised a preliminary online evaluation and live real-time rendering at the conference. We analyze the competition format, participant demographics, system performance, and lessons learned for future iterations. The results demonstrate significant advances in expressive rendering capabilities while highlighting remaining challenges in achieving human-level musical expression. \setcopyright cc \acmYear 2026 \acmDOI \acmConference [NIME ’26]International Conference on New Interfaces for Musical ExpressionJune 23–26, 2026London, United Kingdom \settopmatter printacmref=false \acmISBN \orcid 0000-0000-0000-0000 1. Introduction Expressive performance rendering—the task of transforming a musical score into a performance with human-like timing, dynamics, and articulation, has been a central challenge in computer music since the 1980s 18 . The RenCon (CONtest for performance RENdering systems) series, initiated in 2002, provided an interactive evaluation platform for comparing different approaches to this challenge 9 . After the last competition in 2013, RenCon disappeared from the research landscape, coinciding with rapid advances in machine learning and artificial intelligence. Along with the creation of large-scale performance datasets such as ATEPP 23 and ASAP 16 , the field has since witnessed the emergence of neural approaches to music generation and performance modeling, making the revival of systematic evaluation more important than ever. RenCon 2025 marked the return of this competition, hosted as part of the Music Information Retrieval Evaluation eXchange (MIREX) at the International Society for Music Information Retrieval (ISMIR) Conference in 2025. This paper presents a comprehensive documentation of the competition design, participating systems, evaluation methodology, and results, contributing insights for future performance rendering evaluation and the broader Music Information Retrieval (MIR) community 1 1 1 Competition website: https://ren-con2025.vercel.app/ Online audition: https://ren-con2025-audition-page.vercel.app/ Results: https://github.com/ismir-mirex/RenCon2025 . 2. Past Competitions The Contest for Performance Rendering Systems (RenCon) was established to encourage research in performance rendering, and address the lack of standardized evaluation methods for computer systems for expressive music performance. Initiated in 2002, RenCon served as a “Turing Test" for musical expression, providing a public forum where autonomous and human-supported rendering systems could be judged by both experts and general audiences 9 . In its early iterations, the competition focused on defining valid evaluation criteria for the subjective nature of musical performance. 8 introduced specific methodologies such as the “Turing Test" and “Gnirut Test" (a reverse Turing Test) to assess whether a system’s output could be distinguished from human performance. These contests highlighted the challenge of bridging the gap between technical system measurements and human aesthetic perception. By 2008, RenCon had matured into a multi-category event, distinguishing between fully autonomous systems and those requiring human intervention. 7 detailed the 2008 contest at the ICMPC10 conference, noting the success of systems in the autonomous section. This period solidified RenCon’s role not just as a competition, but as a research platform for analysing the relationship between algorithmic parameters and listener preference. The cumulative knowledge of the competition’s decade-long run was synthesized by Katayose et al. 13 . This retrospective analysis emphasized the “RenCon Experience," discussing the difficulty of maintaining a “common ground" for evaluation as systems became more diverse. Despite the competition’s discontinuation after 2013, its legacy remains critical. For an overview of the different RenCon workshops, see Table 1 . Throughout the years there has been some experimentation of the contest procedure regarding evaluation, preparation of performances, and selection of music. However, the compulsory music has been quite restricted mostly to Chopin and Mozart and has always been restricted to the Western classical repertoire. The last workshop in Stockholm 2013 was organized together with the SMAC/SMC conference using a Disklavier piano. Two pieces were used, one by Domenico Scarlatti and one by Nino Rota. The pieces were performed live and votes were collected from both a jury and the audience. The winner in the automatic category was the Stochastic model 15 and in the human-in-the-loop category it was VirtualPhilharmony 1 . Table 1. Overview of past RenCon workshops. Year Conference Piano Music Interaction 2002 ICAD, Kyoto Disklavier Open Manual; Autonomous 2002 FIT, Tokyo MIDI Bar on piano Compulsory (Mozart or Chopin piece) Manual; Assisted; Autonomous 2003 IJCAI, Acapulco GigaPiano Compulsory (sel. Chopin) + Open - 2004 NIME, Hamamatsu GigaPiano Compulsory (any Chopin or Mozart) + Open - 2005 ICMC, Barcelona GigaPiano Compulsory (Mozart) + Open - 2006 ISMIR, Victoria Bösendorfer Compulsory (Chopin) + Open - 2008 ICMPC, Sapporo Disklavier One or two pieces with limited time Assisted; Autonomous 2009 EC, Tokyo Not known Not known Assisted; Autonomous 2011 SMC, Padova Disklavier New piece + a selected piece Assisted; Autonomous 2013 SMAC/SMC, Stockholm Disklavier Compulsory (Rota and Scarlatti) Assisted; Autonomous Problems due to the differences in dynamics across different digital pianos and Disklaviers have been an issue since the start of RenCon. The reason is that MIDI velocity is not related to any measurable quantities such as sound level. Instead, the MIDI velocity response has been selected ad-hoc and is different for different synthesizers, MIDI keyboards, and piano simulations. Since the different databases of piano performances that exist usually are coded in MIDI velocity as given by the instrument, the lack of dynamics calibration is a general problem in the research community. The long-term solution would be to translate the MIDI velocity to sound level for the instruments used for data collection 2 . This problem of MIDI velocity was addressed already in the 2003 workshop in which the commercial sampling synthesizer GigaPiano was used, thus the piano sampling could be used by the participants in advance. However, that lacked the realism of a real acoustic piano, and subsequently the later RenCons returned to the Disklavier or used the Bösendorfer SE system. A solution specifically for the RenCon workshop would be to provide a simulation of the instrument that is going to be used. In the case of the Disklavier, it would be possible, for example, to sample the instrument in the workshop using an automatic procedure and provide it as a sampling library. In this way, developers could test their models in advance using proper velocity mapping. Another option would be to have access to the instrument in advance so that it is possible to make adjustments before the actual workshop. This has the disadvantage that it would be rather limited in time and that only one user can test it at a time. 3. Competition Design RenCon 2025 adopted a two-phase structure consisting of an online audition round and a live final round. The online audition enabled broad international participation by removing the need for travel and allowing evaluators and teams to engage asynchronously across time zones. Based on the audition outcomes, the live final round focused on a smaller number of shortlisted teams, ensuring higher overall quality while keeping the session feasible within the limited time available during the conference. 3.1. Phase 1: Preliminary Round (Online) • Submission: May 30 - August 25,

Read the complete text