Hidden gauge invariance

Karl-Henning Rehren · 2026

Read Hidden gauge invariance by Karl-Henning Rehren (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-01453.txt.

Introduction

Karl-Henning Rehren reconsiders gauge invariance, the symmetry at the heart of particle physics, by asking whether it must be assumed at all. His route builds the interactions of standard model particles from quantum principles alone, with no gauge input. The rules force the interactions to be string-localized, spread along a line rather than a point.

To his own stated surprise, most interactions that pass these tests turn out to carry an exact gauge invariance anyway, hidden until the fields are redefined. It holds even for massive force carriers, with no breaking step. That hidden symmetry proves the key to showing that scattering results do not depend on the string choice, and that they match the older gauge route's answers. The payoff is a version of particle physics with no ghost states and no indefinite spaces.

Catalog record

CREATORKarl-Henning Rehren
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE101 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.01453

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hidden gauge invariance Karl-Henning Rehren Abstract The role of gauge invariance is reconsidered by “deriving it without assuming it” within an autonomous approach to interactions of Standard Model particles. In this approach, the renormalizable interactions are purely constrained by quantum principles, notably the representation on a Hilbert space, which forces interactions to be “string-localized”. To some surprise, most interactions fulfilling the constraints enjoy an emergent but possibly “hidden” gauge invariance (uncovered via redefinitions of quantum fields). It is exact and unbroken even in the presence of massive vector bosons. It plays a major role in proving that S-matrices are insensitive to the string-localization, and in fact coincide with S-matrices of local interactions from the gauge theory approach on indefinite state spaces. Thus, particle physics with massless and massive vector bosons can be implemented without indefinite state spaces and ghosts. In memory of Ivan T. Todorov (1933-2025) 1 Introduction It is widely agreed that gauge invariance is extremely successful as a criterium to select classical Lagrangians for the Standard Model interactions. But several questions remain unanswered: Why gauge invariance in the first place? Is there any operational meaning of gauge invariance when gauge transformations do not affect observables? Can the notorious trouble with canonical quantization of gauge potentials (indefinite metric, unphysical degrees of freedom) be avoided? Ever since Jordan [ 17 ] and Dirac [ 3 ] , physicists and philosophers of science (e.g., [ 21 , 9 , 18 , 5 ] ) have worried about these and related questions. Concerning the observable content of classical gauge-invariant Lagrangians, an inspiring discussion (and an extended guide to the literature) can be found in [ 7 ] , see Remark 4.8 and Sect. 5 . We want to contribute a new point of view to the discussion. It is “genuinely quantum”, namely, it is ultimately the need for a Hilbert space formulation of the quantum field theory (not addressed in [ 7 ] ) that forces renormalizable interactions to be what they are. 1 1 1 The answer given in [ 24 ] , based on the observation that a covariant Lorentz transformation law for a gauge potential in the Wigner Hilbert space of helicity \pm 1 fails by a derivative term, so that the QED interaction A_{\mu}j^{\mu} is Lorentz invariant only up to a total derivative, has quite some similarity to our more comprehensive answer. Gauge invariance rather emerges as a (possibly hidden) feature of admissible Hilbert space interactions. The meaning of “admissible”, and the first sketch of “hidden gauge invariance” in Item 5 below require some explanations of the setup. It proceeds from an “autonomous approach” to particle interactions. 1. The autonomous approach. The “autonomous approach” to the interactions of particles ( [ 23 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 19 ] ) results in a highly constrained method to select admissible interaction densities, to be used in quantum perturbation theory. It explains several pertinent physical features of the Standard Model, where gauge theory falls short, see the quoted literature and Remark 2.3 , Remark 4.4 , and App. B . “Admissible” means, first of all, that the interactions densities are renormalizable and are defined on the physical Hilbert space of the particles. (The decisive, most restrictive conditions will be stated below.) For particles of helicity or spin 1, this means that one cannot use local vector potentials: Covariant quantization of massless vector potentials A_{\mu}(x) requires state spaces of indefinite metric, while the massive Proca vector field B_{\mu}(x) does not admit power-counting renormalizable interactions because its short-distance (UV) fluctuations are too strong (the two-point function has scaling degree 2). The autonomous approach is committed to quantum principles (Hilbert space, covariance and locality). The Hilbert space and covariance principles provide substitutes for the problematic fields A_{\mu} and B_{\mu} , given by “mildly non-local” (“string-localized”) potentials, see Item 2 below. However, the S-matrix must not depend on this non-locality. This highly nontrivial condition replaces a “gauge principle” to select the admissible interactions. 