Structural Ranking of the Cognitive Plausibility of Computational Models of Analogy and Metaphors with the Minimal Cognitive Grid

Alessio Donvito, Antonio Lieto · 2026

Read Structural Ranking of the Cognitive Plausibility of Computational Models of Analogy and Metaphors with the Minimal Cognitive Grid by Alessio Donvito, Antonio Lieto (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-01359.txt.

Introduction

Alessio Donvito and Antonio Lieto rate how well computer models of analogy and metaphor match what is known about human thought. They use the Minimal Cognitive Grid, a yardstick built for judging whether an artificial system is plausible as a model of the mind.

The authors turn the grid into a formal scoring method with three parts: the balance of function and structure, how general the system is, and how well its performance matches human patterns. They then score four systems, the Structure-Mapping Engine, CogSketch, METCL, and large language models. Because all four face the same math-based rules, their strengths and gaps can be compared directly. The work gives analogy research a shared, repeatable way to argue about mental realism.

Catalog record

CREATORAlessio Donvito, Antonio Lieto
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE111 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.01359

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Structural Ranking of the Cognitive Plausibility of Computational Models of Analogy and Metaphors with the Minimal Cognitive Grid Alessio Donvito, Antonio Lieto Abstract In this paper, we employ the Minimal Cognitive Grid (MCG), a framework created to evaluate the cognitive plausibility of artificial systems, to offer a systematic assessment of leading computational models of analogy and metaphor, including the Structure-Mapping Engine (SME), CogSketch, MET CL , and Large Language Models (LLMs). We present a formal and quantitative operationalization of the MCG framework and, through the analysis of its three main dimensions (Functional/Structural Ratio, Generality, and Performance Match), examine how well each system aligns with standard cognitive theories of the modeled phenomena, thus allowing for comparison of the models with respect to their cognitive plausibility, according to consistent and generalizable mathematical criteria. Introduction The creation, use, and interpretation of analogies and metaphors expressed in natural language sentences represent a crucial capacity of human semantic competence and communication. Analogical reasoning is widely regarded as a foundational cognitive process that underlies our ability to learn, generalize, and solve problems. By recognizing correspondences between different concepts and domains, individuals can extend existing knowledge to unfamiliar situations, identify regularities across varied contexts, and provide innovative solutions to new challenges. Given its relevance, uncovering the computational basis of analogy has been a long-standing objective in cognitive sciences. In the context of computational cognitive modeling, many different approaches have been proposed to endow artificial systems with the same ability. In this paper, we first review the main, state-of-the-art, computational models of analogy and metaphor through the epistemological lenses of computational cognitive science. In addition, we analyze and compare the following AI systems: 1) the Structure-Mapping Engine (SME) [ Falkenhainer et al., 1989a ]: this is one of the most influential systems in the field of analogical reasoning, whose underlying principles of identifying systematic correspondences between different domains have also been extended to metaphor understanding (where metaphors are seen as a form of analogy); 2) CogSketch [ Forbus et al., 2011 ]: an AI system that provides a sketch understanding environment that supports visual analogical reasoning and enables users to draw diagrams that it interprets, supporting reasoning about both physical and abstract concepts; 3)MET CL [ Lieto et al., 2025 ]: a compositional logic-based AI model for metaphor generation; 4) Large Language Models (in particular GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and GPT-4o) used for analogy and metaphor comprehension and generation (currently, no systematic assessment on such tasks of more recent systems like GPT 5.2 is available in the literature). In this paper we evaluate each of these systems with the Minimal Cognitive Grid: a pragmatic framework proposed by [ Lieto, 2021 ] to rank the different degrees of structural accuracy of artificial systems, in order to predict their explanatory power. In the section below, we introduce the theoretical distinction between functional and structural artificial models, along with the main features of the Minimal Cognitive Grid (MCG). Then, we quantitatively operationalize its dimensions and analyze each system on them. Finally, we combine each analysis within an overall cognitive plausibility score, showing that the MCG offers a blueprint for a generalizable comparison and ranking of artificial systems and models according to their biological or cognitive plausibility. The paper concludes with remarks and directions for future work. 1 Functional/Structural Models and the Minimal Cognitive Grid An important distinction in AI and computational cognitive modeling can be established between functional and structural models (or better: between functionally and structurally designed models). Functionalism was introduced in Philosophy of Mind by Hillary Putnam in his seminal article titled Minds and Machines [ Putnam, 1960 ]. This approach had a direct influence on AI, since it led to the definition of a design approach based on the notion of “functional equivalence” between some cognitive faculties in humans and the corresponding mechanisms implemented in AI programs. In other words, it posited that, from an explanatory point of view, the relation between “natural mind” and “artificial software” could have been based purely on a macroscopic equivalence of the functional organization of the two systems and their input-output specification. This position has been widely criticized in the literature over the last decades. In particular, models and systems designed according to the “functionalist” perspective are not good candidates for advancing the science of cognitive AI since, as in the case of an airplane, which flies through mechanisms entirely different from those of a bird [ Russell and Norvig, 2012 ], the mechanisms and the overall design choices adopted to build such artifacts prevent them from having any kind of explanatory role with respect to their counterparts in nature. This is the case, for example, of recent AI technologies, including some self-proclaimed “cognitive computing” systems like IBM Watson, AlphaGo, or Large Language Models [ Loru et al., 2025 ]. In short, such systems, as the vast majority of current AI systems, are “functional” artifacts. They “function as” a natural system (in terms of the provided output given the input that they process) but the internal mechanisms determining that output are completely different with respect to what we do as humans. Therefore, a mere artificial imitation of cognitive capabilities does not necessarily function according to the same principles. Differently from functionalism and functionally designed systems, the structural approach to model building in AI calls for a more strongly constrained connection between the designed artificial systems, and their internal architecture and procedures, and the corresponding ones available in a target biological system. According to such an approach, structurally constrained artificial models and systems can be useful both to advance the science of AI in terms of technological achievements (e.g., in tasks that are easily solvable for humans but very hard to solve for machines using non-cognitive inspired approaches, such as, for example, in commonsense reasoning) and to play the role of “computational experiments”, able to provide insights and results useful in refining or rethinking theoretical aspects concerning the target natural system used as a source of inspiration [ Cordeschi, 2002 , Milkowski, 2013 ]. An immediate problem arising in this view is that it is not possible to build a completely structural and constrained artificial model, since it is not possible to reproduce a realistic artificial “replica” of a natural system. The search for increasingly more structural models, in fact, leads to an asymptotic regress to the microscopic physical world, until it reaches the well-known Wiener paradox, summarized in the remark that “The best material model of a cat is another, or preferably the same, cat” [ Rosenblueth and Wiener, 1945 ]. In short, this “paradox” points to the need for constructing proxy models, not replicas, of a given natural system, while emphasizing the difficulty of such a challenge. A way to address this state of affairs consists in considering the functionalism/structuralism dichotomy as the two extremes of a continuum. Between the explanatory limitations of purely functional artificial models (that, however, can achieve impressive performances in specific tasks, like shown by modern AI systems), and the impracticability of pure structural models, it is possible to identify a wide range of plausible artificial proxy models having different degrees of explanatory power with respect to the natural systems that they take as sources of inspiration 1 1

Read the complete text