Enhancement of superconducting stiffness in hybrid superconducting-metallic bilayers

J. E. Ebot, Lorenzo Pizzino, Sam Mardazad, Johannes S. Hofmann, Thierry Giamarchi, Adrian Kantian · 2026

Read Enhancement of superconducting stiffness in hybrid superconducting-metallic bilayers by J. E. Ebot, Lorenzo Pizzino, Sam Mardazad, Johannes S. Hofmann, Thierry Giamarchi, Adrian Kantian (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-28187.txt.

Introduction

Ebot and colleagues test Kivelson's bilayer idea, in which a metal layer lends phase coherence to a pairing layer to boost superconductivity. Doping away from half-filling, into a partially spin-polarised Anderson- or Kondo-lattice regime, breaks the tie between superconducting and density correlations decisively toward superconductivity. Superconducting near-long-range order then survives a small charge gap, in both pairing-limited and stiffness-limited regimes. The results also bear on heavy-fermion materials in magnetic fields.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. E. Ebot, Lorenzo Pizzino, Sam Mardazad, Johannes S. Hofmann, Thierry Giamarchi, Adrian Kantian
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49509
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.28187

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Enhancement of superconducting stiffness in hybrid superconducting-metallic bilayers J. E. Ebot, Lorenzo Pizzino, Sam Mardazad, Johannes S. Hofmann, Thierry Giamarchi, Adrian Kantian Abstract Boosting superconductivity by metallic reservoirs is the essence of Kivelson’s bilayer proposal. One layer provides pairing to the electrons, while the weakly coupled metal provides additional phase coherence to those pairs by mediating extended-range pair-pair coupling. Demonstrating significant and unambiguous performance gains with strong-coupling methods for such set-ups had been difficult. In the present work, we study these systems doped away from half-filling, corresponding to a partially spin-polarized 1D Anderson- or Kondo-lattice. We show that this breaks the coexistence of dominant superconducting and density-density correlations decisively in favour or the former. Consequently, we provide evidence that in this doped regime, superconducting near-long-range order is not precluded by a small charge-gap in the thermodynamic limit, as we have recently shown to be the case at half-filling 10 . We study the complex manner in which the enhancement of superconductivity in the pairing layer depends on the parameters of the metal, and especially that both pairing-limited and stiffness-limited regimes may appear in these systems. In addition to superconducting bilayers, our results are relevant, via a particle-hole transformation, for heavy-fermion Kondo-lattice materials in magnetic fields, as we provide previously lacking insight on the competition between antiferromagnetic and easy-plane magnetism, as well as a route for comprehensive indirect tests of Kivelson’s bilayer proposal well beyond previous capabilities. I Introduction Superconducting systems appeared to be naturally caught between two conflicting aims 11 : maximising the amplitude of the order parameter, and maximising the stiffness of the phase of the paired electrons. A strong pairing amplitude typically results in low pair-phase stiffness, which would limit superconducting performance (the “stiffness-limited” state). Conversely, a high stiffness for the phase of the pairs often results in a weak pairing amplitude, which would then become the factor limiting overall superconducting performance (the “amplitude-limited” state). Boosting superconductivity by means of sidestepping or at least minimizing this competition has gained much interest following Kivelson’s proposal on enhancing the superconductivity in cuprate-layers 16 . The essence of the proposal is that of a heterogeneous, composite system, where the pairing strength is optimized in one subsystem, and the superconducting stiffness is optimized in the other subsystem. The proposal originated from the theoretical work of 11 arguing that an optimal critical temperature T_{c} for superconductivity is obtained in the crossover region between a phase-dominated and a pairing-dominated regime. In practical terms, one can study and realize such heterogeneous systems, both for conventionally and unconventionally mediated pairing, by using a system that consists of a subsystem with some type of intrinsic pairing mechanism (“P-subsystem” in the following), in contact with some type of metallic reservoir (“M-subsystem”, or just “metal”) 16 ; 5 ; 26 ; 17 ; 24 ; 15 ; 8 ; 27 . These setups are most readily envisioned for one-dimensional 8 ; 10 or