An approach to encode divergence-free stress fields in neural approximations based on stress potentials Journal: …

Mohammad S. Khorrami 1 , Pawan Goyal 2 , Soroush Motahari 1 , David Oexle 2 , Jaber R. Mianroodi 1 , Bob Svendsen 1,3 , Peter Benner 2 , Dierk Raabe 1 · 2026

Read An approach to encode divergence-free stress fields in neural approximations based on stress potentials Journal: … by Mohammad S. Khorrami 1 , Pawan Goyal 2 , Soroush Motahari 1 , David Oexle 2 , Jaber R. Mianroodi 1 , Bob Svendsen 1,3 , Peter Benner 2 , Dierk Raabe 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-00509.txt.

Introduction

Mohammad S. Khorrami and 7 co-authors build physics into the build of neural models for stress in solids, instead of only fining breaches while training. A stress field inside a body at rest must be divergence-free, the math statement of force balance. Standard physics-informed networks only push for that through the loss, so their outputs can still break the balance after training.

The authors encode the constraint directly, writing stress through a potential that makes the output divergence-free by design. Their physics-encoded Fourier neural operator is trained on stress data for a many-crystal solid of springy grains under one-way stretch. Against physics-guided and physics-informed rivals, with matched skill on the stress field itself, the encoded model's output met the balance far more closely. The approach shows how a hard physical law can be built in rather than hoped for.

Catalog record

CREATORMohammad S. Khorrami 1 , Pawan Goyal 2 , Soroush Motahari 1 , David Oexle 2 , Jaber R. Mianroodi 1 , Bob Svendsen 1,3 , Peter Benner 2 , Dierk Raabe 1
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.00509