2. String-localization. String-localized potentials for massless vector bosons (“photons”) and massive vector bosons (MVBs) are defined by the same formula \displaystyle A_{\mu}(c,x):=I_{c}^{\nu}(F_{\mu\nu})(x)\equiv\int d^{4}y\,c^{\nu}(y)F_{\mu\nu}(x+y), (1.1) where F_{\mu\nu} is the local Maxwell tensor defined on the Fock space over the unitary Wigner representation of helicity \pm 1 in the massless case, and F_{\mu\nu}:=\partial_{\mu}B_{\nu}-\partial_{\nu}B_{\mu} on the Wigner Fock space of spin 1 in the massive case, satisfying the free field equations. For massive vector bosons, one defines also \displaystyle\phi(c,x):=I_{c}^{\nu}(B_{\nu})(x)\equiv\int d^{4}y\,c^{\nu}(y)B_{\nu}(x+y). (1.2) The function c^{\mu}(y) is required to satisfy \displaystyle\partial_{\mu}c^{\mu}(y)=\delta(y), (1.3) which entails the identity for the integral transform I^{\nu}_{c}(f)(x)=\int dy\,c^{\nu}(y)f(x+y) \displaystyle I_{c}^{\nu}(\partial_{\nu}f)=\partial_{\nu}I_{c}^{\nu}(f)=-f. (1.4) The identity ( 1.4 ) in turn, together with the field equations \partial_{\kappa}F_{\mu\nu}+\hbox{cycl.}=0 for the local field tensor in both cases (massless and massive) implies \displaystyle\partial_{\mu}A_{\nu}(c,x)-\partial_{\nu}A_{\mu}(c,x)=F_{\mu\nu}(x). (1.5) In the massive case, it also follows \displaystyle A_{\mu}(c)=B_{\mu}+\partial_{\mu}\phi(c). (1.6) The potentials A_{\mu}(c) have UV dimension 1 and serve as Hilbert space counterparts of gauge potentials, admitting power-counting renormalizable interactions 2 2 2 That power-counting is applicable as a criterium for renormalizability of string-localized interactions, is a consequence of work by Gass [ 10 ] . among each other and with scalar fields and spinor currents. We denote by L_{\rm int}(c,x) the interaction densities. There are many functions c^{\mu} satisfying ( 1.3 ), but their supports necessarily extend to infinity. Yet, they may (but need not) be narrow cones, which explains the terminology “string-localized”. Under infinitesimal changes \delta c^{\mu} of the function c^{\mu} , one has \delta_{c}(F)=\delta_{c}(B)=0 and \displaystyle\delta_{c}(A_{\mu}(c,x))=\partial_{\mu}w(\delta c,x),\quad\delta_{c}(\phi(c,x))=w(\delta c,x), (1.7) where \phi(c) exists only if m>0 . The explicit form w\equiv w(\delta c)=-I^{\nu}_{c}(\delta_{c}A_{\nu}(c)) of the “infinitesimal variation field” [ 13 , Lemma 2.1] will never be needed. 3. String-localization and string-independence. String-localization is a problem because locality of the perturbation theory is at stake with a non-local interaction density. This is the origin of the most important constraints on admissible interactions: the resulting S-matrix \displaystyle S_{L_{\rm int}(c)}=Te^{i\int dx\,L_{\rm int}(c,x)} (1.8) (also with source terms for observable fields) must be independent of the string function c^{\mu} . We write this postulate as \displaystyle\delta_{c}(S_{L_{\rm int}(c)})\stackrel{{\scriptstyle!}}{{=}}0.\qquad\hbox{\sl(String-independence)} (1.9) A more ambitious demand is that there exists another manifestly string-independent and local interaction density K_{\rm int} such that \displaystyle S_{L_{\rm int}(c)}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle!}}{{=}}S_{K_{\rm int}}.\qquad\hbox{\sl(Equality of S-matrices)} (1.10) The postulate ( 1.9 ) is truly autonomous: The fields that may appear in L_{\rm int}(c) are dictated by quantum principles, and the postulate selects those L_{\rm int}(c) as admissible, for which the string-localization has no effect. In particular, there is no reference to a “gauge principle”. For ( 1.10 ) in contrast, one has in mind a local density K_{\rm int} to compare with, which may be provided by the standard local (gauge theory) approaches to particle interactions. It is possibly not defined on a Hilbert space (massless case), or non-renormalizable (massive case) or both. We emphasize that S-matrices ( 1.8 ) involve only the interaction density L_{\rm int} (a Wick polynomial in free quantum fields). A “free Lagrangian” L_{0} is not needed, and not present in the autonomous approach, because the free fields are not quantized by “canonical quantization”, but directly constructed from the Wigner representations [ 29 ] . (Yet, there will appear some L_{0} in the sequel of the paper (notably Cor. 2.4 and Sect. 3

Read the complete text