Electrotactile Improves Thermal Referral
Wen Li, Rong Ni, Bozhi Tian, Pedro Lopes · 2026
Read Electrotactile Improves Thermal Referral by Wen Li, Rong Ni, Bozhi Tian, Pedro Lopes (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-00240.txt.
Introduction
Wen Li and 3 co-authors improve thermal referral, a trick that lets a person feel heat or cold at a spot with no heater or cooler of its own. A nearby thermal source supplies the sensation, while a touch cue at the target spot draws the feeling there. Vibration has been the usual cue, but it handles cold poorly and its buzz feels wrong for events with no contact.
The team swaps vibration for mild electric stimulation of the skin. In a laboratory study and a virtual reality study, the electric version raised the rate of successful cold referral. It also strengthened the thermal feeling while reducing the touch feeling itself, and it made scenes such as an open freezer feel more real. The authors give design guidelines for choosing cues.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wen Li, Rong Ni, Bozhi Tian, Pedro Lopes |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.00240
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Electrotactile Improves Thermal Referral Wen Li, Rong Ni, Bozhi Tian, Pedro Lopes Abstract . Thermal referral enables thermal sensations in locations lacking thermal actuators—this is achieved using vibrotactile actuators to redirect a nearby thermal sensation to where a tactile sensation is applied. However, we found that its reliance on vibration introduces critical limitations: it struggles to produce cold referral, and the inherent strong tactile “buzz” makes it unsuitable for simulating non-contact thermal events, such as the chill of an open freezer in VR (in contrast to contact-based thermal events like touching the freezer’s cold handle). To improve this, we propose a shift from vibrotactile to electrotactile-based thermal referral. We evaluated in two user studies—a psychophysics experiment (N=22) and a VR deployment (N=20)—where we contrasted electrotactile with vibrotactile-based thermal referral. Our results reveal key advantages of the electrotactile-based thermal referral: (1) increases the referral rate for cold sensations; (2) increases thermal perception while minimizing tactile; and (3) improves realism across a range of VR thermal scenarios, specifically distinguishing between contact-based and non-contact thermal events. Finally, we provide design guidelines for choosing tactile cues to create immersive multi-modal thermal experiences in VR. Conference: The 39th Annual ACM Symposium on User Interface Software and Technology; November 02–05, 2026; Detroit, MI, USA The 39th Annual ACM Symposium on User Interface Software and Technology (UIST ’26), November 02–05, 2026, Detroit, MI, USA DOI: 10.1145/3830398.3830581 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2856-3/2026/11 CCS: Human-centered computing Haptic devices Figure 1. Thermal referral emerged as a popular technique to minimize the number of thermal actuators needed by swapping some with smaller and less power-hungry vibrotactile actuators. In this technique the vibration motors redirect nearby thermal sensations to the vibration motor’s location. However, despite the rapid expansion of this technique in HCI, we unveiled critical challenges that limit its interactive applicability: (1) thermal referral struggles to reliably produce cold referral, and (2) the distracting tactile “buzz” from vibration motors makes it unsuitable for simulating non-contact thermal sources. Thus, we propose a methodological shift from vibrotactile to electrotactile stimulation. Our results confirmed this significantly improves cold referral rates and thermal quality. Composite figure showing a vibrotactile thermal-referral failure and an electrotactile success. On the left, a person in VR feels cold only at the wrist Peltier rather than near the elbow tactile site. The center box plot shows a higher cold-referral rate for electrotactile than vibrotactile. On the right, electrotactile refers cold to the intended location near the elbow. † † cc-license: by 1. INTRODUCTION Spatially distributed thermal feedback can make wearable and immersive interfaces more expressive, but scaling such feedback typically requires adding thermal actuators at every possible output location. Because these actuators are comparatively bulky and power-hungry, increasing their number limits wearability. Thermal referral offers an alternative: when tactile stimulation is applied near a thermal actuator, users can perceive the temperature at the tactile