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An approach to encode divergence-free stress fields in neural approximations based on stress potentials Journal: … Mohammad S. Khorrami 1 , Pawan Goyal 2 , Soroush Motahari 1 , David Oexle 2 , Jaber R. Mianroodi 1 , Bob Svendsen 1,3 , Peter Benner 2 , Dierk Raabe 1 Abstract The purpose of the current work is the development of an approach to account for quasi-static mechanical equilibrium in empirical (i.e., data-based) models for the stress field employing neural approximations (NAs), which include neural networks (NNs) and neural operators (NOs), in particular Fourier NOs (FNOs). Rather than including such constraints from physics in the loss function as done in the (now standard) physics-informed approach, the current approach incorporates or "encodes" such constraints directly into the architecture of the NA. As a result, both NA training and output are physically constrained in the physics-encoded approach, in contrast to the physics-informed approach, in which only training is physically constrained. For the current constraint of divergence-free stress, a novel encoding approach based on a stress potential is proposed. As a "proof-of-concept" example application of the current approach, a physics-encoded FNO (PeFNO) is developed for a heterogeneous polycrystalline material consisting of isotropic elastic grains and subject to uniaxial extension. Stress field data for this purpose are obtained from the numerical solution of corresponding boundary-value problems for quasi-static mechanical equilibrium. For comparison with the PeFNO, this data is also employed to develop an analogous physics-guided FNO (PgFNO) and physics-informed FNO (PiFNO). As expected theoretically, and confirmed by this computational comparison, for comparable accuracy of the stress field itself as compared to the data, the stress field output by the trained and tested PeFNO is significantly more accurate in satisfying mechanical equilibrium than the output of either the PgFNO or the PiFNO. 1 Introduction Given the inherent lack and sparsity of data for most physical phenomena as well as their complexity, the development of empirical (i.e., data-based) or "surrogate" numerical models for these phenomena based on (artificial) neural networks (NNs) often includes constraints from physics to improve model robustness. As discussed recently by 11 for example, the resulting physics-constrained NNs are currently of three types: (i) physics-guided (PgNNs), (ii) physics-informed (PiNNs), and (iii) physics-encoded (PeNNs). For all three types, the data are constrained to be physical (e.g., experimental measurements); PiNNs and PeNNs are based on further physical constraints. In the case of PiNNs, these constraints are incorporated into the loss function (for training/testing), whereas for PeNNs, they are incorporated into ("encoded" in) the network architecture. By far the most common of these three types are PgNNs and PiNNs. PiNNs in particular have been developed for various applications in science and engineering ( 8 ) such as computational fluid dynamics ( 5 ; 28 ) or heat transfer ( 6 ; 43 ; 30 ) . Additional examples of PgNNs and PiNNs for computational fluid flow are discussed by 11 . Analogously, a number of PgNNs and PiNNs have appeared for data-based numerical modeling in computational solid mechanics ( 13 ; 2 ; 29 ; 23 ; 41 ; 3 ; 9 ; 21 ; 44 ) ; see also 11 . Most recently, 40 have introduced a PiNN for 2D linear elasticity in which the constraint of mechanical equilibrium in the loss function is based on the Airy stress potential rather than on the divergence of the stress field. Among the types of physics-constrained NNs mentioned above, PeNNs are the most challenging to develop (e.g., 11 , §4) and consequently the least common in the literature. Advantages of PeNNs include less sensitivity to data sparsity than exhibited by PgNNs and PiNNs. Prominent examples of PeNNs include (i) the physics-encoded recurrent convolutional neural network (PeRCNN) (ii) neural ordinary differential equations (NeuralODE), and (iii) neural partial differential equations (NeuralPDE) ( 10 ) . In particular, the latter represents an extension of NeuralODE to PDEs by combining the method of lines and NeuralODE in a multilayer convolutional NN. Being dependent on the method of lines, NeuralPDE is not directly applicable to certain kinds of PDEs (e.g., elliptical second-order PDEs). In the realm of computational solid mechanics, PeNNs are being developed for constitutive relations and balance relations. In contrast to balance relations, which apply to all materials, recall that constitutive relations hold only for a specific type of material behavior such as elastic, viscoelastic, elastic-viscoplastic, and so on. An example of these is the so-called constitutive artificial NN (CANN) of 25 for isotropic elastic solids. More specifically, CANN represents a constitutive PeNN for finite-deformation isotropic hyperelasticity which exploits tensor invariants and encodes physically relevant mathematical properties such as polyconvexity in the network architecture. Direct generalization of CANNs to anisotropic and inelastic behavior ( 17 , e.g., iCANNs:) is possible with the help of network parameterization based for example on structure tensors ( 37 ; 45 , e.g.,) . Additional PeNNs (e.g., ICNNs) for scalar-valued constitutive relations like the stored energy, yield functions, or dual dissipation potentials, are discussed by 12 in their recent review of data-driven constitutive relations for solids ( 16 , see also for example) . Rather than being based on functions as in the case of NNs, the approximation represented by so-called neural operators (NOs: e.g., 11 , §5) is based on operators. Advantages of NOs over NNs include for example much less sensitivity to issues related to discretization. Prominent examples of NOs include deep operator networks ( 26 ; 27 , DeepONets: ) and Fourier neural operators ( 24 ; 22 , FNOs: ) . PgNOs and PiNOs have been developed for data-based numerical modeling in computational solid mechanics, including heterogeneous materials ( 19 ) , linear elastic fracture mechanics ( 15 ; 14 ) , or even production by three-dimensional printing ( 31 ) . The purpose of the current work is the development of an approach to encode quasi-static equilibrium (i.e., divergence-free) stress fields in neural approximations (NAs), which include both neural networks (NNs) and neural operators (NOs), in particular Fourier NOs (FNOs). To this end, the representation of such stress fields based on a stress potential is employed. To our knowledge, neither a PeNN, nor a PeNO, of this type for empirical, i.e., data-based numerical modeling of the quasi-static equilibrium stress field has appeared in the literature up to this point. Methodolgically close to the current work is that of 32 , who developed a PeNN for divergence-free vector fields (e.g., the velocity field in the case of incompressible flow) in computational fluid dynamics. In contrast to the methodology developed in the current work, their very interesting approach (i) is limited to vector fields, (ii) is based on the Hodge decomposition of differential 1-forms, and (iii) employs function approximation (i.e., NNs) and automatic differentiation. More recently, 18 have introduced a mixed PeNN-PiNN approach for computational fluid dynamics and magnetohydrodynamics in which mass and momentum balance are encoded in a so-called Riemann tensor neural network (RTNN) for symmetric divergence-free tensor fields. Although not explicitly pursued by them, their approach is potentially applicable to linear elastic solid dynamics as well. Also not pursued by 18 is the fact that the approach to divergence-free tensor fields underlying RTNNs can be generalized to non-symmetric stress tensors, as

Read the complete text