Bell Correlations and Selection Bias
Huw Price · 2026
Read Bell Correlations and Selection Bias by Huw Price (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-00406.txt.
Introduction
Huw Price proposes a deflationary reading of the famous Bell correlations in quantum physics. Experiments inspired by John Stewart Bell's work show linked particles behaving in ways widely taken to prove the world is nonlocal. That reading sits in tension with relativity, unless realism about an independent world is abandoned. Price points to a familiar statistical effect instead: selection bias.
How a sample is selected from a larger population can create correlations between unrelated variables, or hide real ones, and preselection through preparation of the starting state is a known source. Price argues that the selection in standard two-particle Bell experiments is exactly such a preselection, and that it has been overlooked in this setting. On his account, the correlations are selection artefacts, and neither relativity nor realism needs to fall.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Huw Price |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.00406
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bell Correlations and Selection Bias Huw Price Abstract Methods of selecting samples from larger populations may produce bias, in either direction: inducing correlations between variables independent in the full population, or masking correlations between variables dependent in the full population. Here we propose a surprising application of these familiar ideas. We argue that they are relevant to puzzling correlations uncovered in quantum theory by John Stewart Bell (Bell 1964). In the light of Bell’s work and subsequent experiments it is widely believed that the quantum world is ‘nonlocal’, in apparent tension with relativity. Many hold that the only alternative is to abandon ‘realism’, the view that there is an objective world independent of measurement. We propose instead that Bell’s correlations are selection artefacts, in tension neither with relativity nor realism. In standard two-particle Bell experiments the relevant selection is a preselection, achieved by the preparation of the initial state. Again, selection bias via preselection is familiar elsewhere in science, but it doesn’t seem to have been noticed that it is applicable in this case. Keywords: Bell correlations, selection bias, collider bias, nonlocality 1 Introduction Selection artefacts are common in science. Procedures for selecting samples from larger populations may produce bias, in either direction: inducing correlations between independent variables, or masking correlations between dependent variables. Missing such bias has practical consequences, where statistics guide policy. The case discussed here is a long way from policy, but of unusual theoretical interest. Some of the most puzzling correlations in modern science are those uncovered by the physicist John Stewart Bell in the 1960s (Bell 1964). Bell argued that if the predictions of quantum mechanics (QM) are correct, then there are correlations in the quantum world that cannot be explained by a local theory – that is, intuitively, by a theory in which causal influences propagate at finite speed, as required by special relativity. The relevant predictions have since been confirmed in many experiments. Do these experiments prove that the world is nonlocal in Bell’s sense? It is often said that the only alternative is to reject realism – roughly, the view that the world exists independently of our measurement choices. The experiments in question are described as disproving local realism -- as showing that either locality or realism must be abandoned. 1 1 1 (Shalm et al 2015) claims ‘a loophole-free violation of local realism’, for example. Here we propose an alternative. 2 2 2 More accurately, a new alternative. For discussion of other proposals see (Myrvold et al 2024). We argue that the correlations in these experiments may be regarded as selection artefacts. As noted, selection bias often produces correlations between variables that are actually independent. It turns out that Bell correlations fit this model. As we will explain, there are two ways to describe this conclusion. One is to say that the proposal avoids nonlocality (without sacrificing realism). The other is to say that Bell nonlocality itself turns out to be a selection artefact. This is a terminological issue, depending on what we mean by ‘nonlocality’ when the new option is in view. We return to this question below (§4.1), referring to Bell’s own discussion of the term. Either way, the upshot is that Bell correlations are less puzzling than they have seemed, in tension neither with relativity nor realism. ‘Less puzzling’ does not imply ‘not puzzling at all’. The proposal identifies an escape route from some unwelcome consequences seemingly implied by Bell’s work. It doesn’t explain the novel features of QM on which the whole issue depends. Again, more on this below (§4.2). We begin with selection bias in general. Much of this material will be familiar to many readers, but we will introduce new terminology, at a couple of points. Figure 1: Survivorship bias. 4 4 4 Image by Granjean and McGeddon from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias 2 What is selection bias? Readers may recognise Figure 1. It represents the distribution of damage found on bombers, returning from missions in WWII. (Think of the red dots as bullet holes.) Clearly, there is a strong correlation between location on the aircraft and the probability of damage. In some parts of the aircraft the probability is high, in other places close to zero. We can imagine ways in which this correlation might be explained by causal dependencies. There are three main possibilities: (i) the geometry of the aircraft might be influencing the trajectory of the projectiles causing the damage; (ii) the projectiles might be influencing the position of the aircraft, the latter shifting itself to ensure that the damage is confined to these areas; (iii) some third variable – a common cause -- might be influencing the location of both the aircraft and the projectiles. None of these explanations is correct. As Abraham Wald pointed out, 5 5 5 The story may be apocryphal: https://www.ams.org//publicoutreach/feature-column/fc-2016-06 . the correlation results from the fact that we are looking at a biased subset of the data – those aircraft that made it back to base. Aircraft with damage in other locations did not survive, and that’s what’s skewing the data, producing the correlation. This is an example of selection bias. This particular variety is called survivorship bias, for the obvious reason: the selection variable is ‘survival’. Survivorship bias is a subspecies of collider bias. In the terminology of causal models, a collider is a variable influenced by two or more causes – a node where two or more arrows ‘collide’, in the graphical notation of direct acyclic graphs (DAGS; see Figure 2). Conditioning on a collider – that is, selecting cases in which the collider variable takes a particular value – typically produces a correlation between the contributing causes, even if they are in fact independent. In such cases, the apparent dependence between the two causes is explained by the combination of two things: first, the actual dependence between the two causes and their common effect; and second, the fact that the latter is being held fixed in a selection process. (Again, think of the bomber example.) G F H Figure 2: A common effect, or collider We propose here that Bell correlations are similar to collider bias – indeed, some of them may be collider bias. But it will be helpful to start further back, stressing first that not all selection bias is collider bias. Why is selection bias not always collider bias? For two reasons, important in different ways. First, collider bias is a special case of something more general – something not necessarily causal at all. We will need the general notion below, so it will be helpful to clarify the point now. Second, there is another species of selection bias, whose effect is the opposite of collider bias. It masks genuine dependencies rather than inducing spurious dependencies. This kind of selection bias also has some important lessons for the quantum case. We will explain these two points in turn. 2.1 Collider bias and its combinatorial cousins Collider bias typically induces correlations, but there are other cases of correlation-inducing selection bias, with no colliders involved. Most obviously, there are non-physical cases, e.g., in mathematics. Here, where variables are related logically but not causally, we find a similar kind of selection bias. For example, imagine