Directed Social Regard: Surfacing Targeted Advocacy, Opposition, Aid, Harms, and Victimization in Online Media
Scott Friedman, Ruta Wheelock, Sonja Schmer-Galunder, Drisana Iverson, Jake Vasilakes, Joan Zheng, Jeffrey Rye, Vasanth Sarathy, Christopher Miller · 2026
Read Directed Social Regard: Surfacing Targeted Advocacy, Opposition, Aid, Harms, and Victimization in Online Media by Scott Friedman, Ruta Wheelock, Sonja Schmer-Galunder, Drisana Iverson, Jake Vasilakes, Joan Zheng, Jeffrey Rye, Vasanth Sarathy, Christopher Miller (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-00776.txt.
Introduction
Scott Friedman and eight co-authors introduce Directed Social Regard, a method for finding mixed feelings aimed at specific targets in online text. Ordinary sentiment tools give one overall score, so they miss cases where praise and blame appear together, or who each feeling is aimed at. The team grounds its three scoring axes in social science ideas about moral framing and disengagement.
Two transformer models first find the text spans that receive sentiment, then score each span in context from negative to positive on each axis. The authors describe how they built and checked the training data. Applied to six outside datasets, the outputs line up in meaningful ways with existing labels and topics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Scott Friedman, Ruta Wheelock, Sonja Schmer-Galunder, Drisana Iverson, Jake Vasilakes, Joan Zheng, Jeffrey Rye, Vasanth Sarathy, Christopher Miller |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.00776
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Directed Social Regard: Surfacing Targeted Advocacy, Opposition, Aid, Harms, and Victimization in Online Media Scott Friedman, Ruta Wheelock, Sonja Schmer-Galunder, Drisana Iverson, Jake Vasilakes, Joan Zheng, Jeffrey Rye, Vasanth Sarathy, Christopher Miller Abstract The language in online platforms, influence operations, and political rhetoric frequently directs a mix of pro-social sentiment (e.g., advocacy, helpfulness, compassion) and anti-social sentiment (e.g., threats, opposition, blame) at different topics, all in the same message. While many natural language processing (NLP) tools classify or score a text’s overall sentiment as positive, neutral, or negative, these tools cannot report that positive and negative sentiments coexist, and they cannot report the target of those sentiments. This paper presents the Directed Social Regard (DSR) approach to multi-dimensional, multi-valence sentiment analysis, comprised of a pair of transformer-based models that (1) detects span-level targets of sentiment in a message and then (2) scores all spans within the message context along three (-1, 1) axes of regard that are motivated by social science theories of moral disengagement and moral framing. We present a data collection and annotation strategy for DSR dataset construction, a transformer-based architecture for span-level scoring, and a validation study with promising results. We apply the validated DSR model on six third-party datasets of online media and report meaningful correlations between DSR outputs and the labels and topics in these pre-existing social science datasets. keywords sentiment, stance, linguistics, moral disengagement, NLP, social science 1 Introduction Online media can express a broad array of influential sentiments, such as ascribing advocacy, victimization, blame, and opposition toward various topics, and sometimes all in a single sentence. The sentiment and moral commitments in online messaging have implications for a message’s continued existence and viral spread across social networks, potentially propagating outrage across online communities 7 . Consequently, researchers and online platforms have recently begun measuring multiple types of emotion 15 and sentiment to identify and prioritize prosocial media that has the potential to bridge individuals and communities 34 . In addition to understanding the general sentiment of media, recent sentiment-analysis approaches are also answering the questions of “sentiment about what?” or “sentiment toward whom?” 9 ; 22 ; 33 . These questions are important for complex messaging that combines multiple themes—such as advocating that we aid a victimized population and sanction their aggressor—all in the same message. These within-message complexities are important considerations, and ascribing a single score or category for an entire message may gloss over important pro- or anti-social themes that are directed toward different topics in the same context. Understanding how sentiment is directed at specific actors and topics—such as people, organizations, ideologies, geopolitical entities, products, and events—can inform social science, political analysis, cultural anthropology, market research, and information operations. To address this gap, we introduce