On Aubry’s completeness conjecture

Tianqi Shi and Jinxin Xue · 2026

Read On Aubry’s completeness conjecture by Tianqi Shi and Jinxin Xue (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-00305.txt.

Introduction

Tianqi Shi and Jinxin Xue take on Aubry's completeness conjecture, a claim about twist maps and the physics of atomic chains. In the Frenkel-Kontorova model of atoms on a surface, whether the chain conducts or insulates hinges on how rotation numbers vary with a stiffness-like parameter. Aubry predicted that this variation forms a complete devil's staircase, a curve that climbs only in jumps.

The authors present an argument for the conjecture when all minimal configurations are uniformly hyperbolic, the strongly chaotic case. In that regime they argue the rotation number graph is purely singularly continuous, matching Aubry's picture. They also argue the opposite case: when a positive share of orderly KAM tori survives, the staircase is incomplete. The phenomenon is kin to phase locking in circle maps and to steps in the fractional quantum Hall effect.

Catalog record

CREATORTianqi Shi and Jinxin Xue
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE72 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.00305

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On Aubry’s completeness conjecture Tianqi Shi and Jinxin Xue Abstract . In this paper, we prove Aubry’s completeness stating conjecture that for a twist map the graph of rotation numbers as a function of the cohomology classes is a purely singularly continuous function (called complete devil’s staircase by Aubry) when the set of all minimal configurations is uniformly hyperbolic. Such a phenomenon is crucial for characterizing the chain of atoms being an insulator for the Frenkel-Kontorova model, and can be considered as the analogue of the phase locking phenomenon in critical circle maps as well as the fractional quantum Hall effect. In contrast, in the presence of a positive measure set of KAM tori, we prove that the devil’s staircase is incomplete. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 37J40,37J51 1. Introduction The Aubry-Mather theory on twist maps is widely considered to be the most important development in Hamiltonian dynamics after KAM. An important prototypical model studied in the theory is the standard map of the form \phi:\mathbb{T}\times\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{T}\times\mathbb{R},\quad(x,y)\mapsto(x+y+k\sin x,y+k\sin x). The standard map is in general very chaotic, defying analysis. When k is small, the theory of Kolmogorov-Arnold-Moser gives a Cantor set of Diophantine numbers such that for each point \rho in the set, there is an invariant circle restricted to which the dynamics is conjugate to a circle rotation by \rho. However, the KAM theory says nothing in the complement of the set of KAM invariant circles where the dynamics is very chaotic. The approach of Aubry-Mather theory was to utilize the variational principle to obtain a family of minimal configurations, which can be classified, and we can extract an ordered structure from the chaos by the energy minimization procedure. Compared to the KAM theory, the Aubry-Mather theory is nonperturbative. Moreover, it has a global nature lying in the fact that we can parameterize all the minimal configurations by a real parameter, and the dynamical information of the minimal configurations is encoded in the structure of a function called the \alpha -function of the real parameter. The main theme of the paper is to further explore how the structure of \alpha is related to the phase space dynamics. 1.1. Frenkel-Kontorova model, devil’s staircase and Aubry’s completeness conjecture To motivate Aubry’s completeness conjecture, we first give a brief overview of Aubry’s work on this topic. Readers are recommended the paper [ 3 ] of Aubry in 1978, which set the stage for his series of works later. 1.1.1. Frenkel-Kontorova model and minimal configurations Aubry focused on the Frenkel-Kontorova model (FK model) in solid state physics which describes the positions of atoms in solids with nearest neighbor interaction with energy of the form (1.1) h(x_{n},x_{n+1})=\frac{1}{2}(x_{n}-x_{n+1})^{2}-k\cos(2\pi x_{n}), where the term (x_{n}-x_{n+1})^{2} is similar to the elastic potential for springs and the term k\cos(2\pi x_{n}) is the periodic background potential. A configuration is a biinfinite sequence (\ldots,x_{-1},x_{0},x_{1},\ldots) . When the atoms are at a stationary configuration, we should have the Euler-Lagrange equation (1.2) \partial_{2}h(x_{i-1},x_{i})+\partial_{1}h(x_{i},x_{i+1})=0. Moreover, in experiments, we only see stable stationary configurations, since unstable ones are easily perturbed away. It is then natural to look for stable configurations by minimizing the total energy. In general, if we consider