Strong Mpemba Effect Through a Reentrant Phase Transition

Kristian Blom, Doron Benyamin, Uwe Thiele, Oren Raz, Aljaž Godec · 2026

Read Strong Mpemba Effect Through a Reentrant Phase Transition by Kristian Blom, Doron Benyamin, Uwe Thiele, Oren Raz, Aljaž Godec (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-28117.txt.

Introduction

Blom's team shows that temperature quenches across a reentrant phase transition in the antiferromagnetic Ising model produce strong Mpemba effects, direct and inverse, on their own. Quenches ending in the paramagnetic phase leave its slowest mode untouched for paramagnetic starts, giving a strong effect. Antiferromagnetic starts excite it and relax slowly. Varying lattice links confirms the process goes away without reentrance, linking odd relaxation to equilibrium phase pattern.

Catalog record

CREATORKristian Blom, Doron Benyamin, Uwe Thiele, Oren Raz, Aljaž Godec
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63142
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.28117

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Strong Mpemba Effect Through a Reentrant Phase Transition Kristian Blom, Doron Benyamin, Uwe Thiele, Oren Raz, Aljaž Godec Abstract We investigate temperature quenches across the reentrant phase transition of the antiferromagnetic Ising model in a magnetic field and show that the strong direct and inverse Mpemba effects arise when quenches terminate in the paramagnetic phase. These anomalous relaxation phenomena originate from the selective excitation of the slowest relaxation mode, which in the paramagnetic phase is purely staggered. Consequently, quenches starting from the paramagnetic phase have zero overlap with the slow mode and exhibit a strong (inverse) Mpemba effect. Quenches from the antiferromagnetic phase excite the staggered mode and display a slow-relaxation tail. By varying the lattice coordination number we show that the strong Mpemba effect disappears in the absence of reentrance. Our results provide the first demonstration of the strong (inverse) Mpemba effect in the antiferromagnetic Ising model based on the pair-approximation, and establish a link between anomalous relaxation and the equilibrium phase behavior. Systems coupled to a thermal environment eventually attain the temperature of their surroundings in a process called thermal relaxation de Groot and Mazur 1962 . Relaxation close to equilibrium was explained by linear response theory, resting on Onsager’s regression hypothesis Onsager 1931a ; Onsager 1931b ; Kubo et al. 1957 : relaxation after a weak temperature quench is equivalent to that from a spontaneous thermal fluctuation at equilibrium. Far from equilibrium, linear-response arguments fail and anomalous relaxation phenomena emerge, such as the Kovacs effect Bertin et al. 2003 ; Bouchbinder and Langer 2010 ; Santos 2024 ; Lahini et al. 2017 , the Mpemba effect Van Vu and Hayakawa 2025 ; Mpemba and Osborne 1969 ; Teza et al. 2026 ; Lu and Raz 2017 ; Klich et al. 2019 ; Kumar et al. 2022 ; Teza et al. 2023 ; Degünther and Seifert 2022 and the thermal relaxation asymmetry Lapolla and Godec 2020a ; Van Vu and Hasegawa 2021 ; Manikandan 2021 ; Meibohm et al. 2021 ; Dieball et al. 2023 ; Ibáñez et al. 2024 ; Dieball and Godec 2026 . The Mpemba effect refers to a class of phenomena where a system initially farther from thermal equilibrium relaxes faster than one initiated closer to it Van Vu and Hayakawa 2025 ; Mpemba and Osborne 1969 ; Teza et al. 2026 ; Lu and Raz 2017 ; Klich et al. 2019 ; Kumar et al. 2022 ; Teza et al. 2023 ; Baity-Jesi et al. 2019 . One of these classes can be understood within Markovian dynamics in terms of the spectral properties: initial states with a suppressed projection onto the slowest relaxation mode equilibrate faster Lu and Raz 2017 . This framework unifies the standard and inverse Mpemba effects and enables quantitative characterizations, such as the strong Mpemba effect and the Mpemba index Lu and Raz 2017 ; Klich et al. 2019 . Extensions to quantum systems Zhang et al. 2025 ; Joshi et al. 2024 ; Nava and Fabrizio 2019 ; Ares et al. 2025 ; Summer et al. 2026 ; Aharony Shapira et al. 2024 and experimental demonstrations Biswas et al. 2020 ; Jeng 2006 ; Lasanta et al. 2017 ; Kumar and Bechhoefer 2020 ; Kumar et al. 2022 further highlight the breadth of the phenomenon (for a recent account see Teza et al. 2026 ). Among