Integrating equity and productivity in health evaluation

Kristian S. Hansen, Juan D. Moreno-Ternero, Lars P. Østerdal · 2026

Read Integrating equity and productivity in health evaluation by Kristian S. Hansen, Juan D. Moreno-Ternero, Lars P. Østerdal (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-01763.txt.

Introduction

Kristian S Hansen, Juan D Moreno-Ternero, and Lars P Østerdal build one yardstick for health programs that values fairness and working capacity together. Standard measures weigh health alone: quality-adjusted life years, their productivity-flavored cousins, and a recent blend of the two. Each captures part of what societies care about when health spending also keeps people able to work.

The authors widen the family of evaluation functions and discipline it with normative rules. The reading must not depend on the measurement scale chosen. Shifting a unit of health from the better-off to the worse-off must count as an improvement, in the spirit of the Pigou-Dalton principle. Those demands force tidy power-form formulas. The result is a coherent base for judging interventions where health and productive capacity are both at stake, with the equity-efficiency balance set openly rather than smuggled in.

Catalog record

CREATORKristian S. Hansen, Juan D. Moreno-Ternero, Lars P. Østerdal
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE86 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.01763

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Integrating equity and productivity in health evaluation 1 1 1 We thank Odd Rune Straume, Ramses Abul Naga, as well as audiences at Universidad de Montevideo, Universidad de Chile, Kyoto University, and University of Granada, for helpful comments and suggestions. Financial support from the National Research Centre for the Working Environment (NFA), Copenhagen, Denmark, the Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI) via grant PID2023-146364NB-I00 funded by MCIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and FSE+, and the Independent Research Fund Denmark (grant no. 4260-00050B), is gratefully acknowledged. Kristian S. Hansen, Juan D. Moreno-Ternero, Lars P. Østerdal Abstract This paper develops a unified framework for evaluating health outcomes that jointly incorporates equity and productivity. Extending beyond traditional QALYs, PALYs, and the more recent PQALYs, we introduce a broader class of evaluation functions that integrate equity- and productivity-sensitive conditions. By imposing several normative criteria, including independence from measurement scales and Pigou-Dalton transfer principles, we obtain tractable power-form representations. In balancing equity and efficiency, the framework provides a coherent foundation for assessing interventions in contexts where both health and productive capacity are at stake. JEL numbers : D63, I10, J24. Keywords : health, productivity, equity, distribution, QALYs, PALYs, PQALYs 1 Introduction Health interventions affect not only the level and distribution of health, but also the productive capacity of individuals and populations. In many policy domains, ranging from health care to occupational health and safety, resource allocation decisions therefore involve trade-offs between improving average health, protecting vulnerable groups, and sustaining productivity. Conventional evaluation tools used in health economics typically focus on health outcomes alone and provide only limited guidance on how to balance these objectives when they conflict. This creates a need for outcome measures that can systematically incorporate both equity concerns and productivity effects within a single, coherent framework. Standard approaches to health evaluation rely on summary measures of population health that aggregate longevity and quality of life into a single index. Models such as Quality-Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) and Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALYs) have been widely adopted to capture these outcomes (e.g., Murray, 1996; Drummond et al., 2015; Neumann et al., 2016; GBD 2021 Diseases and Injuries Collaborators, 2024). Although valuable, these metrics have been criticized for overlooking broader societal concerns, particularly those related to equity (e.g., Broome, 1993) and the distribution of benefits across population groups. In response, a substantial body of work has developed equity-sensitive health evaluations, adjusting conventional measures to prioritize vulnerable individuals and align with principles of distributive justice (e.g., Wagstaff, 1991; Williams, 1997; Adler, 2012, 2025; Cookson et al., 2020; Da Costa et al., 2024; Robson et al., 2024, 2025b). From a different vantage point, scholars have increasingly emphasized the role of productivity as an integral component of health outcomes, rather than treating it only as a secondary or indirect consideration. A wide literature shows how poor health impairs work performance and generates substantial social costs (e.g., Zhang et al., 2011; Lohaus and Habermann, 2019; Elsler et al., 2017). In response, outcome-oriented approaches such as Productivity-Adjusted