the total energy \sum_{\ell=-\infty}^{\infty}h(x_{\ell},x_{\ell+1}) of a configuration, it is most likely to be infinity. However, we can still talk about minimality in terms of minimality for every finite segment. Definition 1.1 . A configuration is called minimal , if the following holds for any integers i<j \sum_{\ell=i}^{j-1}h(x_{\ell},x_{\ell+1})\leqslant\inf_{\xi_{i}=x_{i},\xi_{j}=x_{j}}\sum_{\ell=i}^{j-1}h(\xi_{\ell},\xi_{\ell+1}). In the FK model, the Euler-Lagrange equation gives (1.3) (x_{n+1}-2x_{n}+x_{n-1})-2\pi k\sin(2\pi x_{n})=0. Defining y_{n}=\partial_{2}h(x_{n-1},x_{n})=x_{n}-x_{n-1} , we get a 2D map \left\{\begin{array}[]{l}x_{n+1}=x_{n}+y_{n}+2\pi k\sin(2\pi x_{n})\\ y_{n+1}=y_{n}+2\pi k\sin(2\pi x_{n}).\\ \end{array}\right. This is in the form of the standard map. 1.1.2. The devil’s staircase Aubry in 1983 ( [ 7 ] ) introduced the mean energy per atom along any minimal configuration with the prescribed rotation number, \beta(\varrho)=\lim_{k\to\infty}\frac{1}{2k+1}\sum_{i=-k}^{k-1}h(x_{i},x_{i+1}),\ \forall\ (\cdots,x_{i},x_{i+1},\cdots)\in\mathscr{Q}_{\varrho}. Here \mathscr{Q}_{\varrho} is the set of minimal configurations with rotation number \varrho . Aubry first proved the strict convexity of \beta in [ 7 ] . This is essentially reflecting the fact that minimal configurations with different rotation numbers necessarily intersect. In the paper [ 7 ] , Aubry discovered the following remarkable devil’s staircase phenomenon encoding further dynamical information of the set of minimal configurations for all rotation numbers. Theorem 1.2 . The \beta -function is differentiable at each irrational point and generically nondifferentiable at each rational point. The result was discovered by Aubry using numerics who formulated it into a conjecture. The mathematical proof of the result was given in [ 26 , 14 ] . The result can be reformulated in terms of the Legendre dual of the \beta -function called the \alpha -function. The notion was also introduced by Aubry in [ 7 ] who considered adding a chemical potential to the FK model. Definition 1.3 . The \alpha -function is defined to be the Legendre transformation of \beta , i.e. the \alpha -function takes its value at c such that \alpha(c)+\beta(\varrho)=c\varrho , or equivalently, \alpha(c)=-\liminf_{K,K^{\prime}\to\infty}\inf_{\mathbf{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{K^{\prime}+K}}\frac{1}{K+K^{\prime}}\Big(\sum_{i=-K}^{K^{\prime}-1}h(x_{i},x_{i+1})-c(x_{K^{\prime}}-x_{-K})\Big). The last theorem is translated to the statement that the graph of D\alpha is a devil’s staircase , where by devil’s staircase we mean that the graph of D\alpha is monotonically increasing and has infinitely many horizontal pieces. Indeed, since \alpha and \beta are mutual Legendre transformations of each other, the convexity of \beta implies also the convexity of \alpha , which further implies that D\alpha is monotonically increasing. the strict convexity of \beta translates to the continuity of D\alpha. A nondifferentiable point \varrho of \beta corresponds to an interval [c^{-},c^{+}] such that D\alpha=\varrho and D^{2}\alpha=0 when restricted to (c^{-},c^{+}) . Thus, generically, the graph of D\alpha has infinitely many horizontal pieces, i.e., a devil’s staircase. 1.1.3. Transition by breaking of analyticity and the completeness conjecture There is an important theme in Aubry’s works that seems not well understood or appreciated by mathematicians that is the transition by breaking of analyticity . The physics of this transition is important. On an invariant curve, the atoms can slide without causing extra energy, thus the chain of atom is a metal. On the other hand, when the invariant curve is broken, some energy (called the Peierls-Nabarro barrier ) has to be costed to shift the minimal configuration to a nearby one, in which case, the atoms are locked and the material is an insulator. When we increase the constant k in the standard map from zero, for a Diophantine number \rho , the corresponding invariant circle persists for k in a certain range [0,k_{\rho}] . When k further increases beyond k_{\rho} , the invariant circle breaks and a Cantor set shows up. This is a transition from metal to insulator called the transition by breaking of analyticity by Aubry. In physics, it is important to know if the devil’s staircase is complete or not. We say a function f:\ [a,b]\to\mathbb{R} is a complete devil’s staircase if f is a purely singularly continuous function, i.e. f is continuous, nonconstant, and its derivative is vanishing almost everywhere. A complete devil’s staircase means zero probability for incommensurate phases. As a commensurate phase means that the atoms are locked, thus the material is an insulator, a complete devil’s staircase means that the material is an insulator with probability 1. This

Read the complete text