the various systems that showcase the Mpemba effect, spin systems are quite unique, since they demonstrate many types of different phenomena: Direct and inverse effects have been demonstrated in spin-glass systems Lu and Raz 2017 ; Mpemba effects across first-order phase transitions have been found in the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model Zhang and Hou 2022 , the spin-1 Nagle–Kardar model Li and Hou 2026 , and the Ising model with a staggered magnetic field Yang and Hou 2020 ; and numerical simulations have revealed Mpemba effects in ferromagnetic systems Chatterjee et al. 2024 ; Ghosh et al. 2025 . Particularly relevant for the present work is the antiferromagnetic Ising model in a uniform magnetic field. In this system, nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic interactions favor staggered order, whereas the external field favors parallel alignment, producing a competition that gives rise to a phase boundary between antiferromagnetic and paramagnetic phases. This phase boundary has been extensively studied using exact arguments, series expansions, Monte Carlo simulations, and analytical approximations Sauer and Temperley 1940 ; Garrett 1951 ; Ziman 1951 ; Kasteleijn 1956 ; Vives et al. 1997 ; Müller-Hartmann and Zittartz 1977 ; Binder and Landau 1980 ; Fisher 1960a ; Fisher 1960b . Within this antiferromagnetic setting, an Mpemba effect through a second-order phase transition was shown in Landau theory Holtzman and Raz 2022 , while final-relaxation Mpemba effects of various kinds were demonstrated in mean-field Klich et al. 2019 , one-dimensional Teza et al. 2023 ; Lu and Raz 2017 , and two-dimensional Gal and Raz 2020 antiferromagnetic systems. The competition between staggered ordering and field-induced alignment also makes the antiferromagnetic Ising model a natural setting for reentrant phase behavior , in which increasing antiferromagnetic order upon cooling is followed by a return to disorder at lower temperatures. Such reentrance has been observed in magnetic compounds Aruga Katori et al. 1992 ; Glazman and Ioselevich 1990 ; Fujii et al. 1985 , spin-glass systems Gingras and Sørensen 1998 ; Thomas and Katzgraber 2011 , frustrated Ising lattices Morita 1986 ; Kitatani et al. 1985 , and superconductors Knafo et al. 2025 . In the nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic Ising model on the square lattice, however, the phase boundary remains monotonic Müller-Hartmann and Zittartz 1977 ; Binder and Landau 1980 ; Pomares et al. 2026 , whereas approximate treatments of higher-connectivity or tree-like lattices predict reentrant critical lines Burley 1961 ; Shirley 1972 ; Hui 1988 ; Monroe 1994 ; Neto and de Sousa 2004 ; Neto et al. 2006 . Together, these results suggest that lattice connectivity is a central factor controlling whether reentrance can occur, and they motivate a closer examination of how this equilibrium feature shapes relaxation phenomena such as the Mpemba effect. Here we show that reentrant phase transitions provide a natural mechanism for anomalous relaxation in the antiferromagnetic Ising model. Using the Bethe–Guggenheim (pair) approximation Ziman 1951 ; Kasteleijn 1956 ; Katsura and Takizawa 1974 ; Burley 1961 ; Huckaby and Huckaby 2005 ; Blom et al. 2023 ; Blom 2023 , we analyze single spin-flip Glauber dynamics on lattices with varying coordination number and demonstrate the emergence of the strong (inverse) Mpemba effect for temperature quenches through a reentrant phase transition. The reentrant phase diagram allows two quenches in the same temperature direction toward a paramagnetic state, one starting in the paramagnetic and the other in the antiferromagnetic phase. As a result, their coupling to the slowest mode is qualitatively different. By varying the coordination number we show that the strong Mpemba effects disappears when the phase diagram becomes monotonic and reentrance is absent. Our results therefore establish a direct connection between anomalous relaxation and the equilibrium phase diagram. Lattice setup and dynamics. —We consider the Ising model on a Bethe lattice with coordination number z in the presence of a uniform magnetic field, described by the Hamiltonian \mathcal{H}(\boldsymbol{\sigma})=-J\sum_{\langle ij\rangle}\sigma_{i}\sigma_{j}-H\sum_{i}\sigma_{i}, (1) where \boldsymbol{\sigma}=\{\sigma_{1},\dots,\sigma_{N}\} with

Read the complete text