Directed Social Regard (DSR), a novel framework for targeted sentiment analysis built upon theories of moral disengagement in the social sciences 4 ; 2 . DSR refines the task of targeted sentiment analysis to include dimensions of regard—interpretable, bipolar axes along which sentiment varies continuously—allowing for richer representations. To support our research, we also introduce a new dataset of DSR annotations over social media data. Figure 1: Directed Social Regard output for a simple sentence, inferring that the author expresses opposition ( oppo , red) and harmfulness ( harmf , red) directed at “they” and “do this” , and expresses advocacy ( advo , blue) and victimization ( victm , red) directed at “children.” We illustrate the richness of DSR representations in Figure 1 . The input sentence “How can they do this to the children??” exemplifies multi-sentiment messaging that directs a mixture of positive and negative regard at different entities and expresses layered regard toward single entities (e.g., advocating for the children while also expressing their victimization). Our model first identifies character (“they” and “children”) and topic (“do this”) spans in the input text. It then scores each span along three bipolar dimensions of regard from the author’s perspective: Opposed–Advocated, Victimized–Aided, and Harmful–Helpful. This paper is structured as follows. We provide an in-depth review of previous work alongside comparisons of DSR to existing sentiment analysis approaches in Section 2 . Section 3 describes DSR’s underpinnings in the social sciences and moral disengagement theory before laying out its realization in a transformer-based NLP architecture. We also describe the data collection and annotation process for our new DSR dataset. Section 4 details experimental results of the span recognition and DSR scoring models on this dataset, followed by example analyses of existing datasets using our DSR model. We close with a discussion of the social science implications and directions for future work. 2 Related Work The task of measuring how language communicates attitudes toward specific entities has been approached under several related paradigms in NLP, including targeted sentiment analysis, stance detection, and aspect-based sentiment analysis. While these frameworks share common goals, they often use overlapping terminology, which can obscure important distinctions. In this section, we clarify our terminology, situate our work within prior efforts, and highlight the advances enabled by our Directed Social Regard (DSR) framework. 2.1 Terminology We use the following terminology in the remainder of this work. A text is a sentence, utterance, or post which may contain one or more spans : contiguous sequences of words that may overlap or nest. A span may represent a topic (e.g., an event or abstract concept) or a character (e.g., a person or group) that is the target of a sentiment. Sentiment is the opinion or attitude of the author of a text with respect to a target. In most research, sentiment takes values along a polarity dimension (i.e., positive, negative, neutral) and can be categorical or numerical. Our work introduces a refinement of sentiment we call regard . Regard breaks out the concept of sentiment into multiple independent yet complementary dimensions, detailed in Table 1 . These dimensions, rooted in the social sciences, provide a rich characterization of an author’s expressed social relationship towards a person, group, or topic. We discuss these dimensions in more detail in Section 3 . Table 1: Definitions of dimensions of regard. Oppose–Advocate Whether the author expresses a desire to hinder or defend a target. Harmful–Helpful Whether the author deems the target to be a source of harm or help towards another character or topic. Victimized–Aided Whether the author views the target to be a harmed or helped by another character or topic. 2.2 Targeted Sentiment Analysis Targeted Sentiment Analysis seeks to determine the sentiment expressed toward one or more entities mentioned in a sentence. Early work relied on rule-based or feature-driven classifiers, while subsequent work leveraged pretrained transformers (e.g., BERT, RoBERTa) fine-tuned for token classification or span-level tagging 26 ; 39 . Targeted sentiment analysis differs from the simpler task of sentiment classification, which categorically labels an entire sentence as “negative” or uses a number to express positive or negative intensity, e.g., -0.8 1 . In Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA), models are trained to classify sentiment with respect to specific \langle entity, aspect \rangle pairs. For example, in product reviews, “battery life” and “camera” might be distinct aspects of a phone 30 , or that “leakage” and “allergenic” are aspects of childcare products 40 . These methods typically assume the