Life Years (PALYs) have been proposed to incorporate productivity directly into health metrics, reflecting a growing consensus to evaluate interventions on both productivity and health outcomes (e.g., Mattke et al., 2007; Ademi et al., 2021, 2025; Premji and Griffin, 2024). In Hansen et al. (2024), we extended this line of work to propose Productivity- and Quality-Adjusted Life Years (PQALYs), which integrate productivity and quality of life into a single metric. This framework recognizes that health not only influences longevity and well-being but also shapes individuals’ capacity to contribute economically. In doing so, PQALYs broaden the scope of evaluations beyond QALYs and DALYs, allowing analysts to capture both health-related quality adjustments and productivity considerations within the same outcome measure. The approach is particularly relevant for domains such as occupational health and safety (OHS), where the dual impacts of interventions on well-being and workforce participation are especially pronounced (e.g., Tompa et al., 2008; Steel et al., 2018). This paper develops a unified framework for health evaluation that integrates equity and productivity dimensions within an axiomatic setting. Our approach generalizes the PQALY proposal in Hansen et al. (2024) by embedding it within a broader class of evaluation functions that reflect fairness and economic sustainability. The framework connects classical tools from welfare economics (e.g., Moulin, 1988) with recent axiomatic advances in population health analysis (e.g., Hougaard et al., 2013; Moreno-Ternero et al., 2023), thereby providing a new normative foundation for assessing interventions in contexts where the equity-sensitive interplay between health and productive capacity is crucial. To achieve this, we outline a set of core axioms for evaluating population health distributions that are natural in this setting, incorporating Pigou-Dalton principles to capture equity considerations while imposing only minimal structural assumptions. From these foundations, we derive several formulations of evaluation functions based on Healthy Productive Years Equivalents (HPYEs), which extend beyond traditional QALYs and HYEs by capturing the joint effects of health status and productive capacity. 1 1 1 Healthy-Years Equivalents (HYEs) were introduced by Mehrez and Gafni (1989) as an alternative to QALYs. Moreno-Ternero et al. (2023) extend the notion to account for reference lifetimes, whereas Hansen et al. (2024) do so to account for productivity. A central feature of our analysis is the use of measurement-scale independence assumptions, which yield tractable power-form measures sensitive to disparities in health and productivity. Time scale independence reflects the view that lifetime length enters the evaluation only through relative duration. Accordingly, rescaling all lifetimes by a common factor, for example changing the unit of time from years to months, does not affect the social ranking of distributions. As a preview of our results, we first note that our framework is grounded in a characterization of equity-sensitive preferences represented by generalized HPYE evaluation functions with concave aggregators (Theorem 1). Imposing an additional time scale independence condition at full health and maximal productivity yields the equity-sensitive power HPYE evaluation function (Theorem 2), whereas a more general time scale independence condition leads to an equity-sensitive productivity- and quality-adjusted power lifetime evaluation function (Theorem 3). As limiting cases, imposing productivity or health independence, respectively, recovers the equity-sensitive power QALY or equity-sensitive power PALY evaluation functions. Moving beyond these broad formulations, we derive an equity-sensitive power PQALY evaluation function that fully integrates quality-of-life and productivity adjustments into the life-year metric (Theorem 4). We also obtain two hybrid specifications (power QALY-PALY and power QALY-PQALY) that introduce partial productivity or quality-of-life sensitivity, respectively, thereby bridging the pure power QALY metric and its productivity (power PALY) or productivity-adjusted (power PQALY) counterparts (Theorems 5 and 6). Finally, imposing a productivity scale independence axiom alongside a Pigou-Dalton principle for productivity yields an equity-sensitive bi-power PQALY function with distinct inequality-aversion parameters for lifetime and productivity (Theorem 7). Empirically, a substantial literature shows that improvements in health often raise productivity, through channels such as cognitive performance, physical capacity, and labor supply (see, among many others, Strauss and Thomas, 1998; Currie and Madrian, 1999; Bloom et al., 2004; Weil, 2007). The relationship may also run in the opposite direction, as adverse working conditions, high work intensity, and long hours can deteriorate mental and physical health, with implications for subsequent labor market outcomes and diminishing productivity returns (e.g., Pencavel, 2018; Belloni et al., 2022; Jolivet and Postel-Vinay, 2025). In

Read the complete text