two-dimensional 5 ; 24 ; 27 (1D or 2D) systems, i.e. where both subsystems have the same dimensionality. But a 1D P-subsystem in contact with a (disordered) 2D metal has also been studied 17 . At the same time, the question as to how a version of Kivelson’s proposal might be realized where both P- and M-subsystems are 3D, and their contact interface is not just a 2D one, is naturally hovering in the background. In the field of reservoir-enhanced superconductivity that was thus established, theoretical work has encountered four interrelated challenges: (1) How does one actually quantify and thus clearly demonstrate any enhancement of superconductivity in the P-subsystem, compared to the optimal cases that can be realized in the baseline of the isolated P-subsystem? Meeting this challenge has turned out to be difficult. Many-body numerics applied to this problem must be of a beyond-mean-field type due to the low-dimensional setting, which makes fluctuations too prominent for mean-field-based techniques. This entails computational resource-requirements that scale significantly with system size. It is thus costly to look for regimes where superconducting properties are boosted significantly by the metal, as this requires attacking a fairly high-dimensional parameter-space, with little analytical guidance available, as discussed in item (3) below. Work on 2D systems has shown that Kivelson’s proposal can impart superconducting stiffness when none is available in the isolated P-subsystem, because it was modelled as a collection of disconnected negative- U centers 5 ; 24 . The metallic layer then allowed the overall system to establish superconducting quasi-order below a finite Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) temperature, T_{\rm BKT} . But so far, there has been no version of Kivelson’s proposal in 2D that evidences a T_{\rm BKT} better than that of the isolated P-subsystem with optimal parameters 12 . However, recent results provide some examples of P-subsystems in a stiffness-limited state (i.e. in the opposite of the amplitude-limited state) for which metallic reservoirs can boost T_{\rm BKT} somewhat beyond the optimal value for a comparable but isolated P-subsystem 27 ; 9 . (2) These latest findings on the 2D version of the Kivelson proposal still come with uncertainties due to the limited system sizes that can be simulated. This restricts the accuracy of any extrapolation to the thermodynamic limit. These problems become more pronounced when trying to move from P-subsystem in a stiffness-limited state (and thus with short coherence lengths) towards ones that are amplitude-limited (i.e. where coherence length could rapidly outgrow numerically feasible system sizes). Our own study of the 1D version of Kivelson’s proposal 8 had in part been motivated by the fact that far larger linear sizes and thus the thermodynamic limit can be reached with modern numerics based either on matrix product states (MPS) 22 or on auxiliary field quantum Monte-Carlo (AFQMC) 2 ; 3 . This allowed us to show unambiguously that 1D systems comprised of a pairing and a metallic chain can far outperform either isolated chains or homogeneous ladders with intrinsic pairing, both inside and outside the stiffness-limited regime. Our approach permitted insight, previously lacking, into how the P- and M-subsystems modify each other’s properties, and how this can lead to significant enhancements of superconducting properties. But these results are still all based on numerics. What remains elusive is quantitative analytical insight and thus the ability to predict - as opposed to painstakingly trying - how traversing the high-dimensional space of microscopic parameters impacts any enhancements of superconductivity. (3) In light of the numerical effort required to study Kivelson’s proposal, especially in 2D and even more so in 3D, complementary analytical treatments with their ability to address the thermodynamic limit are sorely needed. Prior work 5 ; 17 ; 24 , has yielded important insight into how weak coupling between P- and M-subsystem can mediate long-ranged pair-pair coupling within the P-subsystem, which substantially strengthens the superconducting properties. At the same time, these approaches have so far invariably been based on low-order perturbation theory in the coupling between the two subsystems. These approximations left the properties of the metal practically unchanged, and predicted long-range mediated pair-pair coupling 5 ; 17 ; 24 that should be able to drive even 1D P-subsystems to true superconducting long-range order - in apparent contradiction to the Mermin-Wagner theorem (MWT) 14 . Our recent numerical work 8 ; 10 has resolved

Read the complete text