location rather than at its physical source ( Wang et al., 2024b ) . By decoupling the physical and perceived locations of thermal output, this illusion enables interfaces to cover more body locations with fewer thermal actuators. Recent interactive systems have begun using thermal referral as an actuation technique for localized, moving, and object-coupled thermal feedback in wearable and immersive interfaces ( Cataldo et al., 2016 ; Singhal et al., 2025 ; Singhal et al., 2024 ; Son et al., 2023 ; Wang et al., 2024b ; Wang et al., 2024a ; Yi et al., 2024 ) . Across these systems, the standard implementation is based on vibrotactile actuators (e.g., ERM or LRA motors) to anchor the referred thermal sensation. While effective for specific scenarios—such as simulating contact heat where a user expects a physical contact sensation (e.g. feeling hot water splash one’s hand ( Wang et al., 2024a ) )—we will demonstrate, via the findings of our two experiments, that relying on mechanical vibration introduces two critical limitations that hinder broader application of thermal referral in interactive domains, such as VR. First, vibrotactile thermal referral is unreliable for cold output: prior work found its occurrence rate to be approximately 20% lower for cold than for heat ( Wang et al., 2024b ) . In an interactive system, such failures produce a mismatch between the intended output location and the user’s perception, breaking immersion. Second, vibration adds an unavoidable tactile “buzz” to the thermal percept. Although this cue can be congruent with contact events, such as touching a hot object, it conflicts with non-contact events, such as feeling heat from a fireplace or cold air from an ice source, as shown in Figure 1 . Thus, vibrotactile referral cannot cleanly distinguish thermal events that imply contact from those that do not. We overcome these limitations by proposing a novel thermal referral via electrotactile stimulation, as depicted in Figure 1 (b). We evaluated this approach in two studies. Our first study providerd a controlled psychophysics setting ( N =22) that compared vibrotactile and electrotactile referral across modality and intensity, demonstrating that electrotactile stimulation substantially improves cold referral and that threshold-level stimulation can reduce the accompanying tactile sensation (our vibrotactile baseline also provides a partial replication of prior thermal-referral findings ( Wang et al., 2024b ) ). Our second study ( N =20) examined how these perceptual differences affect four contact and non-contact thermal interactions in VR. Together, this work contributes: (1) electrotactile thermal referral as an alternative actuation technique for spatial thermal interfaces; (2) a wearable, interactive implementation and empirical characterization of tactile modality and intensity; and (3) design guidance for matching tactile cues to the semantics of contact and non-contact thermal events. 2. RELATED WORK The work presented in this paper builds primarily on the broadly defined field of haptics (i.e., thermal included), with particular emphasis on the emergence of thermal referral in HCI as a promising technique for thermal rendering. Finally, since our approach substitutes mechanical vibration with electrotactile, we succinctly review the field of electrotactile. 2.1. Thermal referral effect A thermal referral is a type of illusion that perceptually displaces a thermal sensation to the location where a tactile stimulus is delivered—i.e., the thermal sensation is thus referred to the location of the tactile stimulus, giving rise to the term “thermal referral” ( Green, 1977 ; Ho et al., 2011 ) . This effect recently rose to prominence in HCI ( Cataldo et al., 2016 ; Singhal et al., 2025 ; Singhal et al., 2024 ; Son et al., 2023 ; Wang et al., 2024b ; Wang et al., 2024a ; Yi et al., 2024 ) by providing a powerful way to minimize the number of thermal actuators (i.e., by swapping some thermal actuators with smaller and less power-hungry tactile actuators). This technique is in line with a larger trend in haptics arguing for less cumbersome actuators, without sacrificing their actuation capabilities ( Brooks et al., 2020 ; Pacchierotti et al., 2017 ; Teng et al., 2026 ) . Thermal referral has thus been explored to enable more and energy-efficient thermal interfaces ( Wang et al., 2024a ) . 2.2. Vibration dominates thermal referral While the choice of tactile actuators for thermal referral has varied slightly, the vast majority uses mechanical stimulation , with vibration motors (e.g. linear resonant actuators or eccentric rotating mass motors) as the